Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The left and Labour's youth, 1963-65 "New leadership" and irrelevance

Socialist Organiser no. 509, 29 November 1991 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 4,159 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

THE Page Thre © REVOLUTIONY In this article - one of a series Jack Cleary shows how the Healyites (Keep Left|SLL/WRP) in the mid-1960s pioneered ideas now taken up by Militant and the SWP The Healyites were the biggest left group in Labour's then-lively youth movement, outstripping Young Guard (the future IS/SWP) and 1963-64: leadership n January 1963, a 1200 strong rally for jobs assembled in Smith Square (where Labour Party headquarters was situated) as the rump YS NC was meeting. Under this pressure, four of the remaining eight members resigned (three of them were Young Guard supporters). They had showed no signs of resigning before the rally! Two others walked out, without resigning. Of the 1962 NC three had now been expelled, four had resigned, and two had walked out of the meeting, leaving an NC of two.

Outside the Scarborough YS conference in Easter 1963 there was again a big Keep Left demonstration. The YS registered a small advance: there were 365 delegates present, and 769 registered branches.

The drift of the Healy tendency is illustrated by the fact that at the beginning of 1963 Roger Protz took out a writ in the High Court seeking to have made null and void the NEC decision making anyone associated with Keep Left ineligible for Labour Party membership! He also sought a High Court declaration restoring him to membership of St Pancras North Labour Party. Psychologically, this would be rationalised by Keep Left supporters then — as by Militant supporters in the early 1980s when Militant attempted to rely on the courts to save them from the right wing of the Labour Party — as using the right wing's friends in the bourgeois law courts against them. But it was a breach of the principle of keeping the bourgeois state out of the affairs of the labour movement. Any policy for maintaining an integration of revolutionaries in the labour movement which depends on the help of the law courts is fantastic — as Militant found out in the 1980s.

But something of decisive importance now occurred: Keep Left won a majority on the NC. Keep Left supporters took seven of the 11 NC seats. Young Guard took one. It was the opening of a new phase of YS history, though much confusion reigned. Political confusion was manifested still. The conference which gave the Healyites the leadership of the YS came close to voting through the official Labour Party document, Signposts for the Sixties. Conference passed a Young Guard resolution from Hackney against all H-bombs and all military alliances. This was voting for Young Guard policy, while giving control to those who deTHESE ST WOMES GEORGE PERRY L.LEE Years after they left the Labour Party the Healyites were left MPs fight" Wilson. Any SLler bold enough to ask smack in the chops and be expelled as a they combined "making the left MPs fight and his "Red Guards". nounced such policies as treason to the "workers' state" and political scabbery!

The new YS NC immediately launched a big official YS campaign on youth unemployment. The Tory government was heavily discredited by now, and tottering towards defeat in 1964.

Harold Wilson, a former Labour left, had succeeded Gaitskell as Labour leader early in 1963 and the Tribunite left was conciliated. The Labour Party regime would now swing slowly towards internal tolerance and liberalism. The rule of the stone-age right wingers, of the Gaitskell sect - the future SPers of 1981 — was over. It would be 25 years before a purging intolerant regime like the Gaitskell regime returned to the Labour Party.

The YS NC organised another big rally and lobby of Parliament for 11 February 1964. But the YS was not exactly thriving. The Brighton conference, at Easter 1964, had 347 delegates claiming to represent 25,000 members organised in 722 branches (this would include "social" elements in Keep Left branches). It was small enough after four years.

Again conference rejected support for Signposts for the Sixties, opposed immigration controls, and called for nationalisation of the basic industries under workers' control. Again a Keep Left majority of 7 out of 11 was returned for the National Committee.

Chairman John Robertson announced at conference that he would shortly be expelled, for he had been caught red-handed selling Keep Left in a rural area of Scotland... Brighton was to be the last official YS conference for 18 months. By the time of the next conference, the YS had split and the Labour Party had reorganised its remaining youth with a new constitution and even a new name.

goes for a purge, Keep Left goes for a split n 1964, for the second year running Keep Left had the majority on the YS NC. But the Labour Party bureaucracy stood in the way of developing the YS on left politics, and the imminent General Election spurred on the bureaucracy to settle with Keep Left.

They began to pick off the leaders of Keep Left. John Robertson was duly expelled. Dave Ashby, his replacement as chairman of the YS, quickly followed. And now Keep Left gave increasing signs of being willing for a break with the Labour Party.

At the time of the Easter 1964 YS conference there were already whispers about plans for a "Young Marxist Alliance' which could throw off the Labour Party shackles and go on to build a real mass youth movement. Initially Keep Left denied such a perspective. Events, however, had their logic. Transport House attacked relentlessly: an election was looming and the YS with its militant and distinct policies could not be allowed to "embarass" the leaders of the Labou Party. Keep Left was more and mor isolated, and more and more the hard cor looked for salvation to recruiting raw youth The parallel with Militant in Scotland at the height of the poll tax campaign is striking.

"Social" branches had originally been : valuable technique for starting to draw work ing class youth to a political YS. Increasingly under pressure of the witch-hunt, the! became a substitute for and an alternative te any politics other than the current, often ar bitrarily selected, "campaign" (fight thi Tories, defend John Robertson) or the cur rent demonstration. The turnover of youth always a feature of Keep Left, increaser dramatically.

The hysterical atmosphere inside the lef burst out at the Keep Left meeting at the 196conference in a violent harangue by Johi Robertson in which he said Young Guari were nothing but "scabs" and that those whe were not 100% with Keep Left were 100% against them. "Get out of our way or we'l go over your bodies", he warned, and repeated the warning. Scuffles between Y and KL supporters followed.

Roger Protz, Keep Left's editor, resigner after that meeting. Earlier (in 1962), the mail organiser of Keep Left's YS faction, Gavi Kennedy, had left the tendency. Now a lef buffer began to form between Keep Left and Young Guard and Transport House, as Kee, Left generated a left wing opposition to it course towards split, independent of the ex tremely factional and factionally motivater Grant and Cliff tendencies (though IS even tually absorbed most of it).

Outside the YS a movement of engineerin apprentices began to be built, and Keep Lef saw the possibility of the YS fusing with thi movement. Also in the summer of 1964 gangs of youths, rivals in dress and life styles, the "Mods" (early Beatles style) ani old-fashioned "Rockers" rioted and fough each other in various places. Keep Left hailer this as the "revolt of the youth" , a revolt un fortunately in advance of the capacity of th YS to give it leadership...But with an effor they would catch up...

The attractions of an independent Y under Keep Left's exclusive control could on ly be enhanced by such events, and th leadership of the Healy tendency made goo use of them. Keep Left organised a lobby o the Labour Party NEC in June against th expulsion of John Robertson and the closin down of Streatham YS. The Keep Left Nt majority organised a "Fight the Tories' campaign culminating in a demonstration or 27 September which numbered 1500 people critics pointed to the rawness of most par ticipants.

In the late summer of 1964 branches of th YS began to be shut down. Keep Left did no retreat: instead, it stepped up the hostilities The National Committee issued a Y manifesto, "Forward with the Youn Socialists" , with a foreword by Dave Ashby who had been removed as YS chairman b simply being told that he was no longer o the books of the Labour Party in Leeds. At meeting of the YS NC in August thi manifesto was passed, 7 for (all Keep Lefi HANDS THE CHINESE and one abstention (Roger Rosewell, a supporter of Young Guard; he later became IS/SWP industrial organiser, and is now a witch-hunter).

September's Keep Left carried a stirring and defiant clarion call by John Robertson which expressed the "go it alone" perspective of KL. "The time to fight is now" , he insisted. "At Brighton at Easter we passed a policy for a real fight and an end to the shadow-boxing of Wilson and his cronies..." Conference decided policies and elected an NC to carry them out. 7 out of 11 are faithful to conference policies. "Forward with the YS" expresses those policies, and those who call themselves YS must stand by the manifesto. "We will unite with anyone who is prepared to fight for the policies of the manifesto". "At Brighton we told the bureaucrats we would not tolerate witch-hunts and expulsions. We meant exactly that. We will not tolerate them. We will fight on irrespective of the actions of the bureaucracy and the right wing. As far as we are concerned, they can go to hell, with a well-placed boot from us in the rear to help them on their way." Forward to the September 27 "Fight the Tories"" demonstration. "For a Labour government with socialist policies"

The style of this piece of raving unrealism suggests that Gerry Healy wrote it. It inverts the real relationship of forces in the world outside Gerry Healy's head. The tragedy now that the leadership of the Young Socialists was in the hands of people capable of hypnotising themselves with senseless bombast like this. The Labour Party leaders were all too eager to help them on their way.

As Young Guard put it in September: there was now a sulphurous smell of witch-hunting in the air. According to later SLL/WRP myth, what happened next is that the Labour Party leaders expelled the YS, which refused to be snuffed out, choosing independence instead. In fact there were expulsions and purges, there were closures, sometimes the police were called to remove recalcitrant YSers, but there was no suppression of the YS as such. The leaders of the Keep Left tendency decided on an organised break with the Labour Party in the face of the witch-hunting and limited expulsions, and thereafter they set out, by being awkward and provocative in local Labour Parties and elsewhere, to have as many people as possible expelled and branches closed down. The bureaucracy did not need much provocation!

Finally, the Keep Left NC majority announced that it was calling a conference of the YS independent of the bureaucracy for February 27-28 1965, and invited every YS member to attend.

To stop the split a rather feeble Save the YS campaign" was started, capable of attracting only 200 to a meeting in London in October 1964, despite having the support of Tribune, the ex-Keep Lefters such as Kennedy and Protz, Young Guard, Militant (which published its first issue in October 1964) and the "Nottingham Group" (forerunner of Socialist Outlook and Socialist Action). The Labour Party leaders contributed to "saving the YS" by issuing a circular telling people not to attend the meeting. They were entirely for the secession of Keep Left! 1965: A revolutionary youth movement?

as there not a case to be made tor the policy of taking the youth outside the Labour Party straitjacket and continuing to build?

It must depend on an assessment of the situation. For all the bluster, Keep Left was a very small force; so was the entire YS. It was ludicrous to pretend that YS conference decisions could be counterposed to the official policies of the Labour Party without a complete break. This break could only lead to the hiving-off of a small youth group with some ideas to make propaganda for. Was that desirable then, was it responsible revolutionary politics in the situation?

The SLL reprinted articles by Trotsky dealing with the situation in France in 1935.

Scan page 11

"Build new leadership!" "Build the revolutionary party!" - central slogan - "May Day message" - of the Healyites in 1967. Gerry - Healy is dead, but these sectarian "politics" *, which he pioneered in Britain, have been inherited by the WET ORGAN OFTHE CENTRAT Lic.

ONLY FORCE Socialist Workers Party.

The French Socialist Party bureaucracy had started to move against the revolutionary leaders of the Socialist youth. Trotsky argued for a bold orientation to building an independent party: the situation was fast becoming revolutionary, war and fascism threatened, the SP leaders wanted to "make docile cannon fodder of the youth" for French imperialism and to beat down opposition to the SP's alliance with the bourgeois Radicals in the Popular Front.

But for the Healy tendency to hive themselves off in 1964, on the eve of a Labour government, after they had been working in the Labour Party for 16 years, was political nonsense. The "brave" talk was toytown politics, rightly seen by Wilson and Co. as aiding them. And the leaders of Keep Left had a big element of choice - a free choice on whether to take all their forces out.

A policy of setting up an independent revolutionary YS might logically not have prevented a section of the youth from also being individual members of the Labour Party. In 1965 the SLL leaders occasionally talked of things like this for the future.

But if the SLL leaders had been capable of such a balanced policy and strategy then they would never have allowed themselves to be pushed into a break with the Labour Party on the eve of the formation of the first Labour government in 13 years, an event which would (and did) allow millions of workers to learn about political reformism from experience. The point is that the break was unbalanced and hysterical.

The parallel with Militant now is striking here too. Whatever "good" reasons can be cited for what Militant is doing, the people who ran the ridiculous Walton by-election campaign, and, among other things, thereby allowed the right wing to begin to remove Dave Nellist and Terry Fields from parliament, are politically unbalanced and irrational.

The SLL developed ludicrous theories about the possibility of a short cut to a mass revolutionary organisation via "the youth" as if it were possible artificially and at will to separate a generation of youth from the general experience of the class and the labour movement.

In reality they went marching out with a few thousand mainly raw youth, organised SOCIALIST LABOUR EASTE strikebreaking Tabour move he 1964 turn transforming CHIM Behind Comm by a few hundred revolutionaries, foolishly proclaiming that they had defeated the Labour bureaucracy. They went chasing their will-of-the-wisp on the eve of one of the most important experiences of the working class with reformism in government, removing their section of the revolutionary youth from the struggle in the political labour movement.

One consequence of this was that after 1966, when the Labour Government secured a majority in the March election (thus losing its excuses) and then went on a witch-hunting binge against striking seamen and introduced a statutory wage freeze in July, the sincere reformist activists simply began to drop away from the Labour Party. Had the earlier sectarian bloodletting in the YS not occurred, probably they could have been organised to give the Wilson government a difficult passage.

Servicing the YS as an independent organisation demanded more and more of the efforts and attention of the entire SLL cadre, a few hundred strong. By 1965, for example, building worker militants in Manchester were being harangued and browbeaten into accepting that their industrial work was unimportant compared with organising "revolutionary" youth clubs. (Some of them eventually joined IS).

The same youth-centred concern meant that shrill denunciation (occasionally justified, often not) of the CP in industries such as the ports, for the propagandist enlightenment of youth on the "essential" nature of Stalinism, replaced responsible concern with unity in the class struggle. In the dock strike of 1967, for instance, the SEL pursued a vicious propaganda war aginst the Communist Party, some of whose members were fighting the port reorganisation in alliance with revolutionaries, with Workers' Fight, for example. This replacement of the real struggle with newspaper commentaries was part of the process of losing touch with reality and with the real working class and the real labour movement.

La turn awa! the lent and from ti : of and it was ove itreversible for the Healy tendency. Impatience with the tempo of development in the working class movement and wishful thinking about what could be done outside the labour movement with a small section of youth (and a good printing press!) led the Healy tendency to what became - for all their bluster - a sectarian-abstentionist surrender to the dominant reformist bureaucracy in the labour movement.

That the break with the Labour Party was the product of a qualitative political degeneration and of hysteria was demonstrated to anyone still capable of learning (or still needing to learn) by the events of November 1964, when the seceding "revolutionary" YS engaged in strikebreaking!

Apprentice engineers, mainly in Manchester and Liverpool, had begun to organise an unofficial movement around wages and conditions. A big unofficial national apprentices' strike had come from similar beginnings in 1960 and in 1951. In September 1964, 1500 apprentices took part in a one-day strike. A committee was elected. Keep Left, the Young Communist League, Militant and others were represented. Bending to the untutored militancy of angry apprentices, it set the date for a strike. The Keep Left minority on the committee opposed this action as premature. Almost certainly this judgement was correct. Did they accept the decision of the strike committee majority? Not the "majority of the YS"'! They now considered themselves the anointed leaders, by right, of the youth — of all youth. They broke away from the committee and denounced the YCLers and Militant for deliberately betraying the apprentices. Then they announced a date (9 March 1965) on which they would call their own apprentices' strike! On 2 November they toured engineering factories with leaflets telling apprentices not to strike. In Manchester they even physically attacked ("'counter-revolutionary") YCLers trying to bring apprentices out.

The strike was a failure. It is difficult to assess what degree of responsibility for this rested with the sectarian strike breakers. When the date came in March for the YSdecreed strike, nothing at all happened. They vaguely announced a new date in May, which was eventually abandoned. Keep Left blustered and justified itself.

Though the actual strike-breakers were politically immature lads, the sectarian ultraleftism here was not of the sort that was widely seen after 1968 - anarchic, schematic, youthful ardour, impatience, unrealism and lack of tempering. Essentially what happened was that the SLL leaders attempted to submit sections of struggling youth to their own bureaucratic ukase - and ordered their youth to behave with typical bureaucratic brutality when they were "disobeyed"

Trotsky once pointed to the bureaucratic commandism at the heart of the ultra-leftism of the Stalinists' "Third period" (1928-34), which separated it from "naive" ultraleftism: the attempted extension outwards to the general labour movement and even to the working class as a whole of the bureaucratic internal regime in Stalin's Comintern. (Because of its bureaucratic inner structure, it was also - like the Healyites - capable of negating itself to the right, "effortlessly"). In the apprentices' strike the bureaucratic and commandist leadership of the SLL attempted to extend the methods of their internal life to a section of the movement. It was a qualitative step in a self-cutting-off process which led to the deep isolation of the SLL. It signalled a further loss of awareness of reality for the closed-in leaders of the SLL.

Keep Left after the 1965 split En February 1965 the Morecambe conference called by the Keep Left YS NC majority was attended by 1,000 people. It declared itself to be the YS from then on, with Keep Left as its official paper: effectively it became the youth wing of the SLL which now went off on an "Oehlerite binge" to end all Ochlerite binges, and whose central slogan became "Join the SLL, build the revoluSocialist Organiser No. 509 page 11 tionary party". For them, the party became an entity separate from history, from society, and even from politics (their politics were wildly unstable), when the needs of its onanistic development required it. It was concerned essentially only with its own growth and survival, by almost any means and on any conditions, and irrespective of its relationship to the labour movement and the working class; irrespective too of what damage techniques such as systematic lying would do to that movement.

To "maintain" his party — and his own princely bureaucratic lifestyle - Healy would in the 1970s, after much political zigzagging, sell it as a spying agency (on Arab dissidents and Jews) to various Arab governments, bourgeois or worse.

It should be noted that it was now - from Healyites, in the mid-'60s - that the notion first made its appearance in Britain of raising the call "Build the Revolutionary Party!" as a central slogan. (It had, I believe, been so used in France by the Frank-Bleibtreu faction in* 1946-8, and by the Lambertists in 1952-58). Today, it is commonplace in Britain. The people who mocked the Healyites for it, and called it "toytown Bolshevism" in the mid '60s - the Young Guard/IS-SWP group - picked it up in the "70s, and now they, too, use "Build the Revolutionary Party!" as the answer to most current political problems.

In the 1960s it did the Healyites no good!

The youth were organised always on the perspective of imminent revolutionary crisis, and sent on one campaign after another. Certainly by the mid-'60s (probably earlier) the SLL leadership was using this as a cynical dn technique. The fact that the perspectives of the SLL were always quickly falsified led to a rapid turnover in membership. Many of the cadres dropped away in the mid-'60s, Ashby and Robertson for example. Robertson, who ate state-capitalist "scabs" for breakfast in 1964, was knocking around with Leeds IS in 1968-9, and later went to the CP.

The Healy regime destroyed real political life. From about 1966 systematic lying about political opponents and their positions became a prominent feature of the SLL. Surviving cadres suddenly had to accept the line that Ernest Mandel and Michel Pablo had supported the Russian invasion of Hungary in 1956 — something none of them had ever heard about until a decade after it allegedly happened! Nevertheless, many of them - all those who "survived" this period -swallowed it. Then when the great mass movement against the Vietnam war erupted in 1967, and a vast new ultra-left youth radicalisation started, the sectarian SLL, finding "its" territory encroached upon, could only denounce it, isolating itself from the post-1968 radicalisation. It is a grim and tragic story, but we will not follow it beyond this point.

The secession of Keep Left marked the end of a definite period for the YS. In the early '60s it had been politically centre stage, with a more or less clear field for development as a socialist youth organisation. The 1964-65 split marked a defeat for socialist youth, a defeat centrally the responsibility of the Labour bureaucracy, but which happened also because the leaders of the old Trotskyist movement failed the revolutionary youth. A mass YS had not been built. The character of the Wilson government, especially after 1966, made the YS far from attractive to militant and socialist youth in the late '60s. The great youth mobilisation after 1967 was to pass the rump LPYS by (while the Keep Left YS hid from it). Prospects of real development did not open again until after 1970, and by then the LPYS had other problems. Now Militant was in control.

Scan page 12

Socialist Organiser No. 509 page 12 : CULTURAL FRON

----- pull-quotes -----

TMPs.FIGHT OFF support the Red Guardsh

The Newsletter BUILD NEW LEADERSHIP

MAY DAY MESSAGE *Hoiskyism lives Tighis and grows

OUR H 3L32 ANNIVER

Sinisi for

"The people who mocked the Healyites' 'toytown Bolshevism' in the mid-'60s picked it

70s, themselves in the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 509

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →