Socialist planning versus free market
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Thomasıpk Socials»
Organiser debeted Professor Damid Mensland on "free marketnvensis soranist planning"
The free market is a cruel and unequal system. In a whole epoch of human history, nonetheless, it played a progressive role. Now it is possible to do better.
I shall also look at the relevance of the experience of Stalinism to the question of socialist planning.
The free market is a system of inequality fundamentally because of one exchange which takes place within it, the exchange between worker and employer.
On the face of it, this is a tree and equal exchange. Selling your labour power is much like selling a sack of potatoes.
The difference is that when you sell your labour power, the employer then controls the bulk of your life. He decides what you do with your skills, your energy, and a large part of your time.
He has the power to destroy your health, even sometimes to destroy your life. In Japan, they now have a new word for death from overwork, because it is so common.
That not a particularly backward capitalist country. That is the most dynamic capitalist economy in the world today.
The sale of labour power is not like just exchanging one good for another. It is a fundamentally unequal exchange, and the root of that inequality is that the means of production are in the hands of a small minority.
The free market is also a system of inequality because, built into it, is a varying, but always substantial, level of unemployment — that is, a number of workers who cannot even become wage slaves. Unemployment means poverty for those who cannot sell their labour power and insecurity for those who can - for the moment.
It means that the idea of the free market being the best way of enabling individuals to plan their lives is nonsense. All your plans can be destroyed from one week to the next. If you lose your job, you can lose your home. You can lose everything.
The inequality of the free market goes wider than that. The free market system also generates huge inequalities between countries and regions. In the free market system, investment goes where it is most profitable, and that is a place where there is already a good infrastructure of communications, a healthy, educated workforce, good relations with suppliers, ample markets and so on, i.e. a place which is relatively developed economically already.
Thus, in the world today, and for the last 200 years, most investment has gone to the advanced capitalist countries and a few selected areas in the underdeveloped countries. We get huge inequalities at an international level.
The free market system is not just an unequal system. It is an inhuman system. I do not think that anybody, given a choice, would say that the millionaires of western Europe and the USA having that little bit extra is more important than feeding the millions of people in the world who live constantly in danger of starvation.
In the free market, money buys everything — and human need buys nothing. If you're hungry, in a free market system, that is no entitlement at all to food. If on the other hand, you are quite well-fed and have lots of money, you can buy lots of food on a whim. Your whim is more important, in the free market system, than the desperate needs of the poor.
Further, the free market system counts or recognises as important economic considerations only what can by packaged as commodities for individual consumption.
If you have the money, you can buy a house, a car, all sorts of gadgets. You cannot buy a healthy environment. You cannot buy the preservation of the world in a state where it will be safe for our children or grandchildren.
You can buy hospitals full of high-tech equipment, you cannot buy preventive healthcare. You can't even buy decent drains.
The free market system is inherently negled in human. It systematically rejects what is social in favour of commodities for individual consumption. That is a good reason for looking to see if something better is possible.
David Marsland argues that most of the evils of the free market system exist in other known systems, and generally in worse forms. That is true.
But if it is true that poverty on a great scale existed in all previous cultures, I do not think that is good reason for saying that we must stick with what we have today. Poverty has not been eradicated. The living standards of the poor have been going down.
In the US, the average level of real wages has been going down since the 1970s. In many parts of the Third World, real wages have gone down by 25-30% since the debt crisis of the early 1980s. In Eastern Europe and the USSR there is a mass pauperisation.
Poverty today is not a marginal consideration. Even if you think it will decrease, how many generations are you prepared to see live out their lives in these conditions?
Why did this poverty and this inhumanity exist in previous systems? Until quite recently, the level of human industry and technology was not sufficient to meet the needs of the entire population. If you took what was produced and shared out equally, it would not provide a comfortable life for all. That was true for thousands of years.
If there is not enough, then either you have an overlord deciding who gets enough and who does not; or you have a more impersonal system. such as the market.
Historically, the market was the mechanism which produced progress. It was more progressive than having an overlord decide.
However, the pre-condition does not hold now. If you took the total production of the world now, and divided it up equally you would get an average amount per head roughly equivalent to the average national income of Portugal. The average better-off worker in Portugal is not starving. They are not living in splendour, but they have the basics. There is enough produced to give everybody the basic necessities of comfortable life. That is true now. It was not true before.
Now the market system was shaped by the struggle for the basic necessities of life. And food and clothing lend themselves well to the use of market mechanisms.
They can be divided into discrete units consumed by individuals. They can be dealt with well by independent market transactions.
The market begins to break down even tor housing. It breaks down even more if we look at things that make life more than just physical survival.
In the developed capitalist coun tries today, the proportion of the labour time of society needed to produce basic food and clothing is very small. That basic production used to take almost all the labour time of society. With modern technology, it takes very little.
It is no longer necessary for our lives as human beings to be dominated by an unequal system shaped by the struggle for the basics of food and clothing. A more equal şystem, based on democratic planning, is possible.
In the free market, the whims of the rich are more That new system will require other things apart from productive capacity. It demands that people have formed a habit of working together in cooperative units. It demands that we have a relatively high level of literacy and good provision of information, so that people know what is going on sufficiently to plan.
It requires a certain level of culture and civilisation. It is not possible to plan an economy democratically where the majority of the people are illiterate and do not know what's going on outside their own village - or even if they did know, they would not have the level of education and knowledge to make any useful judgements on it.
It requires a certain level of information and education. It requires also, the will to make society different.
Those preconditions created by capitalism, or tions of capitalism.
have argued market system and cruel syste •poch of hur are all are functhat the free is a 1 unequal For a whole nan history, however, it was progressive in terms of what was possible then, but conditions have been created now where something better is possible.
The obvious objection is that the better system has been tried, in the Stalinist states, and those states show the failure of socialist planning.
I would argue that, whatever it was called, Stalinism was not even an attempt at socialist planning. argue this is not a matter of saying "it went wrong" after the event.
If we look back at the criteria and conditions that Marx saw as necessary for the development of socialism, we see that the practices and models of Stalinism were denounced by socialists long before they were ever put into practice.
If we go back a century to the beginning of the mass Marxist movement, one of its main arguments and polemics was against what they called "state socialism". They argued against people who thought that socialism meant control by the state, bureaucratic manipulation of the economy and bureaucratic nationalisation like that being carried out by Bismarck in Germany.
Marxists argued, not after seeing what would happen under Stalin, but in the 1880s and 1890s, that "state socialism" had nothing to do with their socialism.
Socialism, they said, was about democratic planning controlled by the working class. Bureaucratic planning, contrary to the interests of the workers, was anti-socialist. They did not even give qualified support to Bismarckian nationalisations, let alone see them as socialism.
Marxists further argued that the idea of developing socialism in a single country, particularly in a backward country, such as Russia was in 1917, was out of the question. Socialism could be developed only on the basis of the achievements of the most advanced capitalism, and in a much broader framework than a single country. Aain, that are experience ta out after the experience COTE Stalinism. It was argued before anybody in the socialist movement had ever heard of Stalin or Stalinism.
Finally, when Stalin launched into his Stalinist economic policy -and at the start, not after seeing the results - Trotsky and other Marxists condemned the policy as bureaucratic, over-centralised, and foolish in its attempt to do away with market mechanisms far too quickly.
Socialist planning does not mean that we want to do away with free markets straight away. We recognise that the free markets have played a huge role in human development, and cannot be dispensed with overnight.
After a socialist revolution we will have to use markets quite considerably. It will take generations to eliminate them.
On the basis of the evidence, Stalinism was not an attempt at socialist planning. It was bureaucratic planning. It was form of economic organisation which - Marxists had argued long before - represented no advance over capitalism.
Moreover, Stalinism was shaped not by socialist ideas, but much more by economic competition with and emulation of the capitalist West. Stalinism was trying to develop the industry of the Soviet Union in competition with that of the West.
If we want to give credit or discredit for shaping the Stalinist system to socialism or to capitalism then the discredit must go to capitalism.
f socialist planning is nothing to do with Stalinism, how then do I define it? What would socialist planning be, if not 'state socialism'?
From a socialist point of view, the main purpose of socialist planning is quite different. Stalinist planning was about industrial development in competition with the capitalist world. Socialist planning is not primarily about faster economic growth. It is not even primarily about increasing control over the economy.
It is primarily about decreasing the control of the economy over human lives.
Up to now, economic affairs have dominated human life. For a whole epoch, the low level of technology and industry meant that the struggle to get the essentials of life had to dominate human life. Under capitalism the level of technology has made it possible that we could produce the essentials of life without being dominated by the need to do that. under capitalism we are still dominated by economic drives, because capitalist production is organised for profit.
Under capitalism it doesn't matter if enough of this or that is produced. There is always a drive for more profit, for this or that profitable new line of production, for increased pressure on the worker to work more.
In Japan, they have the most tremendous technology, and they could produce the basics of life with a relatively small effort. It would be possible for people to have a relatively leisured and dignified life.
Despite that, something like 70% of Japanese workers say that they constantly feel physically exhausted and mentally exhausted. That is their lives. Their lives are dominated by being exhausted for the sake of profit.
Socialist planning is aimed at ending the dominance of economic concerns over human life. How is that to be done?
The first thing is to cut the working week to a level which enables everybody to have free activity, not to have their lives dominated by what an employer tells them all to do - still less by what the state tells them to do!
We must reduce the drudgery necessary to produce the basics of life. We cannot do away with that drudgery but by mechanisation and automation we can continue the process already developed by capitalism, of reducing the necessary drudgery to a small amount.
We should share that drudgery out equally, so that we don't have some people overworked, some people in idleness and rich, and other people in idleness and poor as under capitalism.
The organisation of that drudgery is the area where planning operates. Socialist planning is not about state planning of people's whole lives.
And even in the area of basic production, we will not be able to plan
Scan page 11
SOCIALISTS ANSWER THE NEW RIGHT social needs straight away. It will solidarity. take generations before the level of We are well aware of the deficientechnology, the degree of informa- cies with which those developments tion and culture, and the spirit of co- have been marked - the deficienoperation have developed enough cies of the existing working class to make the planning of basic movements, the way in which they economic essentials just an ad- are moulded by the society in which Under socialist planning view, the remarkable thing is that everybody would be expected to do capitalism generates a class which their share of the drudgery. When has this capacity to organise, and they have done that they have free consciously to set itself the tasks of time. That free time would not be firstly changing its conditions just like the enforced idleness of within the old society and eventualmany under capitalism. It would be ly substituting a new society. free time on the basis of having the The working class is a class which show diinter fenezas-kie-as-cam Africa: nature brings drought, the market brings starvation ministrative question. essentials of life and on the basis of access to education, culture and so on.
It would be free time we could use for study, for sport, for handicratts, for conversation, for friendship, or if we like just for idling.
Free time - time which is not dominated by economic considerations - is the core of socialism. It would release the time for people to plan their lives decently.
They would not have their lives decided by the free market, where your life can be ruined from one week to the next, and not even by your own fault - not because you are an inefficient worker or an idle worker, but simply because of some shift in demand for your employer's products. T ing. It is utopian? That "hat is how I see socialist planquestion really comes down to: is human nature sufficiently elastic that it can develop the spirit of co-operation and solidarity necessary for such re-organisation?
It is impossible to say yes or no for sure because it has not been tried yet. We will find out whether or not it is possible by trying.
Then the question is, is there a force which will try?
Yes, there is. One of the most important and progressive things about capitalism is that it generates general, it generates it in particular among a particular class, the working class.
The working class in capitalist society is the basic toiling class, similar to the toiling classes in other forms of society. But it is also different. It is the only basic labouring class in human history which has developed permanent organisations based on the principle of they exist. But in a broad historical be managed By David Marsland here is nothing wrong in principle or in general with planning. It depends who is doing the planning, what for, and how.
Individuals and families absolutely need to plan the personal project of their lives carefully and longterm. It is a primary function of the capitalist ethos and an enterprise culture to encourage this.
Many do, but, alas, too many of us have been discouraged from the need for it by the Welfare State, which pretends to make it unnecessary.
Big Brother does people's planning - for their children's education, for the family's health care, for pensions, and so on — very ineffectively. Only the people whose project it is can plan properly for themselves, since no one else can know or understand their wishes, needs, and situation.
Organisations also need to plan if they are to carry out their proper tasks effectively. The larger the organisation the more difficult it is to plan well, so it should be devolved as far as possible, with the centre handling only strategic planning.
Even then there are difficulties due to the inaccessibility, finds itself all the tim like it or not, in class struggl owners of the means of production. It finds itself in that struggle irrespective of what we, or anybody else, wishes.
That class struggle is going to continue, whatever people say about socialism being condemned by the experience of Stalinism. In that class struggle, there is the force which is going to try - at least - to reorganise society on a basis which is not as unequal and as cruel as the free market.
And it is well worth a try. unreliability, and fluctuating state of relevant planning information. Hence the key role of markets, as a source of information - about demand and consumers' preferences - to assist organisations in their planning.
The crucial importance of the market as a handmaiden to organisational planning is demonstrated by the general inadequacy of planning in organisations operating outside any sort of market. A major reason for the gross inadequacy of planning in health care or in education in Britain is their protection within a top-down, command-mode, statecentralist cocoon which insulates them from the information they need and blunts the awareness of managers of the need to plan.
Thus, quite contrary to the socialist analysis, a market is necessary to encourage long-term, strategic thinking. Only when power is devolved to relevant operational levels - schools, hospital trusts, etcetera - and when at least a quasi-market is established, is rational planning at the level of the organisation feasible.
Planning, then, is necessary for individuals, groups, and organisations, and beneficial provided that relevant sorts of information in terms of which to ground planning decisions are available.
Planning, beyond those limited spheres - in state and society - is where the serious difficulties and the key theoretical and political arguments appear.
Both at local state and especially at central state levels grave problems about planning are inevitable, for three distinct reasons. First the scale of activities involved. The larger the context of action, the more problematical planning becomes. secondly the nature anc range of tasks for which the state is responsible.
Generally speaking, the less appropriate for state capacities the tasks taken on by the state, and the wider the range of such tasks, the less effective does planning become. Thirdly, the infeasibility of states operating in a market. State capitalism is a contradiction in terms.
In general terms, wherever states take over tasks better handled by other agencies and a wider rather than a narrower range of tasks, in these conditions the essential planning tasks of the state - and of course there are such, for the interand external protection of citizens, for relations with the governments of other states, and for the management of the law and money - are likely to be handled badly.
Thus at state level too planning is essential and beneficial, but only provided that it is done in a minimal state context, and even then only if it is modest and cautious in the extreme.
In general, subsidiarity requires that state planning • should restricted to tasks in relation to which individuals and groups cannot plan for themselves, and which cannot be handled by organisations independent of the state and operating in markets, preferably Teal markets.
The grounds for this restriction of the state's planning role are twofold. First economic: the state in general plans badly, lacking both the personal involvement and understanding of individuals and groups, and the task specificity and market-driven efficiency of independent, profit-oriented organisations.
Secondly political: if the state, even a democratic state, is allowed control of planning outside its proper sphere, liberty is bound to be dangerously threatened.
Thus there is a perfectly Organiser and very important role for planning in a free society, by individuals, by groups, by organisations, and by the state as well. However, planning should be located appropriately, and at state level limited to essential modest tasks. The economy narrowly defined should be left largely to independent organisations and the market.
So too should much of the economy broadly defined - the production and distribution of goods and services, which of course includes much of what we have been schooled by socialists to call welfare.
The socialist challenge his analysis leaves the state tance of planning by the state, within its proper sphere, is unapologetically acknowledged.
free society needs a strong, confident state capable of carrying out on behalf of its citizens its vital role - including the planning required by that role - effectively and efficiently in a world of unpredictable challenges and dangers.
Despite this, socialists will read it as an expression of an extreme and intolerable market-orientated ideology. Certainly it goes beyond the level of marketisation achieved even by a decade of Thatcherism. It challenges absolutely the concept of the "mixed economy" of the Butskellite era, which postulated considerable state control and planning. And of course it must seem absolutely unacceptable to real socialists of whatever specific persuasion, as a contradiction of their basic principles.
Yet it is, I suggest, a modest proposition. The supporters of capitalism have never suggested that the market should replace planning entirely, or denied the importance of planning by the state in pursuit of its proper objectives. Unfettered capitalism" is a socialist concept intended to subvert liberal capitalist societies, not a liberal concept at all.
By contrast, socialists can never in principle be satisfied with controlling or managing the market. The principled aim of socialism is to supersede the market with alternative mechanisms, expropriate it entirely, and install a planned economy within a planned society. Capitalism requires modest but effective "fettering" of the market: socialism relies on "unfettered command", that is to say the replacement of the market by planning.
And of course we know why socialists want this. Their analysis exposes markets as inherently inefficient and unjust. It reveals profit as inevitably exploitatative. It condemns competition as wasteful and as destructive of the character of those involved in it. It condemns capitalism, defined essentially by profit-driven competitive markets, as incapable of serving people's real needs, as requiring and reproducing intolerable inequality, and in short as a morally repugnant system serving the real interests of no one save capitalists.
My answer to this socialist challenge to capitalism, and to the demand for comprehensive planning deduced from and justified by it, is two-fold. First a response in terms of theory and principle concerning the feasibility of planning. Secondly a pragmatic and practical response in terms of the demonstrated benefits of markets and the consumer sovereignty on which they rely.
However, there is one logically prior point. There is no need to justify markets in principle or in practice if the socialist critique of capitalism is fallacious or substantially exaggerated.
I suggest that, despite the continuing popularity among intellectuals here and in other free societies of socialist ideas, the analysis of capitalism which provides their only justification is erroneous.
The socialist critique manages despite the patent contradiction involved - to condemn capitalism for sustaining and aggravating poverty, and at the same time for maintaining its il legitimate power by bribing and corrupting the people with the fruits of economic progress.
Turn
----- pull-quotes -----
Atuhe Stand Up hor Real ISpciansm" emem on 21 Nowerber,-Martin
important than the desperate needs oi the poor."
•'The marketasiai productive institutiom, emoned nover generations, with which-ve
the desire to improve society. It does not just generate that desire in
1 with an important but restrict- ed planning role. The impor-