Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Arab Volunteers accepted in the Libyan Arab armed forces

Socialist Organiser no. 507, 14 November 1991 · scan pp. 14–15 · about 785 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

(Our emphasis). Connection" , a crazy ways and the British Overseas Newsline upon Zionist imperialism to . The question of the hour, we 3-0* glorying Saddam 419790 antis recruits to the Libyan ar The debate on Palestine.

Zionism and anti-semitism (including "Trotsky and Zionism")

£1.80 A Workers' Liberty pamphlet Debate on Palestine, Zion and antı-semıtısm d anti-semiti £1.80 + .80 28p postage from Box 823, Lon SE15 4NA de self-satisfied sneers and clichés about "sectarians" distinct from broad "democratic" organisations his own; but the point here, David Rosenberg, is that by way of Charlie Pottins your "non-sectarian", "democratic" , all-inclusive organisation was annexed as convenient camouflage by the most vicious sectarians in the history of the British labour movement. Your virtuously anti-Leninist Jewish socialist organisation was used as a cover by anti-semites!

This seems to me to have a bearing on the dispute between the Leninists and the others about how best socialists shoul organise, and I said so. Ah, says Rosenberg, so you questio the right of a group of Jews to define themselves? Is this because of hostility to Jews?

According to the anythinggoes rules of Octopus polemic, there is nothing weird in Rosenberg, defending Pottins, and himself for tolerating Pottins's links with the crazy antisemites, thus turning things on their head and accusing those of us who fought the real and open "left" anti-semites of... anti-semitism. It's all in the game. But it is not serious.

The reference to antisemitism is a two-edged weapon for Rosenberg because I think one of the reasons why people like himself tolerated having a member in common with Gerry Healy's WRP was that they have not faced the fact that the 'anti-Zionism" of the left is currently the most important form of anti-semitism in Britain.

number of questions A are entangled in Rosenberg's defence of the "Bundist" JSG: the sort of organisation that socialists of any sort should build; whether ethnic or national minority groups should organise separately from the rest of the socialist and labour movement; if there is a case for a distinct organisation to work with a certain constituency, whether it should be completely autonomous or a sub-section of the general socialist movement.

This latter question was disputed at the 1903 congress of the Russian Social-Democratic Labour Party, where the majority - including the founder of the Jewish socialist Bund, SURGING FORWARD from the revolun Left: *The Zionist world Zionist conspiracy editorial from the Healyite Matgamna's comment in Socialist Organiser. Above: Charlie Pottins's reply to SO's comments; 1980 ewsline pampile ewsine adverusemer the future Menshevik Julius Martov - wanted the Bund to be a sub-section of the general movement rather than fuily autonomous. I cannot for spac discuss the dispute here. If ther is a case for a separate Jewish socialist organisation, there is no possible case for one so loose that it includes a stooge of anti-semites!

A Jewish socialist organisation which includes a member of Healy's organisation - a political organisation defined its Jewish identity which includes a befuddled stooge of mercenary anti-semites - is surely loose and ill-defined. Saying it is just "democratic" no answer, and neither is a reference to the group's political manifesto. A political programme is not just words on paper; it is the totality of what the organisation does in life.

Yet Leninist truths about loose organisations like the JSG do not answer all the questions raised here.

Sympathy for Charlie Pottins; "tolerance"; philistine dismissal of the dispute between the WRP and SO as "sectarian"; old Bundist obsessions with old anti-Zionist polemics and thus, I guess, the half blindness to the fact that anti-Zionism" is now the cutting edge of anti-semitism, especially on the left; a rare, only-once-ina-life-time, political obtuseness - these are the elements which led them to tolerate Healy's advocate Charlie Pottins as a "much respected" member of the JSG. But what was the mix? And why does Rosenberg mark "tolerance" of "anti-Zionism" a virtue? I wish he would tell uS..

If apotogy is due, then it is due SO from Rosenberg for helping cover for the WRP at a time when they were dragging us through the courts and conducting a lying campaign against us in the labour movement. For myself, I would settle for a plain no-bluster explanation!

Yet the JSG is, I think, owed an apology - from David Rosenberg and any others of its members who knew what Charlie Pottins was doing for Healy and let him get away with it, being all too tolerant" of Healy's crazed anti-semitism and its "anti-Zionist" Jewish stooge Pottins. Or, maybe, they like me would settle for a candid explanation.

Scan page 15

Socialist Organiser No. 507 page 15

----- pull-quotes -----

Arabs, Jews socialism

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 507

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →