Towards Eur
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
(tened strike action. Our answer to Euro-capitalist integration must be workers' unity The Burne would beat like fan is or deteries but ts, Tony Three points about the First, there is fundamental agreement between the three party leaders. The Prime Minister is on the eve of negotiations so he has to be cautious.
The Leader of the Opposition, who hopes to take over, can bolder. The Liberal Democrats, who are far from office, can ne quite clear about their objective. There is no disagreement about the idea that we should move from the original membership of the community through the Single European Act to something stronger.
Secondly, a degree of caution has emerged from people who, when they discussed the matter 20 years ago, were far more uncritical. Thirdly - and I say this with some satisfaction - 21 years after I urged a referendum, I have won the right hon. Member for Finchley (Mrs Thatcher) and the right hon. Member for Yeovil (Mr Ashdown) to my cause. I had to wait 21 years, but it has been worth waiting for some recognition of the fact that the people have a right to a say in their government.
I do not want to go over old ground because this is not a question of yes or not to the status quo; we are looking to the future. Some people genuinely believe that we shall never get social justice from the British government, but we shall get it from Jacques Delors.
They believe that a good king is better than a bad parliament. I have never taken that view. Others believe that the change is inevitable, and that the common currency will protect us from inflation and will provide a wage policy. They believe that it will control speculation and that Britain cannot survive alone. None of these arguments persuade me because the argument has never been about sovereignty.
I do not know what a sovereign is, apart from the one that used to be in gold and the Pope, who is a sovereign in the Vatican. We are talking about democracy. No nation - not even the great United States which could, for all I know, be destroyed by a nuclear weapon from a Third World country - has the power to impose its will on other countries. We are discussing whether the British people are allowed to elect those who make the laws under which they are governed. The argument is nothing to do with whether we should get more maternity leave from Madam Papandreou than from Madam Thatcher. That is not the issue.
I recognise that when the members of the three Front Benches agree, I am in a minority. My next job therefore is to explain to the people of Chesterfield what we have decided. I will say first, "My dear constituents, in future you will be governed by people whom you do not elect and cannot remove. I am sorry about it. They may give you better creches and shorter working hours, but you cannot remove them.
I know that sounds negative, but I have always thought it positive to say that the important thing about democracy is that we can remove without bloodshed the people who govern us. We can get rid of a Callaghan, a Wilson or even a right hon. Lady by internal processes. We can get rid of the right hon. Member for Huntingdon (Mr Major). But that cannot be done in the structure that is proposed. Even if one likes the policies of the people in Europe one cannot get rid of them.
Secondly, we say to my tavourite friends, the Chartists and suffragettes, "All your struggles to get control of the ballot box were a waste of time. We shall be run in future by a few white persons, as in 1832" The instrument, I might add, is the Royal Prerogative of treaty making. For the first time since 1649 the Crown makes the laws — advised, I admit, by the Prime Minister.
We must ask what will happen when people realise what we have done. We have had a marvellous debate about Europe, but none of us has discussed our relationship with the people who sent us here. Hon. Members have expressed views on Albania and the Baltic states. I have been dazzled by the knowledge of the continent of which we are all part. No one has spoken about how he or she got here and what we were sent here to do.
f people lose the power to sack their government one of several things happen. First, people may just slope off. Apathy could destroy democracy. When the turnout drops below 50 per cent, we are in danger.
Mr Peter Hardy (Wentworth): Like in the United States.
Tony Benn: As my hon. Friend says, in the United States turnouts are very low. That is partly caused by the scale of the country.
The second thing that people can do is to riot. Riot is an old-fashioned method for drawing the attention of the government to what is wrong. It is difficult for an elected person to admit it, but the riot at Strangeways produced some prison reforms. Riot has historically played a much larger part in British politics than we are ever allowed to KnOW • Thirdly, nationalism can arise. Instead of blaming the Treaty of Ranse, people say, it is the Gertionalism is built out of frustration that people feel when they cannot get their way through the ballot box. With nationalism comes repression. I hope that it is not pessimistic — in my view it is not -to say that democracy hangs by a thread in every country of the world. Unless we can offer people a peaceful route to the resolution of injustices through the ballot box they will not listen to a House that has blocked off that route. There are many alternatives open to us. One hon. Member said that he was young and had not fought in the war. He looked at a new Europe. But there have been five Europes this century. There was one run by the King, the Kaiser and the Tsar - they were all cousins so that was very comfortable. They were all Queen Victoria's grandsons. And there was no nonsense about human rights when Queen Victoria's grandsons repressed people. Then there was the Russian revolution. Then there was the inter-war period. Then there was the Anglo-Soviet alliance. Then there was the cold war. Now we have a Boris Yeltsin who has joined the Monday Club. There have been many Europes. This is not the only Europe on offer.
I understand that my hon. Friend the Member for Sunderland South (Chris Mullin) is a democratic tederalist, as is my hon. Friend the Member for Derbyshire North-East (Mr Barnes). They want an American-type constitution for Europe. It could be that our laws would hang on which way the Albanian members voted. I could not complain about that because that is democracy. However, it is unworkable. It is like trying to get an elephant to dance through a minefield. But it would be democratic.
Another way would be to have a looser, wider Europe. I have an idea for a Commonwealth of Europe. I am introducing a Bill on the subject. Europe would be rather like the British Commonwealth. We would work by consent with people. Or we could accept this ghastly proposal, which is clumsy, secretive, centralised, bureaucratic and divisive. That is how I regard the Treaty of Rome. I was born a European and I will die one. But I have never put my alliance behind the Treaty of Rome. I object to it. I hate being called an anti-European. How can one be anti-European when one is born in Europe? It is like saying that one is anti-British if one does not agree with the Chancellor of the Exchequer. What a lot of nonsense it is.
I ask myself why the House is ready to contemplate abandoning its duties, as I fear that it is. I was elected 41 years ago this month. This Chamber has lost confidence in democracy. It believes that it must be governed by someone else. It is afraid to use the powers entrusted to it by its constituents. It has traded power for status. One gets asked to go on the telly if one is a Member of Parliament. The Chamber does not want to use its power. It has accepted the role of a spectator and joined what Bagehot called the dignified part of the constitution, leaving the Crown, under the control of the Prime Minister, to be the Executive part.
If democracy is destroyed in Britain it will not be the communists, Trotskyists or subversives but this House which threw it away. The rights that are entrusted to us are not for us to give away. Even if I agree with everything that is proposed, I cannot hand away powers lent to me for five years by the people of Chesterfield. I just could not do it. It would be theft of public rights.
Therefore, there is only one answer. If people are determined to submit themselves to Jacques Delors, Madam Papandreou and the Council of Ministers, we must tell the people what is planned. If people vote for that, they will all have capitulated. Julius Ceasar said "We are just merging our sovereignty" . So did William the Conqueror.
It is not possible to support the government's motion. I have told the Chief Whip that I cannot support the Labour motion. I invite the House to vote against the government's motion and not to support a motion which purports to take us faster into a Community which cannot reflect the aspirations of those who put us here. That is not a nationalist argument nor is it about sovereignty. It is a democratic argument and it should be decisive in a democratic Chamber.
Tony Benn was speaking in parlia ment.
Scan page 9
ereignty? SO debates Tony Benn opean unity? cross the continent.
Go back 10 years or so, back, say, to the discussion on the EC in Socialist Organiser in the early '80s. There you will find the then very powerful anti-European Community left - including Tony Benn -raising, in anticipation, exactly the same arguments against the EC as the Tories raise - from the other side.
The EC would, they used to argue, stop a left wing Westminster government from carrying through socialist measures. The Europeans would hold us back from socialism.
Since capitalism was enshrined in the EC constitution. British sovereignty was the best guarantee for the future the labour movement had of controlling its own affairs, and preserving the chance of settling with our own bourgeoisie.
For the left, too - 1 mean the mainstream left of the broad labour movement, not the "revolutionary" groups, which have chopped and changed on Europe shamelessly over the years, or the Stalinists who used to follow USSR foreign policy — the reason for opposing the EC, and now for opposing moves towards tederalism are many and complex.
At the core of it is a plain old-fashioned unashamed British nationalism, frilled up with attachment to the Westminster parliamentary tradition. The messianic notion inbedded in the old arguments that "Europe" would stop "us" reaching socialism was itself deeply nationalistic. Socialist Organiser answered those arguments then: a revolutionary socialist government at Westminster would disrupt and break EC restrictions on its right to take action against capitalism — and appeal for support, solidarity and similar actions to the workers of all Europe. The same answer in general is appropriate now that Britain is so far from being ahead of the rest of Europe that some Tories see the EC as a "socialist" conspiracy. Briere is a very he E eare enn is right: the issue is there is a very high degree of economic integration; there is a strongest and most dynamic capitalist economy, tried to unite Europe — and succeeded briefly in 1940 — two times Germany was defeated.
After the second great slaughter, the main capitalist classes started to unite. They could not, for political reasons, decide to create a European federal union that would allow the European economy to follow its natural course of development as one entity within a single state. National hatreds, divisions and pride were too strong for that.
So they did it back to front: economy first, and then, decades later - now - politics.
They created an international European coal and steel community in 1951 and the Common Market (with six countries, excluding Britain, which joined in 1972) in 1957-58.
Slowly, since then, the European Community has knitted together, until in some ways it is more closely knitted into one entity than the US economy is.
Slowly, the bureaucracy created to run the affairs of the Community has siphoned away the powers of the sectional national parliaments, rising in power and importance, until today it has greater power than any of the national parliaments.
The European Parliament is still a shadowy affair, though its power has slowly grown - too slowly -and is growing: the bourgeoisie now want to take the decisive steps to federal unity as they have taken all the other steps over 40 years - by strengthening the bureaucracy.
Is it possible for serious socialists to respond to all this by calls to strengthen one, or all, of the national parliaments? But the essential thing is that the economic unity of Europe is already a fact: the EC is an economic entity distinct from all others in the world market currency union, for example, is very important but it is a matter of tidying things up, a detail. Britain is locked into it.
Britain could not without tremendous economic self-destruction now disentangle from the European Community. It is this economic unification that undermines and enfeebles the national parliaments: their influence on the_ EC_ varies power the British capitalist class exercise at Westminster. Nor does the championing of what are in fact now regional parliaments, like Westminster, necessarily weaken the EC power of the capitalist class exercised now mainly through the EEC bureaucray. But it is a foolish argument - and an anarchist one - which dismisses more political democracy because it does not in itself solve the problem of economic inequality and lack of democracy. Socialists recognise politics and political rights as steps, as tools, in the realisation of economic democracy.
What we need in Europe is a fight for tull political rights in a pariament with real power over the community. It is understandable that political formations like the SWP, who dismiss Westminster politics too, dismiss the idea of a democratic struggle for European democracy. They are essentially -if you reduce what they say and do to a coherence it does not openly display - a-political anarchists, albeit anarchists who have tasted the forbidden fruit of political knowledge, and, knowing they are naked, feel enough shame to hide their anarchism in toy-town "Leninism" and, on election day, calls to "vote Labour"! Tony Benn is no anarchist! His reference to 'Communists, Trotskyists anc subversives" is irony directed against the establishment, but he is not a Trotskyist, nor a subversive either.
What you are left with in Benn's speech is an amazing defeatism -European political integration, he says more or less clearly, must mean the end of democracy, autocratic rule. The power of Westminster is being snuffed out: there can not, he seems to say, be a Europe-wide replacement for it. What should the labour movement do? If taking up the age old struggle for democracy, but on a European scale, in alliances with the other workers of Euorpe, is ruled out what can the working class do? Unite with Mrs Thatcher?
decade ago Tony Ben in called