[operative commonwealth is far from lal "To talk…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
operative commonwealth is far from lal "To talk about regulating economic me ana yer evaue the question of the nationalisation of the banks means either betraying the most profound ignorance or deceiving the *common people by florid words and grandiloquent promises with the deliberate intention of not fulfilling these promises"
In South Africa, the banks and mining finance houses have financed development according to the dictates of Apartheid-Capitalism. Nationalisation of these enterprises will give the state direct control over the surplus. We agree with the ANC and COSATU who say that if these enterprises remain privately-owned invest their *They will funds overseas, in financial speculation, in socially undesirable projects or in new mines, factories and aori-husinesses using the old apartheid-based work processes".
The reason for this is self-evident. We have seen that there are a small number of giant monopolies which, because of their huge economic power, (their abiliDe merk: happy to tame the blaci workers' movement with the help of the ANC ead. ty to dispose of the surplus cained throuch the exploitation of labour power), are able to shape development and thus subvert a coherent plan.
We have heard the argument that the power of these conglomerates can be curbed only if we "break them up" But this only applies if your goal is limited to regulating capitalism, not challenging its rule. On its own, such a move does little to forward the struggle for socialism. To "break up" the monopolies assumes that the state does not own or effectively control them.
At a more fundamental level, we recognise that the laws of motion of capitalism move inexorably towards monopolisation, as firms always seek to reduce the effect of competition on the price of their own products. And while it is true that curbing the monopoly power or the big cartels and conglomerates may increase competition which may help to keep prices more stable through the checks and balances of "supply and demand", it has little or no impact on the exploitation of labour power. Indeed, as many workers have found to their cost, wages and conditions are often far worse in smaller firms in a highly competitive market situation. •In addition to these tWo vital areas, a nationalisation programme must also include Health, Education, Transport, Utilities, and Housing Services.
course, nationaliheights does not constitute a sort of magic formula which would ensure "automatically" a regular and harmonious growth of production, the adaptation of the latter to social needs and so on. As we have already said, it is a necessary condition, but not a sufficient one. What is further needed, is to ensure, under concrete conditions, the effective socialisation of the means of production, which implies among other things, efficient accounting, allocation and management under the control of an incipient proletarian state.
Socialisation does not only mean a workers' state con"We would prioritise nationalisation the four main monopolies [Anglo-American the Rembrandt Group, Sanlam and SA Mutual] the land and the banks."
trolling the economy, but also workers controlling their workplaces. The term, "workers' control" can be used in a variety of ways. It can refer to workers establishing, through trade union action, some measure of control over their immediate working conditions. This is a step forward and should always be fought for, but in itself it does not change the capitalist system.
Workers' control can also refer to workers' participation in capitalist management through trade union representatives on the board of directors. This is generally a trap where unions are lured into collaboration with the bosses.
The sense in which we use "workers" control signifies workers' control of society as a whole. It is this and only this form of workers' control which is the foundation of the building of real socialism. Without workers' control of the state, workers' control at the level of the workplace will not be effective. Nor will it last because it is the state which guides and controls the interrelations between the economic establishments and has the power to enforce decisions.
On the other hand, workers' power at the level of the state which is not accompanied by workers' control of the workplace, will likewise fail. This is because managerial layer or caste will persist in industry, which sooner or later will use its economic power to wrest political power from the workers.
Workers' control t is not possible to provide a blueprint as to how such workers' power will come about. But we know enough from past workers' struggles to suggest a broad outline.
Mass workplace meetings can elect delegates to area workers' councils; which in turn can send delegates to the national or central workers' councils. This network of councils could constitute the core of the state. The workers' militia and all other bodies for the defence and administration of the state will be responsible and accountable to the workers' councils. Workplace meetings may also elect committees for the management of individual enterprises.
These committees, in turn, send delegates to industrial and national boards for economic coordination and planning where they work with trade unions which also have a central role to play in industrial management.
Such structures, once working effectively, will lay the basis for a genuine transi NIS tion to democratic socialism. To put it simply, it is out of this process that we will decide whether to make school desks for use or surfboards for profits.
How will workers' control manage the economy? For example, there could be regular congresses of workers and popular councils to determine the division of the national product. Of course, the choices must be clearly spelt out, l.e. the length of the working week, priority needs to be satisfied for all through guaranteed allocation of resources, volume of resources devoted to growth, money incomes, pricing of goods. The framework of the economic plan would therefore be established on the basis of conscious choices by a majority of those affected by it. A coherent plan would be drawn up indicating resources available to each separate branch of production (industry, transport, agriculture, distribution) and social life (health, education, communication, leisure, retirement etc.)
Self-managing bodies for example, congresses of workers' councils in the food, electronic equipment: steel and energy industries would divide up the workload flowing from the general plan among the existing producer units. The product mix would flow from previous consultations between the workers' councils and consumers' conferences elected by the mass of citizens. Administration would no longer be monopolised at the "central level" , any more than selfmanagement confined to plant level.
We don't expect workers to immediately be sufficiently skilled and have the necessary experience to run all facets of industry. Management will therefore temporarily have certain functions. But the important point is that these must be under the control of workers' committees who watch the managers" ever step and carm from manager if s/he engages in activities aimed at sabotaging production.
For these managers, the rule "he who does not work, neither shall he eat" applies. Workers' democracy or us, then, the class anarchy and brutality of market capitalism is not command planning, nor welfare planning; the real alternative, indeed the only acceptable alternative for the working class is a workers' socialist democracy.
In a market economy, (in any of its forms, including a so-called "mixed economy") decisions about production and distribution cannot be taken by the producers. They are dictated behind their backs by the laws of motion of capitalism itself, of unbridled profit-making by the few.
A democratic planning process, although calling for a central plan to ensure that the overarching social needs are prioritised, is one which allows for decentralisation and devolution of decision-making. This extends down to the workplace and community, so that working class control over the means of production and distribution takes on real meaning. The beginning of socialist transition To achieve this requires first that the working class lead its allies in an anti-capitalist revolution - one which goes far beyond the end of racial domination.
The working class must achieve a decisive victory against the capitalist class and bring the most important parts of the economy under the control of the workers We have no illusions that such a fundamental change can take place through negotiations. Indeed, we think it is unrealistic to believe that simply with black majority rule and a certain mix of plan and market can we reform a (capitalist) post-apartheid South Africa into a socialist society by gradual degrees. The whole recent history of southern Africa shows otherwise.
Those who speak of capitalism with a human face are sadly deluded. Capitalism is about the drive to accumulate, about profits and competition. It is not about liberating the working class from their misery. Our position is one of support for reforms but not in order to help capitalism be more efficient at exploiting workers.
We support all reforms which strengthen the position, including the material situation, of the working class in our struggle against the rule of capital.
Scan page 6
nis
----- pull-quotes -----
WITH ROE
FORES OTHE CUSTOMAR ANDS ON