Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Trades Cour despair?

Socialist Organiser no. 508, 21 November 1991 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,793 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Only ten years ago the Trades Council was the hub of the local trade union movement. Every halfway active, self-respecting union branch was affiliated. The monthly meetings attracted a regular 80 or 90 delegates. It was the first place that workers in dispute looked to for support. Resolutions were hard-fought, and the votes would be In short, it was the main forum of debate for the local labour movement, and a central focus for rank and file trade union organisation. Now, it seems, they are doing well if the meeting is quorate. There are few resolutions and fewer proposals for activity. So what has gone wrong?

Obviously, part of the answer is simply the clobbering that trade unionism as a whole has taken over the past decade. But there is more to it than that.

As late as 1984-5, the Trades Council was organising packed meetings in support of the miners, and was the cornerstone of a vigorous Miners' Support Committee, involving activists from every union and across the political spectrum from right-wing Labour to revolutionary left. The rot seems to have set in some time during the late 1980s.

In fact, I think that I can pinpoint the exact moment when the Trades Council ceased to be a serious representative trade union body. It was at a meeting in 1987 when a resolution calling for free abortion on demand was under discussion. All the speakers had been in favour, and it looked as though the resolution would go through on the Then, towards the end of the discussion, an EETPU delegate — a black person, as it happens, and an opponent of the Hammond regime - spoke up against the resolution. He stated that, apart from his personal reservations, his branch had never discussed the issue and that he could not, therefore, vote in favour of the resolution.

There was general outrage from the floor of the meeting. The delegate was heckled and eventually shouted down. It occurred to me at the time that this EETPU delegate undoubtedly represented a substantial body of opinion within the trade union movement as a whole. Something was badly wrong if he could not express a honestly held viewpoint without being shouted down.

What had happened was that the "left" (members and ex-members of groups like the SWP and the IMG) had come to regard the Trades Council as a kind of alternativ party or extension of "the party", with an implicit "line' on a whole range of questions - from racism through abortion to Ireland - that in some cases had never been debated. And dissent from that "line" was beyond the Since then, delegates from industrial unions have gradually disappeared. Meetings have become dominated by NUT, NALGO, NATHE, and the NUPE Social Services branch. The Trades Council has become the "property" of a clique of professional lefties. Where industrial branches bother to maintain their affiliation, either they do not appoint delegates or the delegates do not attend.

Maybe the tide will turn once the industrial struggle picks up again. But I for one find myself in the embarrassing position of wishing that more right wing delegates would attend. Then, at least, when the left won a vote on a "difficult" issue, it would count for something.

ran into the Chair of my local Trades Coun- INSIDE cil recently. He always used to be one of those THEEUNIONS up-and-at-'em types, full of bright new ideas and boundless energy.

But now he seemed like man in despair. "I do not know what has gone wrong", , he whimpered. *No-one bothers to turn up any more, affiliations have fallen right off, we're almost bankrupt. I think the Trades By Sleeper Council is going down the tubes, to be honest"

reported in the local press. nod. pale.

Pd from the base The organised black working class has been at the forefront of the large percentage of black struggle against workers are at the very least apartheid over the skilled workers in all fields of decade. the economy.

Now, as the regime welcomes the ANC to the negotiating table, a major debate is opening up within the ranks of their exploitation and oppresthe workers' movement on what 'PostApartheid' South Africa will look like.

Salim Vally - an activist from the for Socialist Action people, that (WOSA) - argues for democratic workers' control through nationalisation as a vital part of the struggle for workers" tom of the pile. rule. He was speaking at an economics workshop held by the million-strong union federation COSATU our country, for reasons connected with the technical problems of diamond and gold mining, racism, racial discrimination, racial oppression, segregation became for the last jority — the working class. quarter of the 19th cehtury and for most of the 20th century, a necessary aspect of the production of profit and thus of the capitalist system. The main features tion. of this system are: 1) At the top of the system is a powerful group of men and women, the white redistribution of wealth. capitalist class. They own and control all the means of pro- many countries around the duction, distribution and exchange e.g., mines, factories, farms, banks, building ountries of eastern Europ societies, shops, super- ind even in South Africa markets etc. The main pur- certain sectors of the pose is to produce profit. economy have been owned by 2) At the bottom of this the state, yet wealth and control have remained in the system are some millions of black workers who own hands of the few. In fact, nanothing but their ability to tionalisation has, in some inwork. Until the middle of the stances, been used'as a form 'sixties, the vast majority of of disciplining workers. the black workers were un- (Remember Kaunda's skilled labourers. Today this famous dictum to the copis no longer the case. A very perbelt miners, *Now that you own the mines, there is no need to strike against semi-skilled; many are highly yourselves!")

Who controls the state?

The overwhelming division ut the really vital in the system of racial capitalism between "white" and "black" has given rise te is, if the state controls situation where black the banks, industry and a workers see the reason for wide range of social services, who controls the sion in the fact that they are black rather than that they are workers. However, if our Socialism is not just an struggle is not directed at economic change, but a removing capitalism as such political one as well. The as well as racial oppression, capitalists hold power in two the simple fact of the matter ways: not only and most imis that under the historical portantly) do they control the conditions of South Africa, where 95% of all productive "The really vital question for which is produced and social or class inequality workers is, if the reproduced in every capitalist state controls society, will continue to be reproduced as largely as the banks, racial inequality. That is to that most black people industry and a South Africa has one of the highest concentrations of who controls the wealth in the hands of a small minority of any country in the world. It is well known that almost 80% of the economy directly, but also economy is owned and con they protect their interests trolled by a handful of large politically through their inmonopolies. Barely 0.1% of fluence and control of the he population (or a mer state. Unless that state is 360 families) own and cor smashed, and equally importrol a large part of thi tant something set up to wealth Leaving these replace it, the bourgeoisie will monopolies untouched in a not really have its power future society means not taken away. As long as the allowing control of the capitalists control the state, wealth of society by the ma- then any industry which is nationalised will serve the inThere is general agreement terests of the bosses. No within the liberation move- amount of nationalisation ment, the maior can bring socialism without monopolies which dominate workers' power. the economy and our lives It must be emphasised that cannot remain untouched nationalisation on the basis and that there should be of a capitalist state means some measure of nationalisa- these enterprises will become state capitalist parts of a From the outset, we must capitalist economy, not be clear that nationalisation "havens of socialism" within in itself will not guarantee the it.

Over the last 60-70 years in Nationalisation under workers' power world, for example in Britain, the Soviet Union, the For WOSA, nationalisation is a vital first step which will allow us to develop society where there is democratic co Itrol over the planned production of social wealth, its distribution, exchange and consumption. This goal cannot be achieved without eliminating progressively the private ownership of wealth. Nationalisation, at least of the commanding heights of the economy, is absolutely essential.

Nationalisation is necessary in order for the new workers' state to have the capacity to plan production more effectively for the goals of economic growth and the satisfaction of need. It will allow the workers' state to have greater control over the development of industry, that is, decisions can be made as to which sectors are most important for economic growth. The new state can direct resources more efficiently, it can turn major industries to producing for the good of the population rather than Just for profit.

Nationalisation is also necessary in order for society to produce goods at levels which can satisfy the fundamental social needs of the majority a task which capitalism refuses to carry out). We are talking here of basic food and drink, clothing, shelter, running water, electricity, sanitation and standard comforts linked to it (bedding, furniture) as vell as education and health provision, guaranteed transport to and from the workplace, and a level of recreation and leisure indispensable to the reproduction of labour power. (While we recognise these basic needs to be the priorities, they are only a starting point beyond which we will develop as circumstances permit).

What do we mean by the "commanding heights" of the economy?

We would prioritise nationalisation of the four main monopolies (which would include most of the mines as well as most of manufacturing industry, the land and the banks.

Nationalisation of banks The banks are centres nerve centres of the whole capitalist economic system. According to Lenin:

Scan page 5

Organiser management's experience. These workers' committees would not only have the right to appeal against the orders of management, but could also secure the removal of a

----- pull-quotes -----

Workers' Organisation peat, read by ormal"

will continue to be at the bot- wide range of social services,

of modern economic life, the principal

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 508

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →