Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Octopus School of polemic World Jewish Conspiracy Mr Matgamna This ATURDAT MATGAMNA JOINS The Zionist CHARLES connection

Socialist Organiser no. 507, 14 November 1991 · scan p. 14 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,557 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

More ranting lies from Labour Party right into the centre of mic government of Libya' and seek i Thatcher's government in Downing Jam and Gaddali! This is the posi Chronicle* director of the 'Jewish The same organ supported the Zionist. Ninv. 12 The Tories know they can rely totally bran masses and in support in order to transform the situation, is the pro-Zionist policies David Rosenberg, D whose letter is prineLed on page 11, evidently belongs to the Octopus School of polemi writing.

He comes out kicking and swinging wildly and spewing clouds of ink. Unfortunately, he does not believe in dealing with the real points in dispute: his chosen technique is to lose them in inky clouds of general abuse and hope no-one notices.

Though Rosenberg throws everything he can into this letter, almost all of it is beside the point.

Some of it is mildly paranoid SO has no especially friendly links with the Union of Jewish Students, though we have united and do unite with them against anti-semitism in the National Union of Students. The fact that a young SO supporter took a holiday job the Jewish Socialists' Group [JSG] office six years ago and she was known to be SO -is now cited as a take-over plot!

We do not throw around the charge of anti-semitism loosely. We have argued at length that the dominant attitude to Israel on the left - that it should not exist - leads in practice to a comprehensive hostility to most Jews, who identify with Israel. We have never called anyone or the left an anti-semite without spelling out why in terms of that assessment. Does David Rosenberg think that it is a wrong assessment?

And much of Rosenberg's polemic is silly. Thus, I wrote that the Jewish Socialists' Group [JSG] is politically ill-defined. Back comes Rosenberg to remind us that I, his critic, have used a few pen-names ("pseudonyms") over the years. Now, he demands sternly, who is ill-defined?

I can think of many good things to say about the JSG: the JSG's sharing a platform with the Palestine Liberation Organisation, advocating conciliation, compensates for a lot of the political woolliness exposed in David Rosenberg's letter. But woolliness takes its toll.

Therg reples to said: he article David Rosen"The JSG I'S) a-political solidarity with Pottins meant that they allowed themselves to be used as camouflage for Healy's WRP, who were the paid agents of Q. Why did they subsidise Healy?

A. For a number of reasons: to have an English-language propaganda organ putting their point of view, and because Healy provided other services for them.

Q. What other services?

A. According to the WRPers who fell out with Healy in 1985, Healy's WRP was contracted to spy on Arab dissidents in Britain and to provide reports on Jews prominent in British life. Healy helped get a number of Iraqi Pers shot in 1980, it seems.

Q. Did outsiders have to wai until the WRP broke up to know these things?

A. Not at all! It was obvious from the WRP's press that the! were paid propagandists. For example, they published in 198 a glossy pamphlet about the ris to power of Saddam Hussein that might have been produced by the Iraqi government, and surely was paid for by that government. They publicly justified in their press the killing of the Iraqi CPers mentioned above.

Q. What grounds are there for the charge that the Healy WRP were anti-semitic, and no just anti-Zionist?

A. They printed rabid worl Jewish/Zionist conspiracy" explanations of events. See, for example, the editorial in the illustration accompanying this article. Some of the stuff, abou the world Zionist conspiracy stretching from SO to Reagan's White House for example, was on the level of open clinical lunacy. It was unmistakeably modelled on the old "world Jewish conspiracy" , With "Zionist" substituted for "Jewish".

When the BBC put out a mild programme about the Healy WRP's financial links with Libya, Newsline conducter a months-long campaign accusing *Zionists in the BBO of smearing them - and accusing SO too, because in reviewing the programme SO had said it was only part of the truth.

Q. Specifically, what did Charlie Pottins do in this connection?

A. When I wrote a short piece in SO about the antisemitism of the WRP, in response to the crazy Newsline editorial about the "world Zionist conspiracy", Pottins wrote, or at least lent his name to, a three-page diatribe against SO and in defence of the WRP It was later included in a WRP pamphlet.

Pottins's membership Never in proving this. recent appointment of Mr Stuart Party. man of the BBC, youngest-ever chair brother of Mr David Young, another governor only since 1981. He is the man of the Manpower Services Com- chairmission.

This is the key organisation which the !. 1 years upwards into a slave seek to mobilise jobless youth from wages, safety procedures and working conditions rolled out these appointments with Labour Party and TUC chiefs have accepted them without a murmur of for (983). March 28.

duce the proat a later datains WRP allowed people who explained world events by "Zionist conspiracies" stretching across the globe into both the cabinets of imperialist powers and the editorial board of SO, to more plausibly deploy a hypocritical ir dignation against the patently true charge that they were engag ing in anti-semitic agitation.

The Healy WRP, too, belonged to the "ink in the eyes" school of polemic. The "much respected" Charlie Pottins — if it was Charlie Pottins; but certainly it was Charlie Pottins's name on the polemic — was particularly indignant because I wrote somewhere that the Jewish community might rightly see ti WRP as future pogromists, an its agitation as the preparation of pogroms. From a "much respected" member of the Jewish Socialists' Group, that indignation was probably very useful.

Q. Did the JSG do anything about these activities by Charl Pottins?

A. Not in public they didn't nor, as far as i can judge, was anything done in private. The JSG allowed him both to fron for the anti-semitic agitation o the WRP and to be in the JSG Q. Did the "non-sectarian" JSG, whose other members ha as much right to autonomy as did Charlie Pottins, denounce the WRP, or take any specific stand against it?

A. Not that I know of. In response to the BBC programme on their finances, the WRP for months ran a half-page or page a day of testimonials to themselves, denouncing SO as "Zionists" and "agents", ete. They had the public support of promines leftists like Ken Livingstone; they even got trade union branches and Trades Councils to pass resolutions denouncing uS.

While all this was going on, the JSG's contribution to the fight against anti-semitism in the labour movement was to provide the wkr with a captive wInn 342. - -49. "Jewish socialist" , David Rosenberg's "much respected" Charlie Pottins.

Q. Has tne JSG reconsidered any of this?

A. No. Its leaders do not even seem to have taken it in.

Q. What is the evidence for that opinion?

A. David Rosenberg's ing to speak for 'lefts' in the Labour IRAT March 20. They wrote: "We ('Secialist tell Organiser') dide't wait for the BBC te - BBC now says It doesn't make it c less Ilkely to be true.' (April 7, 1983)

Here is unqualified support for the , director of British Caledonian Air Organiser has landed tell neat bang in the middle of Thateber's hunting the WRP and the News Line imperialism our principled stand against and Thatcher nde Rosenberg is bitterly Rangry at what I wrote concerning the strange story of how the JSG's "much respected" and "highly valued" member Charlie Pot-l tins was used by the anti-semiti WRP.

Yet Rosenberg does not even try to deal with what I wrote except by a few flat assertions.

He neither refutes the facts I alluded to and here spell out, nor seriously disputes the construction I put on them. Essentially, he confines himself to telling us that Pottins was "much respected" and was the only JSG member also to be in "The JSG tolerated a member in common with Gerry Healy's WRP because they have not faced the fact that the 'antiZionism' of the left the most important form of anti-semitis in Britain"

the Healy WRP. ("Just one.

We only had one stooge of tl anti-semites in the JSG. Just one little muddlehead, Guv'nor!")

Rosenberg does not notice that here he reinforces the mystery I described: for how could the Jewish Socialists' Group, of all people, "respect"

Charlie Pottins - even if they felt sympathy with him, a man torn by terrible contradictions and conflicts, as I do, having known him since we were both troubled adolescents - when he was up to his neck in Healy's dirty anti-Jewish propaganda?

I queried their "tolerance" of Pottins; Rosenberg "explains"

it by saying that Pottins was "much respected". It is not an answer; it raises an additional question.

What is oddest about Rosenberg's letter is that he seems to believe it is a sufficien answer. It is as if he does not realise that there is anything ou of the ordinary in this extraordinary story.

In face of the facts cite, he contents himself with few litTripoll, Muharram 3, man.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 507

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →