Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A fu view of the left and

Socialist Organiser no. 509, 29 November 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · Patrick Murphy · about 705 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

recent weeks the Oissue of left-wing anti- YCE Zionism/anti-semitism has been dealt with in a highly commendable way by this paper.

The myth of Nazi-Zionist collaboration is one aspect of this issue.

The far-right in Britain accuses Zionists of collaborating with the British security services for the purpose of achieving a Jewish state (by creating the "myth" of the Holocaust).

Sections of the left accuse Zionists of collaborating with the Nazis for exactly the same reason. The parallel is striking and both are sickening and sinister myths with phenomenally frightening implications for Jews all over the world today.

Neither argument deserves the respect of an intellectual response.

If it is to be given, however, then the attack should be fully comprehensive - a definite failure of SO's recent well-intentioned approach.

I draw attention to a few of many points which may have been overlooked:

(1) It was in fact the Mufti of Jerusalem, with the political aim of preventing Zionist settlement in the area, who conspired with Hitler and the Nazis. This is not an absurd attempt to paint the Palestinians with the Nazi collaboration brush. It is, however, a clear, undeniable and relevant historical fact.

(2) The idea of Nazism having any sort of partnership with Zionism shows a fundamental misunderstanding of Nazism. The idea that the most virulently organised anti-semitic movement the world has ever seen could possibly compromise with a Jewish movement or that it could possibly be in Hitler's interests to do so during the war is totally absurd.

(3) Certainly a number of individual Jews did collaborate with the Nazis, as did individual socialists and trade unionists. This concept of the Jews sharing collective guilt and blame for the actions of a few is a classic historical strand of anti-semitism. For example, the Nazis blamed Jews generally for Communism and Capitalism as individual Jews, such as Marx and Rothschild were prominent figures in both movements.

(4) There also exists a huge paradox in the argument. On the one hand we are asked to believe that before the war the Zionist movement was a small insignificant group. Yet at the same time we are asked to believe that the Zionists were powerful and significant enough to conspire with the most powerful country in Europe at the time.

This is also parallel with another long standing classical anti-semitic strand - the Jew, on the one hand a vermin-like inferior being, yet at the same time powerful enough to be dominating the world.

I have only touched upon a small number of points, all of which in isolation crush this evil and poisonous myth. I hope it has roadened the scope of the argu ment for those who choose to intellectually confront and debate its purporters.

Anthony Hermer Anti-Racism Officer Manchester University Labour Club

Scan page 13

THE CULTURAL FRON City of Hope: a true evocation of the jungle and decay of American urban life Socialist Organiser No. 509 page 13 The long march of medicrity is at an end"

says John Major. "The progressive theorists in education have had their day."

Education, like health, is a voteloser for the government but they intend to turn the tide and their big idea is based on a double lie. The first is that educational standards have fallen disastrously in the last 20 years and the second is that the blame lies with trendy, progressive educational methods.

As BBC's Panorama showed last Monday, the case for these claims is very thin. The statistics were very few and always either misleading or plain wrong. "One quarter of seven year olds are unable to read" quoted the BBC report; but this was a newspaper summary of recent SATS results with proved nothing of the sort.

The results actually showed that about 50% of seven year olds had the expected reading ability, 25% were above average and 25% failed to reach the expected targets. In other words, the result shows a fairly normal distribution curve - they certainly don't show that one quarter of seven year olds can't read. Even more important, they do not prove that standards have fallen as there is no comparison made with previous years. And this was

----- pull-quotes -----

be too clever Television

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 509

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →