Understanding Stalinism's history
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Tom Rigby continues our debate on the nature of Stalinism with a repl to Hillel Ticktin, editor of Critique The pages of SO remain open for contributions to this vital debate.
illel Ticktin's contribution the debate on the nature of Stalinism is only to be welcomed.
Over the last 18 years the Critique comrades have provided an invaluable service both in the form of their detailed analysis of the demise of Stalinism and in reprinting such works as Rakovsky's classic "The five year plan in crisis"
However, I must challenge Hillel's contention (SO 508) that "under Stalinism, unlike capitalism, there was no fundamental economic law regulating the system" The origin, existence, development and death of Stalinism talinism was most definitely development. Trotsky outlined this very clearly in 1936 in the "Revolution Betrayed"
This law was not a general abstract law but one that was historically specific to the Stalinist system, a law which regulated its origin, existence, development and death as a social organism.
Obviously, this law is not analogous to the laws of capitalist development, but why should it be? Stalinism is not capitalism.
Nor is it an exclusively economic law but again why should it be as under Stalinism politics and economics are fused Let us call this law, Trotsky's basic planning.
"The progressive role of the Soviet bureaucracy coincides with the period devoted to introducing into the Soviet Union the most important elements of capitalist technique.
"The rough work of borrowing, imitating, transplanting and grafting, was accomplished on the bases laid down by the revolution. There was, thus far, no question of any new word in the sphere of technique, science or art. It is possible to build gigantic factories according to a ready-made Western pattern by bureaucratic command — although, to be sure, at triple the normal cost. But the farther you go, the more the economy runs into the problem of quality, which sips out of the hands of a bureaucracy like a shadow. The Soviet products are as though branded with the grey label of indifference. Under a nationalised economy, quality demands a democracy of producers and consumers, freedom of criticism and initiative - conditions incompatible with a totalitarian regime of fear, lies and flattery."
If we pause for a moment to digest Trotsky's argument we can see:
1) Stalinism can copy a given level of technology "but at triple the cost"
2) It cannot however solve the question of quality, of innovation, as there is no workers' democracy. surplus product. The Soviet produces arths though branded with the grey label of indilference" . Surely this is an analysis [in 1936] of Hillel's "defective surplus product""?
4) Note, Trotsky is here providing us with an historical law that encompasses Stalinism's present and future. He is outlining a tendency to collapse due to the basic truth that on the basis of modern technology an effective plan requires a thoroughgoing workers democracy.
Trotsky then goes to enlarge on this point:
*Behind the question of quality stands a more complicated and grandiose problem which may be comprised in the concept of independent, technical and cultural creation. The ancient philosopher said that strife is the father of all things. No new value can be created where a free conflict of ideas is impossible. To be sure, a revolutionary dictatorship means by its very essence strict limitations of freedom. But for that very reason epochs of revolution have never been directly favourable to cultural creation: they have only cleared the arena for it. The dicbe a dictatorship. The socialist culture will flourish only in proportion to the dying away of the state. In that simple and unshakeable historic law is contained the death sentence of the present regime in the Soviet Union. August 1991 Soviet democracy is not the demand of an abstract policy, still less an abstract moral. It has become a life and death need of the country."'l Stripped of the inconsistencies involved in Trotsky's later version of the "degenerated workers' state" formula with which it sits idea in ensolutely vital to an understanding of Stalinism.
Surely, Hillel would agree that his description of the contradiction between the laws of organisation and of self-interest and his earlier theorisations constitute a development and deepening of Trotsky's basic insight, and also of the parallel work engaged in by Rakovsky, rather than a new line of reasoning altogether?
A state with no class character?
think that the core issue in this discussion is that Hillel's notion of the Nomenklatura as an elite or 'an actual ruling group and a potential ruling class' does not provide a convincing and theoretically sound alternative to either the inconsistencies of Trotsky's formula — "degenerated workers' state" — or to the question Trotsky posed to those who reject his formula: if the state is neither bourgeois or proletarian, what then is the class character of state In other words, is the most brutal police regime in human history not a class state at all?
To reply as Hillel does to this question that the bureaucracy is 'an elite' with an unspecified class status or alternatively that *The USSR has mutated from a society in transition to socialism, so that it is now in the limbo of history" is simply to evade and sidestep the basic question of historical perspective posed by Chris Arthur at the start of this discussion.
What's more, the status of being 'in limbo" hardly recommends itself as a precise scientific definition, nor does it exclude the possibility that the bureaucracy is a class. Marx specifically talked of Asiatic despotism as a class society "vegetating in the teeth of time"
The confusion is compounded by Hillel's comment on Mandel: "My object... has never been to simply attack him but to put forward an alternative view based on the same theoretical foundations". Perhaps Hillel could clarify this point.
To complicate the picture further, what Hillel actually describes, labels apart, is a new collective bureaucratic ruling class, arising out of a unique series of circumstances with its own self-limiting history. Is there a social surplus?
urely Hillel puts far too much Son the burden of his analysis ne explanatory power of the concept 'Mode of Production'. This is very marked for instance in his polemic with Bettelheim.
As a result he loses sight of the significance of what is most basic to an understanding of classes, the state and modes of production: the question of the control over the appropriation of the surplus product. By this change of focus and inversion of Marx's method, Hillel erects a purely formal and arbitrary barrier in the way of understanding the bureaucracy as a class.
So, as a result, Hillel's treatment of the 'precise form' in which the surplus is extracted and the significance of this is in fact superficial.
Hillel's basic argument is that the specific form in which the Nomenklatura appropriate the surplus product is so limited that it is meaningless to call them a class. "They have only a limited degree of control over the surplus product. For that reason, they do not constitute a class. "Why? Because the workers continue to have a negative control over their own labour process. As a result, the ruling group could not "plan the system. As a further result they were and remain an unstable grouping"
But surely Hillel would not deny that there is a surplus, however imperfect the Soviet product may be, no matter how many "defective use values" have been produced? Or that the nomenklatura engage in a struggle to appropriate it? (Remember, if there is no surplus product then logically we must arrive at the absurd conclusion that Stalinism is a pre-class society.)
I think that the correct way to present the history of Stalinism is as 'The origin, existence development and death' of a particular party/state bureaucratic ruling class doomed precisely because it was incapable of establishing for itself a stable form of appropriation of the surplus product.
This is a lot less contradictory than saying it was not a class because it developed no stable mode of production.
The absence of a stable mode of production is thus simply an effect of the nature bureaucratic class rule. Hillel's snapshot of Stalinism - frozen in its moribund Brezhnevite phase of terminal decline — simply obscures the history of the whole period from the late twenties onwards. A history that involves both development and then — after the slackening of the terror -decline.
A parallel system to capitalism?
Be can now turn to the question of whether or not Stalinism was a limited parallel to capitalism or as Hillel argues: "In converting to capitalism, practically all machinery will have to be replaced with market-type machinery. Hence it is not even a parallel road to capitalism. It is not even a footpath"*
I would not doubt that a large measure of
truth is contained in this argument from Hillel but it is beside the point to an understanding of Stalinism's place in history.
Let me explain. If Stalinism is to be replaced by capitalism or democratic working class power as Hillel seems to be saying in Critique 23, it was not, by definition, 'post-capitalist' as the majority of post-Trotsky "Trotskyists" believed [ie. Mandel].
Thus the Critique comrades and those of us in AWL/SO agree on what Stalinism was not.
Further, notwithstanding Hillel's strictures, if capitalism is restored in the USSR then terror, forced collectivisation and industrialisation were in historic perspective but a vile and wasteful bloodletting to pave the way for capitalism and the market.
And finally, if the workers replace Stalinism with socialist freedom, then the system was not simply "a self-aborting monstrosity" as Chris Arthur so vividly put it — but rather performed the same task of "accumulating its own gravediggers" | as capitalism performs.
Labels, name tags, theory and the fate of the Left Opposition Pliscussion is that both Hillet and! art of the problem with this Chris appear to be attacking a theory or developed school of analysis which they call 'Bureaucratic Collectivism' that simply does not. actually exist!
As far as I am aware, bureaucratic collectivism' evolved into a general name tag with which to describe more or less any theory that saw the Stalinist bureaucracy as a noncapitalist exploiting class. Underneath this common name tag radically different substantial theories developed.
Meanwhile, the orthodox Trotskyists used Trotsky's refusal to call the bureaucracy a class for a purpose [that of glorifying 'progressive' Stalinism] that Trotsky would have revolted against.
Obviously, this raises again what it means for Hillel to say he shares the same theoretical foundation as Mandel?
If we are to move forward from this sorry state that the revolutionary left finds itself in today, Marxist theory needs to be clarified by both analysing the reality of present day Stalinism and capitalism and by returning to some of the unfinished work of the past. Rakovsky, and the Left Mensheviks understanding of "planlessness' , Trotsky's evolving prognosis and Shachtman's merciless critique of 'orthodox' Trotskyism all have something vital to say to us today.
Perhaps most of all, we have to realise that the greatest defeat of all that our movement faced this century was its failure from the early "30s onwards to come to terms scientifically with what Stalinism represented.
Fundamentally this was the product of the elimination of an entire revolutionary generation.
If we are to rebuild an international Marxist left that can even aspire to the levels reached by the Left Opposition in the late '20s, never mind attempt to go beyond it, it is vital that all obsession with secondary questions of labels and definitions are abandoned for the development of a substantive analysis of Stalinism and its place in history.
There can be no 'Chinese wall' between different Marxist schools attempting to analyse Stalinism - between 'bureaucratic collectivism' and the analysis developed by the Critique comrades — because so many of the sources are the same.
After all, it was Christian Rakovsky to whom the Critique comrades are so endebted and who analysed in rough outline both planlessness and "The systematic production of defective products" who put forward this characterisation of the Stalinist bureaucracy.
A characterisation pregnant with meaning and with a clear tendency towards an understanding of the bureaucracy as a class:
*"Under our very eyes, there has been formed, and is still being formed, a large class of rulers which has its own interior groupings, multiplied by means of premeditated cooption, direct or indirect [bureaucratic promotion, fictitious system of election]. The basic suport of this original class is a sort, an original sort, of private property, namely the posession of state power. The bureaucracy 'posesses the state as private property' wrote Marx (Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Law")".
Scan page 15
lan Murch overturns right wingers 2 to 1 majority Socialist Organiser No. 509 page 15
----- pull-quotes -----
tatorship of the proletariat opens a wider scope to human genius the more it ceases to