[Britain has exercised direct Brule in Northern Ireland…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Britain has exercised direct Brule in Northern Ireland for almost 20 years now, since the Belfast Home Rule parliament was abolished in March 1972. Yet, after 20 years ot direct rule, Northern Ireland is once more experiencing a sickening eruption of sectarian slaughter — Catholic killing Protestant, Protestant killing Catholic, Catholic killing Protestant again and so on, and so on.
British direct rule - supplemented, as it has been since November 1985, by a measure of political power-sharing in Northern Ireland between Britain and the Dublin government - has been and is an abject and vicious failure.
Could there be a greater condemnation of the last 20 years than the continued paramilitary grass roots warfare and the new spiral of killing?
Yes, there could! The news that the British government is thinking seriously of bringing back internment without charge or trial!
The sudden discussion of internment in the press and on TV as "the answer" is the government testing opinion and trying to prepare it. This time, the message is, internment would work. Unlike last time.
"Last time" was 9 August 1971. There had been a few killings in the first half of the year by the newly established Provisional IRA, Which began in December 1969-January 1970 as a right-wing breakaway from the then mainstream Republican Movement. Belfast still had its own parliament, with a Protestant government under Brian Faulkner.
In Britain, Edward Heath's Tory government was in power. Early on the morning of 9 August, in a tragic-comic parody of a South American coup, soldiers and RUC policemen descended on hundreds of Catholics all across the 6 Counties. Without charge or trial, men were arrested and in many cases horribly ill-treated.
Taken away half-dressed, Catholics were forced to walk on broken glass or stone under the blows of unleashed soldiers and policemen, and taken aloft in helicopters for "in depth" interrogation at police and army centres. Many of them were tortured.
All of those taken were Catholics. The pretext was that they were all paramilitaries, all members of the IRA. Probably a majority of them had nothing to do with the IRA.
The leaders of the student civil rights movement were arrested, illtreated, and interned — Michael Farrell, for example, who was then politically a sympathiser of the British SWP (then called IS).
The hard-pressed Unionist government of Brian Faulkner and the sectarian RUC had drawn up lists of names designed to settle accounts with all their opponents; political as well as military, socialist as well as Republican.
That is what they had always done before. Internment had been normal in the Six Counties of Northern Ireland through the state's 50 year history. It had been used in the '20s, the "30s, the '40s, and the '50s. It was used in the South, too, in every decade except the "30s.
In 1971 internment seemed to be just business as usual for the RUC and the Unionist Establishment. But they were seriously mistaken.
n previous decades the Catholic minority were a beaten and partly cowed people. In the '60s they had come back on to their feet, inspired by such experiences as the black civil rights movement in the USA, asserting their right to equality and fair treatment.
In 1969 they had driven the RUC out of Catholic Derry and out of parts of Catholic Belfast, and built walls of makeshift barricades to keep them out.
Internment did not cow the Catholics. It roused them — one third of Northern Ireland's population — into a general outraged revolt.
Before internment the Provisional IRA was a weak and faltering movement. Afterwards it had the active or passive support of perhaps a majority of Northern Ireland Catholics, and much sympathy in the South and outside Ireland.
Strengthened by the effects of internment on the Catholic people, the Provisional IRA was now able to go on a large-scale offensive. Northern Ireland became ungovernable. Bombings and killings multiplied tenfold in the next year.
Catholic areas barricaded Police state repression in Northern Ireland. In vehicles are set alight to mark the anniversal themselves off once more, and then the British Army smashed the barricades. In the next two years, following up the British Army terror against the Catholics, hundreds of people - mostly Catholics — were murdered in often random sectarian killings by Protestant paramilitaries.
nternment in 1971 was one of the great disasters of modern Irish history - except for the Proviespecially if it were to be introduced in the South simultaneously. (And it might well be: the last time they had internment in the South, after 1957, it was introduced by Charles Haughey's Fianna Fail, "the Republican party").
The short answer is that nobody knows what effect internment would have, whether it would prove to be sand or petrol on the fires that have proved unquenchable in the last 20 years. It would be a giant gamble at the very least.
For example, nobody knows what the reaction would be in the Protestant community to a largescale attempt to round up the UDA.
The assumption that the IRA is "a few hundred men" is classic British policeman's blindness. It makes it impossible to understand where the present IRA - which mushroomed from almost nothing to mass support in a matter of months - came from in the first place.
It came from the ingrained Republican tradition in the Northern Ireland Catholic communities, and from their need for self-defence.
On that, certainly, were superimposed the concerns and the militarist strategies of a comparatively small para-military sect. But variants of that para-military sect had existed for all the 50 years of the Northern Ireland state. What was new 20 years ago was the mass revolt of the Catholics.
That has not gone away, nor is it artificially kept in being by the Catholic para-militaries.
Either the interners would act according to the plainly false belief that the problem is a few hundred Provisionals, pick up some or most of them, and then find the militarist organisation replenished manifold tion to y internmale of ther elsethey would recognise that the paramilitaries are not a thin crust to be skimmed oft, and once more they would go in for wholesale terrorisation of the Catholic ghettoes.
Such wholescale terror was British policy — under the Labour governments especially -throughout the later 1970s. It would bring no more progress now than it brought then. It would inevitably build up the para-militaries.
Either way, internment is unlikely to "work" in its own terms. It is only a new police gimmick, a recipe for increased repression to tackle a situation characterised above all by the failure of a policy of repression, and a situation which is implicitly a condemnation of the longstanding British policy of reliance on repression, supplemented only by political initiatives of a cripplingly limited sort such as the 1985 DublinLondon treaty.
There is a more basic reason why labour movement activists in Britain should oppose internment. Police-state repression can not possibly solve what ails Northern Ireland.
It is not police power, military power, or the will and expertise to