Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

City of decay

Socialist Organiser no. 509, 29 November 1991 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 1,159 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Roosevelt's "good reason": Pearl Harbour, 7 December 1941 "Timewatch" ", BBC2, Wednesday "City of Hope"

The title of John Sayle's new film "City of Hope" is ironic; there's precious little hope for anybody living in his fictionalised New Jersey city.

It's a city on the verge of bankruptcy and decay, run by an Italian-dominated political machine steeped in the politics of patronage and kickbacks. Everybody's corrupt, some in bigger ways than others, of course, but everybody's got their own angle on things. Graft greases the wheels.

Nick Rinaldi, whose father is a big building contractor and slum landlord, hates his life. At the start of the movie, he quits his job on his father's site but it's hardly a positive move. He takes drugs, he drifts, he finds a girl, but he isn't going anywhere. He knows what he's against, but not what he's for. He's totally cynical.

His friends are pretty much the same, a bunch of losers who turn to petty crime for the money and status the real world denies them. When they're caught, and Nick is implicated, it sets off a tragic train of events. As the price for Nick's release, the Mayor puts pressure on Rinaldi to torch the slum buildings he owns and to make way for the Japanese-financed condominium development he and his City Hall cronies want to build - more kickbacks for them. The fact that black and Hispanic families will be made homeless by the blaze - and that some will die — means nothing to the Mayor. He can only see the Japanese money coming in, money that will help him in his upcoming Senate run.

Other plots are woven into this story of corruption. One, the story of Wynn, an honest black councillor, offers at least some hope. He manages to overcome the divisiveness in the black community (the black Muslims versus the rest) and weld them into an angry fighting unit, ready to demand their rights.

But there's not much hope and not much optimism in much of the rest. Angela, the single mother Nick takes up with, is let down again. She, and her disabled son, will have to struggle on alone.

Sayles has captured the hopelessness of life in American cities, a world where there is nothing to aim for. For boys like Nick, everything is tainted and compromised. They grow up in a world with no positive role models, and with no future. They slide into drugs or petty crime as a way of getting kicks, but it's a slide, not a choice. If they're lucky, their parents pull them out by leaning on politicians for favours. If they're not, they end up trapped in the system, or mad, like the crazed character, Asteroid, who roams in and out of the film, ranting and raving.

Sayles has also caught the dogeat-dog world of American community politics, in which italians help the Italians, the Irish help the Irish, and so on, each community fighting for its own members, against all the other communities, because they fear there won't be enough for everyone to share.

There is enough to share, more than enough, but with blacks pitted against whites, Hispanics against blacks, the fight is futile and circular, never directed against the real causes of poverty and inequality. Periscope Everyone has two reasons for what they do: a good reason and the real reason.

Capitalist cabals and governments have their reasons: democracy demands of them that they also find good reasons. Thus in the recent Gull War, George Bush's real reasons for war had little to do with his stated reasons.

Duplicity and lies and bourgeois double-dealing are as essential to our political affairs as gold, oil and oxygen.

US President Franklin D Roosevelt' "City of Hope" is sometimes schematic, and there are scenes and characters which don't quite come off, but it's the truest evocation of the jungle and decay that is present-day American urban life in a film that I can think of. It's intelligent, and it's got something to say. Maybe Sayles has no answers, but at least he knows what the problems are. That's a start.

Tre.

4 December "good reason" for war with Japan was Japan's "surprise" attack on Pearl Harbour, the US naval and air force base in Hawaii. The real reasons were different: imperialist rivalry.

Essentially the US was the aggressor. Six months before Pearl Harbour Roosevelt had slapped crippling economic sanctions on Japan. And even "Pearl Harbour" was no surprise. Roosevelt - who won the 1940 election on a pledge to keep America out of war, as Lyndon Johnson won the 1964 election on a pledge to avoid war in Vietnam - let it happen to gain an unanswerable "good reason" for stampeding the people of the US into war.

"Timewatch" tells the story. the BBC's best statistic!

It would be silly to deny that huge numbers of children do not get the education they deserve. Socialists can't be satisfied with the reading standards reached by many pupils. The government's attempts to blame progressive teaching are, however, a smokescreen.

Parents are becoming more and more aware of the devastation wreaked in schools by the government - the SATS are very unpopular, the shortage of teachers in specialist subjects, the lack books, the time now spent saving money rather than teaching will affect standards.

In that atmosphere Kenneth Clarke has clearly decided to try to exploit parental fears and use proaccusations made Panorama were, by any standards, unserious: Roger Scruton put all problems down to *people from the 60s" and advocated the closure of all teacher-training colleges.

A lone parent in Leeds objected to a progressive and very popular school "because too much time was devoted to less able pupils". Kenneth Clarke was asked why, if standards had fallen, the Tory government of the last 12 years was not to blame, and he feebly insisted that left-wing LEAs, left-wing teachers unions and "people from the 60s" had obstructed his reforms.

The only venture into a school which actually used "progressive" teaching was revealing. Chapel Allerton primary school in Leeds is over-subscribed surely the ultimate verdict for this government. The truth is that almost everyone who has had anything to do with teaching children since comprehensive schooling was introduced is repelled by the government's attempts to return to selection and elitism.

They are deliberately running down state comprehensive schools to justify their prejudice. They are also frightened of some of the good practices in schools, frightened of what education can do. One of the most revealing comments on Panorama was made when Clarke was asked directly what was. wrong with "progressive teachers": "They're trying to be too clever", he blurted.

Ah, so that's the problem with education, we can't have ordinary people spending their time in schools trying to be clever: we might decide to create a rational, well-funded education service!

Scan page 14

Socialist Organiser No. 509 page 14 IISCUSSION

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 509

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →