The roots of the
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Full-scale fighting between Catholics and Protestants erupted in mid 1969. By 1972 the situation became one of war between the Catholics and the British e them, that the British state in orthern Ireland lacks. It has nory courts, shoot-to-kill squads, ass surveillance, and it has had ininment.
What it lacks 1s willingness to ce the reality that the Northern land unit is untenable, and in the nger term unviable. No amount police-military action will make viable. Without a political soluon, the Catholic-Protestant Lughter will continue, and may calate.
For that reason arguments such the idea that internment is bad It better than sectarian slaughter e radically false. Internment will t be an alternative to slaughter. It Il probably lead to a massive ways it is worse than the lies' criminals there. abour passed the 1949 Act ch entrenched and buttressed irs the Army went round ematically wrecking Catholic Republican prisoners were not Ireland.
escalation of slaughter.
The only way it would not fuel the revolt would be for the British state to use a Stalinist or fascist level of police-state repression against either the Catholics or the whole Northern Ireland population for the next decade or more. And even then - even if internment "worked" -eventually the basic problems would resurface, in 10, 20 or 50 years' time, and the conflict would be reopened.
Labour must oppose internment.
It did no good and much harm 20 years ago. It will solve nothing now.
Northern Ireland needs political solutions, not more state violence against the people.
Catholic people. They allowed them a status in jail different from that of the Labour's Northern Ireland secretary, Roy Mason, tried to criminalise the Kepublican prisoners, and provoked a against such treatment.
Labour Party activists should government actively seek a political ahe basic political problems perspective of Irish and IrishBritish history.
In the 12th century England occupied Ireland, a country with an archaic culture and political system more akin to pre-Roman Britain than to then-contemporary Europe. Feudal ownership and English enclaves were established.
In the 16th and early 17th centuries.
England and Scotland, now Protestant, thoroughly conquered Ireland, but the Irish people remained Catholic. In that age religion was inseparable from politics, and for English rulers the Catholic Irish represented a permanent potential "fifth column" for Catholic powers Europe.
In north-east Ulster, Scots and English colonists were established as the dominant population. Everywher the Catholic Irish were robbed of the land. English landlords took over, ar Catholics became oppressed tenants.
After the last wars of conquest at the end of the 17th century, the Catholic Irish experienced a hundred years under a system very like South African apartheid. They were not allowed to own property in certain places, or above certain values, nor allowed freedom of religion, nor allowed to run schools or to practise professions.
This system, the "Penal Laws", fell into decay towards the end of the 18th century.
In response to the French Revolution of 1789-99, Protestant and Catholic Ireland demanded an independent Irish Republic. French troops landed to support them. There was a defeated rebellion in 1798. Savage repression followed.
In 1800 the British government abolished the Dublin parliament, and united Britain and Ireland. British prime minister Pitt intended to link the Union with full rights for the Catholics. The idiot king George III vetoed Catholic rights. Catholics remained second-class citizens.
Early 19th century Irish history was dominated by the struggle for Catholic equality. "Catholic emancipation" — the right of Catholics to become MPs — was won in 1829.
Then the Catholic middle class began to demand a restoration of the Dublin parliament. Northern Irish Protestants had opposed Union in 1800, but now, fearful of being a minority in a new Irish parliament dominated by the aroused Catholic middle class, they became pro-Unionist.
In the last third of the 19th century, the Catholic tenants organised against the still predominant power of the Anglo-Irish landlords. Eventually they forced British governments to enact a series of measures to curtail the landlords' power and then buy them state.
out.
A system of alliances grew up in the British Parliament, in which Catholic Irish MPs looked to the Liberals (then the main party of the industrial bourgeoisie) and Protestants to the Tory party (then closely linked with landlord interests)The Tories bitterly opposed even a Dublin parliament with limited powers ("Home Rule"'), which the Liberals under Gladstone advocated from 1886. In the months before World War 1, when the Liberals were about to enact Home Rule, the Tories and the Northern Ireland Protestants prepared for armed rebellion, importing guns from Germany up to the eve of the outbreak of war.
The Liberal Government surrendered. They decided to partition Ireland. They betrayed their Irish Home Rule allies.
The victory for Tory-Protestant rebellion reinforced the idea that "force was the only way" in Catholic Ireland. At Easter 1916 there was an armed rising in Dublin, bloodily repressed.
In the November 1918 general election, the Irish nationalist party Sinn Fein stood on a pledge to secede from Westminster and set up a Dublin parliament. They won 75 per cent of the seats, on 50-odd percent of the vote, and in January 1919 set up their parliament in Dublin, "Dail Eireann"
War followed, in which, after 1920, Britain used large-scale terror, including the burning of small towns and the centre of Cork City.
The war ended in 1921. Ireland was partitioned, with Home Rule governments in both Belfast and Dublin.
The Southern "Home Rule" state soon gained real independence. In the Northern state, the Six Counties, ther was a one-third Catholic minority. Th Protestants of all Ireland would have been a lesser minority in a united Ireland.
The Northern Catholics were for a united Ireland; the Six County state saw them as a threat, and they saw that state as an alien imposition on them.
They were "kept down" by special laws and special constables. They were discriminated against in employment, in housing, and in voting.
In the South, the Catholic majority enacted Catholic laws obnoxious to the Protestant minority there, abolishing divorce for example.
For fifty years there were only sporadic stirrings from the Northern Catholics. Then in the late 1960s they started a vigorous civil rights movement. This triggered a Protestan backlash and repression by the Six County state.
Full-scale fighting erupted in mid1969. For almost 50 years British governments had largely ignored Northern Ireland. Now they sent the British Army on to the streets to take direct control.
11916 Movements dedicated to achieving an independent united Ireland by military conspiracy had existed since the mid 19th century, but by the 1960s were feeble. Now the "Provisional IRA" split off and began to build towards a military campaign against the British Army. Internment in August 1971 transformed the situation into one of all-out war between the Catholics and the British state.
In March 1972, the Belfast parliament was abolished. Britain tried to create a Catholic-Protestant "power-sharing" government in Belfast in 1973-4, but was defeated a Protestant general strike. British direct rule has been the system ever since.
Northern Ireland was set up to give Protestants "democracy" against the Catholic majority of all Ireland. But for 20 years the Protestants have not been allowed to exercise that democracy because it would most likely be used, as in the past, against the Northern minority.
There has been a system of interlocking vetoes, both backed by the threat or the use of force. The Protestants have a veto on any move: to a united Ireland; the Catholics a veto on any restoration of Protestant majority government in Belfast.
In 1985 an Anglo-Irish Agreement was signed, setting up joint LondonDublin political control in Northern Ireland, with direct physical control remaining in the hands of Britain. It has been one more way of freezing the situation.
Northern Ireland - as it existed when it could exist without British troops on the streets - broke down irretrievably 20 years ago. What exists now is the political debris, and in that debris the people live and struggle.
Only a radical political rearrangement can end the CatholicProtestant confrontation and the killing.
No solution that keeps the Norther Ireland Catholics trapped in an artificial Protestant-dominated unit can be stable or democratic. "Self-determination for the Protestants" is impossible without bloody civil war and repartition; but the distinct identity and allegiance of the Protestant community must be accommodated as far as is compatible with the democratic rights of the majority of the people of Ireland as a whole.
The only way of reconciling the rights of both communities is through a federal united Ireland, with regional autonomy for the Protestant-majority area in the north-east, maximum local autonomy for all local communities, and free confederal ties with Britain.
Such a policy can be the basis for uniting workers from both Catholic and Protestant communities, and both North and South, and thus for creating the united working-class movement which alone can create a free and democratic Ireland.
Scan page 10
SOCIALISTS ANSWER THE NEW RIGHT Socialist Organiser No. 508 page
----- pull-quotes -----
Talented only to thee understood only in the