Hillel Ticktin on the nature of the USS "The Stalinist bureaucracy was potential ruling class and an actual ruling group'
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Hillel Ticktin on the nature of the USS.
The Baikal-Amur railway line. A monument to the Brezhnevite stagnation. Billions of lovements trademUnional pesu 6100 ASposker Paul Ramsa n the discussion over the mode of production in the USSR, I cannot but agree with the use of Marx's famous statement on the importance of the form of the surplus product. Tom Rigby does not follow it up.
What is the form of the surplus product in the USSR? I have tried to answer that by saying that it is the 'defective product surplus' or the 'Soviet surplus product' More clearly stated: the contradiction in the USSR lies not between use-value and exchange-value, but between the potential (intended) product and the actual product. The surplus product therefore takes on this special form of a product which is internally contradictory.
That means that the ruling group have a surplus product which is different from what it seems to be. They may have produced more machine tools than anyone else in the world, but they actually have a shortage of machine tools because of the low quality, poor technique etc of their products. So the surplus product is a surplus product and is not a surplus product.
Differently put, they have only a limited degree of control over the surplus product. For that reason, they do not constitute a class.
Why? Because the workers continue to have a negative control over their own labour process. As a result the ruling group could not 'plan' the system. As a further result, they were and remain an unstable grouping, which could only stay in power through the atomisation of the population.
Such atomisation reduced was no fundamental economic law the level of productivity to the point where innovation was below the level of capitalism. Indeed, it was extremely difficult to introduce any new technique into an exroubles have been spent trvina to complete it. isting plant in the USSR. The system had no integrating mechanism other than its own command over surplus labour time and once that dried up, the system went into free fall.
In other words, Chris Arthur is surely right that the USSR was never a new mode of production. Its short life was a pointer to the more profound inability of the system to establish itself as a mode of production. The reason lay in the fact that unlike capitalism, there was no fundamental economic law motivating the system. Its laws were conflictual and disintegrative.
Even the usual argument, which Tom Rigby is adducing along : with Mandel and others, that the system grew is dubious. Its growth was so marred that Gorbachev could termiegetrationed. claim that there was no growth except in vodka and oil in the Brezhnev period.
converting to capitalism, practically all machinery will have to be replaced with market-type "It [Stalinism] is not even a not even a footpath".
machinery. Hence it is not even a parallel road to capitalism. It is not even a footpath. I have tried to argue the case in much more detail in my book on the origins of the disintegration of the USSR.
The increased production of semi-useful goods is an indication that there was a nonintegrative conflictual social relationship within production held together by temporary forces. One can, of course, call such a relationship by any name one wants, even a mode of production, but one must live with the consequence that there would be hundreds of modes of production in human history and not the few Marx adduces.
During periods of world transition such as the present there are bound to come into being temporary formations or systems which are like defective embryos in not having vital ingredients for life. The founder of "Against the Current" - the late Steve Zeluck compared the USSR to Neanderthal Man in not having an evolutionary future.
The great advantage of this approach as against the bureaucratic collectivist approach, is that it permitted me to predict the disintegration of the USSR from 1975 onwards. It provided a dynamıc to that system, one of disintegration, and allowed one to understand that the ruling group desperately wanted to be a class, and indeed always preferred to go to capitalism, but could not make it.
Just as the products of the system are potential use-values as well as actual use-values, so the ruling group was a potential class as well as an actual ruling group. Today they see their potentiality in converting to capitalism.
----- pull-quotes -----
"Unlike capitalism,
regulating the system".
parallel road to capitalism. It is