Law, labour and "union capitalisı
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
niser of the 1930s speaking to the longshoremen of New York. Os, American labour won the right to organise, and then lost it side are you on? - trying be for labor when it's flat its back" by Thomas Geoghegan. (New York; Farrar, Straus and Giroux), 1991.
his book takes a uniquely American view of of the American labor movement. It is written by a union advocate - a Harvard law school graduate, no less, who, by income and profession is an outsider to the union movement.
But it also embodies a social sensibility - an identification with the underdog, the oppressed and the down — or soon to be down - and out of the American industrial heartland, that is all but extinct in this land of the leveraged buyout.
Geoghegan is, in short, throwback to the idealistic social liberalism of the early CIO days. For him, the journey began reluctantly in the late 1960s. Not a new, or any other brand of leftist in college, he was cajoled against his better instincts to poll-watch as dissident miners tried to recapture their union from its murderously corrupt leadership With the victory of the rank and file, Geoghegan signed on as a staff attorney. From there, he eventually established a new base in Chicago, where in due course he threw himself into the struggles of teamsters, steel workers, nurses and carpenters. Baedeker's tour of the American rust belt — of labor beaten down by economic decline, capitalist laws and self-serving labor bureaucracies.
Geoghegan's tone is one of hardboiled moralism, suspicious of ideologies, yet wide-eyed American in his embrace of quick-fix schemes. For starters, he understands as well as any socialist - and better than a good many that there exists an indissoluble bond between democracy and solidarity.
This is a lesson even understood by good bourgeois democrats. Scrupulous concern for the trappings of fair-play electoralism within capitalist democracies is a powerful social glue that binds the working class to the "national mandate". In the American case, the failure to extend these concerns to the union movement represents also, in a cnical fashion, a bourgeois devotion to the sanctity of its own institutions. For capitalist democracy works best where working class solidarity is undermined.
And this is to no small degree the purpose of the very American law regulating union "democracy" , the Landrum-Griffin act. This act is rightly dismissed by Geoghegan as a joke. But it's more than just a bad joke.
It expressly approves of indirect elections of national officers through delegate conventions.
These delegate conventions are in turn composed of ex officio union officers. No attempt need be made to inform the rank and file as to when the elections occur, or to involve them in national campaigns.
And while local officers must be directly elected by the rank and file, there is no mechanism enforcing an honest ballot. The act does not provide for a neutral agency, and the Labor Department has no interest in intervening on behalf of rank-and-file democracy. Well then, what else should one expect from a capitalist state?
Geoghegan — good lawyer and true-believer that he is — would like the US Congress to fix the problems of American labor. How? By providing for an outside neutral agency to count ballots; by requiring a rank-and-file vote for all officers; by giving all bona fide candidates a copy of the membership lists; and by providing "public funding" from the union treasury for all candidates.
These are of course, excellent suggestions and should be core elements in every insurgency strug gle within the union movement. They are just unlikely to be on the legislative agenda of the Congress. For while the ruling class may sell us the hangman's rope, we should not expect them to build the scaffold and personally offer to test the integrity of the instrument.
"For the sorry state of American labour is not just attributable to the lack of internal democracy or Ronald Reagan. In the 1930s unions were every bit as authoritarian, and far more racist and sexist than they are today."
And Geoghegan's peculiar mix of cynicism and idealism leads him to other farflung social tributaries. He casts a jaundiced glance at socialism - few prospects, even less appeal. But "union capitalism" through pension fund control - now there's a vision packing a true wallop! This sort of thing leaves socialists rubbing their eyes in disbelief.
But then one remembers that Geoghegan believes that "union capitalism" is required because private capitalists lack the imagination, energy or vision to run a productive society. They want to make profits, it is true, but wish to skip the process of production itself in their pursuit.
They have forsaken innovation for papershuffling with economic chaos, ruined communities, broken workers and a plague of lawyers the predictable results. Traditional capitalists are thus no longer fit to run society, therefore... Oh well, only in America.
If Geoghegan is a little mushy on social theory, he is right on target when it comes to the current status of American labor law, and not just Landrum-Griffin. For the sorry state of American labor is not just attributable to the lack of internal democracy or Ronald Reagan. In the 1930s, unions were every bit as authoritarian, and far more racist and sexist than they are today. And Reagan is not the first dyed-in-thewool reactionary of the post-war era.
No, the lack of dynamism stems all the way back to when American workers lost - for all intents and purposes — the right to organise. In fact, they only held that right briefly. The "Big Bang" of the labor movement in the 1930s was detonated by the Norris-LaGuardia act, which stripped the courts of their right to hear cases involving strikes. "After the NorrisLaGuardia law, there was no law at all. No injunctions. No Us army to enforce the injunctions. Nothing. It was a total vacuum. It was in this total vacuum that the Big Bang occurred"
Because there were no rules, everything was fair game. No one had to establish their credentials as an "appropriate bargaining unit" There were no laws to prevent the steelworkers or autoworkers from mass picketing, secondary strikes of neutral employers or sit-downs. The 1935 Wagner act then compounded this by sanctioning the actual, affirmative right to unionise.
This was the context in which the modern Democratic Party was reborn. Still a bourgeois party resting on urban machines and Southern Bourbons, the Democrats were now capable of commanding the loyalties of the working class, while containing their aspirations.
The precise dynamics by which the working class was held in check within the Party by Southern racists, is no longer operative - a casualty of the civil rights movement. But before the civil rights movement could undermine Jim Crow, the labor movement had already been defanged by the TaftHartley act of 1947.
This act made illegal everything that the CIO did in the 1930s. It is nicknamed in American labor, the Taft-Hartley Slave Labor act. The Democrats' platforms always promise to abolish it, the Democratic Congress - even when combined with Democratic Presidents -never bothered to.
Beyond this is the outright politicisation of the National Labor Relations Board. A product of the Wagner act, the NLRB is charged with investigating unfair labor practices arising from union disputes and elections. The vast majority of unfair labor practice charges involve claims of illegal firings for union activities. There was a time, perhaps more in mythology, when the NLRB was - as one of Geoghegan's mentors put it -"neutral in favor of the workers' =200 HI H But that was before the Reagan cultural revolution. Today the NLRB is staffed with right wing kooks. It in effect oversees a massive wave of civil disobedience on the part of the employers which began to swell in the 1960s and 1970s.
*Breaking the law, ie. firing people, is absurdly cheap. The best dea: in America, in cold business terms.
*There is a famous study... that says a union on average will increase a company's wage bill by 20%. So let us say, at plant X there are 50 workers who make $25,000 a year. A union at this plant would cost an employer, then, about $250,000 a year... And the penalty for violating the Wagner act is... what, $3,000 a crack? Paid one time only, three or four years from now?
"An employer who didn't break the law would have to be what economists call an irrational firm' ."
It was recently reported in the Multinational Monitor that from 1982 to September 1990, approximately 4,000 charges were filed against the 500 largest companies in the US. The NLRB found that unfair labor practices had occured in only 2% of the cases. 37% were dismissed without investigation and an additional 25% were withdrawn.
That is why organising in the private sector has virtually stopped. As related by Geoghegan, "unions can still win a special set of circumstances: when the employer does not oppose or delay the election, or commit any legal violations, the unions currently win over 90% of the time"
Who could dispute Geoghegan's conclusion that union organising faces no tougher restrictions this side of the Third World than right here in the USA?
Geoghegan seeks a legal revolution, the creation of a level playing field in the class struggle. Readers of Socialist Organiser undoubtedly have something else in mind. Don't let this put you off. Geoghegan has a lot to say and he says it well.
----- pull-quotes -----
Book Barry Finger reviews "Wh