Ballot setback for the NUM
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
Traders on ohe matonat he Scottish NUM change in the national union's stance on British Coal's 'majority-minority' bargaining code got a boost from the results of the ballot on an overtime ban without safety cover. But it is likely that the NUM leadership will see off any moves to change their bargaining stance.
Members voted 18,806 to 11,106 against the ban, a significant fall from the 43% in favour in last year's ballot for an overtime ban with safety cover. Yorkshire, usually a pillar of support for industrial action voted against, 7,343 to 6,062. Only Nottinghamshire voted for (400 to 239).
Scottish area officials have been pushing for a ballot on whether or not the NUM should support the 'majority-minority" principle. Accepting this would mean allowing the Union of Democratic Mineworkers to negotiate on behalf of NUM members in pits is a majority.
For six years the NUM has refused to sit down at the negotiating table with the UDM. Rates for miners have hence been negotiated between British Coal and the UDM.
Even though the NUM leadership's advice to take industrial action was rejected they will still receive strong support against moves to change the NUM's negotiating stance. Members in the larger areas like Yorkshire and the North East are unlikely to support recognition of the UDM. So the Scottish NUM official's campaign stymied.
But it is still necessary to be clear why members voted 'no' to action in the ballot. Arthur Scargill has put it down to demoralisation after years of seeing jobs butchered, pits closed and communities destroyed. This is true in part, but it is not the whole picture.
Dave Cliff, then of Hem Heath NUM argued in SO 467, after the 'no' vote in last year's ballot on an overtime ban with safety cover, there were other problems involved, relating to the nature of the industrial accampaigns, focussing on national bargaining, the national rate for the job and a serious 1992 pay claim. Coordination across the Broad Lefts will be vital.
The 7 December pay conference being called by the CPSA Broad Left (on the initiative of Socialist Organiser supporters) must be turned into a working conference jointly organised by all the civil service union Broad Lefts. It would be a disaster if the Militant majority in CPSA Broad Left seized this excellent idea only to transmute it into a Militant rally (as they always do with conferences they are able to The NUCPS Broad Left in particular, must be quite firm in insisting on the democratic and working character of the conference as the best way to prepare for the official conference. The fight on pay and London Weighting presents a real opportunity to build the left as a serious non-sectarian force in the civil service unions. That opportunity must be seized with both hands. tion being considered.
The last time an overtime ban with safety cover was operated many miners worked overtime citing safety as an excuse. To operate an overtime ban without safety cover also has drawbacks. With shafts not being inspected regularly, many miners who never work overtime may lose whole shifts and hence incentive payments.
Such a situation is worse than being on strike when nobody expects to get paid - if you are working everyone wants paying.
The NUM needs to adopt more sophisticated tactics. Perhaps it is time to learn from the railworkers and adopt their tactics of days of action and area strikes of short duration.