Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists Answer the New Right

Socialist Organiser no. 508, 21 November 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 2,750 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Organiser From page 1 erfectly absurdly, as it of creating poverty comprise today, as they have for more than a hundred and fifty years, one of the main lines of critique of capitalism.

Yet no civilisation throughout history, no other type of society, past or present - among modern societies neither self-proclaimed socialist societies, nor fascist societies, пог military dictatorships, nor dynastic despotisms, nor revolutionary theocracies, nor any others — have succeeded in providing and sustaining such wealth as the tiny minority of capitalist societies have entirely reliably produced. None of these alternative systems has raised the general standard of living of whole populations to the high and continually improving levels which even the so-called poor in Britain take entirely for granted. Only capitalism destroys povertyWhether measured in terms of life expectancy, real incomes, distribution of property, leisure spending, or whatever, the material condition of the British population - even in general recession - is good and continually improving.

*Trickle down" is altogether too modest a characterisation of recent improvements in standards of living. Capitalism has produced in Britain a veritable cornucopia of wealth, which has cascaded right across society. This has transformed the standard of living and the quality of life in material terms beyond what was even conceivable except by a tiny minority as recently as 1945.

None of this is contradicted in the slightest by the persistence of economic inequalities, or even by their increase from time to time. Inequalities are required as the engine of the economic progress which increases living standards all round and destroys poverty. They are a major source of incentive, aspiration, and ambition. They are also widely accepted, in moral terms, and they are in a strict philosophical sense natural, being liberated by capitalism, as Hayek has shown, most notably in The Fatal Conceit, as a key component the market which defines it. Challenge the shifting inequalities of capitalism, and economic progress is destroyed.

Of course this is miscomprehended by capitalism's critics, and even by some of its more luke-warm supporters. The Poverty Lobby's spurious identification of economic inequality with poverty, and its dogmatic determination to eliminate by socialistic measures and mechanisms the very dynamic which has rendered real poverty obsolete, are an index of the poverty of socialist analysis and of the timidity of the pro-capitalist intellectuals who are their supposed oping other than that, as George Gilder has demonstrated in The Capitalist Revolution, on the material front at least, capitalism has succeeded and is succeeding triumphantly.

The second line of socialist critCialist slander".

It comes in many distinct versions, put they share a common inclination to find in the styles of life, in the forms of character, and in the values required by capitalism for its success, a gross underestimate and a hideous deformation of human potential.

It is the charge that capitalist culture is altogether and merely materialistic; the claim that competition is inherently destructive; the charge that property divides and subjugates; the accusation that individualism, or at least capitalism's possessive individualism, inhibits co-operation; the critical presumption that economic inequality precludes citizenship and even fraternity; the belief that pursuit of profit inhibits altruism and prevents genuine service; the widespread view even among moderate critics of capitalism that markets destroy community.

Yet most even of the worst features are even worse by a big margin in pre-capitalist and post-capitalist societies. The scope for effective reform and improvement without structural change is patently enormous. Empirical studies of people's lives — as reported, for example, by Gilder and by Michael Novak in The Spirit of Democratic Capitalism -clearly and definitely suggest high levels of satisfaction at work, at leisure, and holistically; improving levels of education, sophistication, and civilisation; and consistent movement overall towards a far greater degree of personal and interactional expression and development than we have any right -given a realistic view of the past and of man's infinite capacity for evil — to expect.

Moreover, the supposedly destructive features of capitalism which it is alleged are responsible for all the problems property, profit, competition, inequality, and the rest — turn out to be precisely the mechanisms which directly, in and of themselves, and indirectly through their sustenance of freedom, are making positive human development possible.

Immigrants flood, where they can manage it, away from all sorts of primitive and evil societies, into capitalist societies, pursuing an escape from poverty certainly, but also and equally freedom, and the dream, which is no mere phantasy, of a good life for themselves and their families in the broadest and deepest sense of the concept of good so far available.

Thus, in material and moral terms alike, even those capitalist societies such as Britain which have been most gravely weakened by socialist intrusions, cluding especially excessive planning and regulation, are succeeding to degree which makes the proposal for substituting the plan for the market unnecessary and implausible.

Moreover, on both the economic and the moral front, those central features of capitalism which socialists would displace by installing a planning regime - competition, profit, enterprise, and consumer choice — are demonstrably playing a key role in securing this success.

The failed theory of planning Planning is unnecessary then;

Pout in any case it can't work.

This seems to me to have been adequately demonstrated in Hayek's refutation of Oskar Lange's thesis of the possibility of socialist calculation.| Lange claims that all the information available to capitalist entrepreneurs which is necessary for them to make optimal decisions about resource allocation is available in practice to socialist planners. Given this data, they can then plan the socialist economy rationally.

Or as Heilbronner, following Lange, puts it: "A central planning board would receive exactly the same information from a socialist economic system as did the entrepreneurs under the market system", This assumption -strengthened in some quarters recently by developments in information science and technology which speed up the flow of any sort of information and make it potentially much more comprehensive — is required by even the most modest sorts of planning, and is absolutely essential to systematic detailed planning such as would be required to replace the market. Hayek's response is as follows:

"I am afraid this is a blatant untruth, an assertion so absurd that it is difficult to understand how an intelligent person could ever honestly make it. It asserts a sheer impossibility which only a miracle could realise.

In the first instance: most of the information which the capitalist entrepreneurs have consists of prices determined on a competitive market. This knowledge would not be available to anyone in a socialist economy where prices are not provided by the market.

So far as the particular case of the production function is concerned. the relevant production functions which guide the competitive market are, of course, not (as the theoretical models simplifyingly assume) relations betweer general, generic categories of commodities, but very specific relations showing how, in a particular plant under the specific local conditions, changes in the combinations of the particular goods and services employed will affect the size of the output' (Journal of Economic Affairs Vol.2 Moreover, even if the information were available - which by definition it cannot be in a socialist society - there is still no way it could be collated and analysed by a planning unit or by a single person or by any other means than the infinite complexity of the market itself. Dispersed market knowledge simply cannot be mobilised centrally.

Even on more modest and substantially oversimplified assumptions about the range and particularity of the knowledge required, such that a kind of *accountancy planning" could possible, it couldn't work in practice. As Hayek says:

*The mere idea that the planning authority could ever possess a complete inventory of the amounts and qualities of all the different materials and instruments of production of which the manager of a particular plant will know or be able to find out makes the whole proposal a somewhat comic fiction. Once this is recognised it becomes obvious that what prices ought to be can never be determined without relying on competitive markets.

The suggestion that the planning authority could enable the managers of particular plants to make use of their specific knowledge by fixing uniform prices for certain classes of goods that will then have to remain in force until the planning authority learns whether at these prices inventories generally increase or decrease is just the crowning foolery of the whole farce". • (Ibid.)

This is why all planning systems but only some markets — fail. A competitive market system capitalises naturally on a complex interaction of individual decisions which cannot be adequately recorded, let alone reproduced in the abstract by any artificial means. This is why Central Europe, and now Kussia and the Ukraine, are simply haying to marketise fully.

Without a market, economic decisions are bound to be guesswork and commonly - and cumulatively. -mistaken. This is also why rational planning within the Welfare State is so difficult, why state functions which cannot be privatised such as defence are so expensive and inefficient, and why it is at those boundaries between national economies which are not made transparent by free trade that major dislocations of economic efficiency and dynamism occur.

In the absence of a market, there is simply no rational basis available for resource allocation decisions. If a plan, of whatever sort, is used instead, systematic resource mis-allocation is inevitable. Moreover reactions to the consequences of these errors will multiply them still further, resulting sooner or Tater in complete economic collapse -in an economic crisis such as socialists have long expected in capitalist societies but actually occurs only in socialist societies, or at least in those societies which have defined the competitive market as the essential characteristic of capitalism and replaced it by the plan.

Even the much more modest and commonsensical notions of planning typically recommended by socialists in Britain — for example organising the health service either nationally, or even regionally, in terms of prescriptions derived other than from a market, or distorting the natural flow of regional investment in order to supposedly protect economically weaker regions — are subject to the same fundamental errors. Socialist planning, however desirable it might seem to be, is simply not on. Practical problems planning n addition to these problems of principle about planning, there are also grave practical difficulties.

I can best make what I mean clear by spelling out the reasons why market systems - that is to say, modes of organising the production and distribution of goods and services which are responsive via prices and profits to consumer sovereignty — are generally effective.

All the eight advantages of competitive markets I will spell out are matched by correlative disadvantages in any non-market planning system. Similar disadvantages would also of course appear as a result of private monopoly, though these are worsened by state monopoly, and worsened further again by the comprehensive state monopoly of a planned socialist society.

Sooner or later private monopolies are defeated by innovative competitors.

A state monopoly, by contrast, will persist - and grow progressively more inefficient — until the state can no longer afford it either economically or politically. A socialist society — a planned monopoly of planned monopolies - will simply go on and on, getting worse and worse at everything, until it collapses.

In the absence of free markets:

• Prices go up or fail to reduce;

• Supply is reduced and shortages follow.

• Innovation is blocked.

• The quality of service is reduced.

• The state incurs costs - for running nationalised industries or for subsidies - instead of benefits from taxes.

why does this happen? The main reason is because the only alternative to a competitive market — the only other way of organising the production and distribution of goods and services — is a command system. The central planning essential to a command economy simply cannot, in its nature, answer consumers' needs effectively as a competitive market system in most cases can.

There are eight reasons why this is so.

I. Consumer tastes and needs vary over a wide range and unpredictably.

Only markets, that is to say mechanisms specifically answerable to consumer demand, can address this variety effective2. Consumer tastes and needs are subject to rapid unpredictable change. Only markets can adjust with reliable rapidity to such change.

3. Entrepreneurs and technologists tend - unless they are prevented - to produce innovations and improvements. Only a market answerable to consumer preferences allows reliably for effective testing and implementation of such improvements.

4. Only those forms of organisation of the production of goods and services which are oriented to consumer preferences and subject to consumer sovereignty are likely, through competition, to minimise costs and prices. 5. Only those forms of organisation of the production of goods and services which are oriented to consumer preferences and subject to consumer sovereignty are likely, again through competition and the effects of prices, to reduce waste and more generally to maximise efficiency.

6. Only consumer sovereignty is capable of determining optimum levels of investment and expenditure. In its absence investment and other expenditure is likely to be artificially and damagingly either held down or exaggerated.

7. Only consumer sovereignty within a competitive market prevents the need for excessive and dangerous political controls, ramifying bureaucracy, and rationing in one form or another.

8. Only organisations which are answerable to competitive markets and consumer choice are capable of resisting exaggerated trade union demands.

For all these reasons, a market, involving real competition between a number of producers and suppliers of goods and services, is likely in most cases to be superior to any command or planned economy in delivering the quantity and the quality of what people want.

Conclusion: the fatal conceit The states belonging to free societies need to plan if they are to do their proper work effectively. However, this should be modest in scope and scale, cautiously handled, and limited to the decisively restricted sphere of operations which are appropriate to the state in free societies.| Any extension of state planning beyond these limits is bound to be both ineffective and counter-productive. Extension of state planning as a counterweight to or a substitute for the normal and natural operation of the free market cannot in any circumstances be other than gravely damaging to the real interests of the whole population.

When liberal capitalist societies like Britain are faced by recession, or challenged over the longer term by suecessful competition from other nations, there is a powerful temptation to believe that state planning and state intervention can provide an antidote. All our experience in Britain since the War refutes this optimistic notion. Interference with the market, however modest and well-intentioned, simply makes things worse.

The real answer is not more planning, but less, not an increase in state intervention, but a radical reduction. The success of the British economy depends entirely on the capacities of entrepreneurs, managers and workers to invent, produce and sell products and services at a profit on the global market.

I have argued here that, beyond very modest parameters, planning is unnecessary, infeasible in principle, and ineffective in practice. It may seem that the progressive application of human intelligence to social affairs must inevitably counsel adoption of a comprehensive planning mode in relation to every sort of human problem. This is how it is being argued currently, for example, in relation to environmental problems and "green" issues. But in this important instance and generally this conception is mistaken.

Human intelligence and advancing knowledge ought, on the contrary, to advise us that the market is a powerfully productive institution, evolved naturally over generations, with which we should interfere as little as can be managed.

The better part of intelligence is to marvel at the market's gifts to mankind, to protect and facilitate its operations, and to resist the impatient clamour of the planners tooth and nail. The commitment of socialists and others to planning is indeed, in Hayek's memorably precise phrase, a "fatal conceit"

Our tape-recording of the summary speeches at the end of the session was not good enough for them to be transcribed accurately. John O'Mahony's series on the Labour youth movement in the early 1960s will be continued next week.

Scan page 13

E CULTURAL FRONT liSI

----- pull-quotes -----

ponents. Certainly their efforts provide not the slightest justification for believ-

"Only consumer sovereignty within competitive markel prevents the need for excessive and dangerous political controls, ramifying bureaucracy...

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 508

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →