Civil war in the Young Socialists
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Jack Cleary continues his series on the seedbed of today's left. Earlier articles have described how the Labour youth movement was relaunched after 1959. The labour movement was dominated by the right wing. but being livened up by the nuclear disarmament movement. In the Young Socialists, radical factions came to the fore: Keep Left, associated with Gerry Healy's group (then sectarian, but not yet crazy). Young Guard (dominated by the future SWP of Tony Cliff and Militant.
hroughout 1961 the YS slowly. At the Blackpool Labour disarmament, overthrowing the prounilateral resolution of the 1960 Brighton conference.
The experience of an important lett victory then, which the left (like Michael Foot and Frank Cousins) did nothing to consolidate, and thus lost, was a decisive one for the Healy tendency. Not to emulate the 'fake left' -Foot and the Tribune-ites — but to fight the battle against the right wing through to the end, became their driving goal in the youth movement.
They began to talk and act as if all that was necessary to defeat the right was the will to do it — as if the relationship of forces between the Marxists on one side and the right and soft left on the other, could be magically transformed by shouting the right slogans and "demands". In practice, they ignored such questions, and denounced those who said they were impatient as "fainthearts" "sell-outs" ; "fake lefts", "scabs" and "right wing finks"
At the second YS conference, in 1962, there were 356 delegates from 772 registered branches. It reiterated unilateralism, opposed the Tory immigration control Bill then being pushed through Parliament, and demanded that Britain withdraw all troops from overseas and quit all military alliances.
Only three Keep Left supporters were elected to the National Committee; with one supporter of Young Guard. But there was a left, unilateralist majority, which was maybe what spurred Transport House to act.
The right wing got a resolution through conference condemning Keep Left and asking for an investigation into allegations that some of its supporters had used violence against opponents. David Todd; who made the allegations, later retracted them and said that the whole business had been a plot hatched by Gaitskellite MP, George Brown.
In fact violent clashes did occur in London and Glasgow on May Day, when Young Socialists rushed the platforms: those involved were Young Guard (IS), not Keep Left.
In May 1962, following the conference vote and the May Day clashes, Keep Left (which claimed a circulation of 10,500) was proscribed. An investigation was started into Young Guard (which claimed 3,000). Keep Left editor Roger Protz was expelled by St Pancras North Labour Party. In June, four members of the National Committee were suspended: Liz Thompson, Mike Ginsberg and Dave Davis (KL) were eventually expelled, while Malcolm Tallantire (YG) was reinstated. The remaining seven NC members were told to either accept the NEC action or have the YS disbanded.
Keep Left was banned. Young Guard was not. In July 1962 the NEC interviewed YG representatives (among them Keith Dickinson of the Grant tendency) and threatened to ban the paper unless: • YG's 'tone' improved, • YG included in its aims a statement of unconditional support for the return of a Labour government (this was Keep Left policy) and a declaration that the YS was part of the Labour Party, • YG was made open to all YS opinion, • YG ceased to have speakers at readers meetings, as that gave the impression that YG was a faction.
The National Editorial Board of Young Guard, meeting in September, accepted these conditions, stating, "We have always rejected the arguments of those who say that we should be building a faction within the YS. The YS, in its federations etc., has all the necessary organisations which we can utilise for the spreading of socialist ideas"
This was hypocrisy, of course, and just a little obscene in the face of the triumphant Gaitskellite faction. Though it might have been necessary tactical bowing to superior forces, in fact it was also a very pointed differentiation and separation from Keep Left, Gerry Healy: not as nice as he looked of factions, and was moreover, the faction being targetted by the right wing just then.
But it was not only just hypocrisy! They meant it about the Labour Party: the Grantites had a long, long-term entry project; the Cliffites - today's quasi-syndicalist sectarians — explicitly anti-Leninist and recruiting libertarian-minded youth on that basis had an even longer one, more vague and even more indeterminate.
The subsequent editorial in Young Guard explained that at their meeting with the NEC representatives, they "laid great stress on the democratic organisation of the paper and denied being a faction within the YS, pointing to the large disparities in the view between YG supporters". Read: 'unlike the Trotskvists'. In fact. Keen Left too had a general meeting open to its supporters, though operating under tight control. When all is said and done, what Young Guard said about the differences between the two factions, was true.
The Cliffites would remain an open, democratic organisation until the special conference of December 1971, which barred factions which had basic differences with the group around Tony Cliff.
They had a right to point this out, if it was to their political advantage. To do it at the moment Keep Left was being banned was to repudiate all left solidarity against the right wing and to greatly embitter the already very bad relations within the YS Left.
After this relations between Keep Left and Young Guard were extremely poisoned and rancorous. It did not require malicious invention to put the story in circulation that YG had done a deal with Transport House as the price of tolerance, or for it to be widely believed. Despite Young Guard's statements in defence of the rights of Keep Left, their acceptance by Transport House as the 'good', 'nice' left-wingers after they had made big efforts to present themselves as such, seemed to many YSers the decisive thing in characterising them. This reduced the credibility of Young Guard's subsequent criticisms of Keep Left — many of which gained point as the Keep Left leadership made serious errors, and span off into the outer space of ultra-left unrealism and sectarianism. In their own way, they helped Gerry Healy lead the youth off into the wilderness. 1962-63: Keep Left building its own YS hough banned by the Labour Party, Keep Left, a paper of the left wing of the labour youth movement, continued publication. This, as we shall see, had massive implications.
In July 1962 the first issue of Keep Left since proscription appeared, announcing that the paper would continue despite the ban. Keep Left supporters made tremendous efforts to maintain circulation: it was sold in "safe" YSs and by people who travelled out of their own areas to sell where they were unknown to potential witch-burners.
In the following six to nine months big advances were made in building YS branches, as Keep Left turned to a big campaign around youth unemployment, which reached a freak level at the end of 1962. (So did general unemployment, because of an exceptionally cold winter). In those campaigns, and despite the ban, the basis was laid for Keep Left to become the majority at the 1963 conference. Operating with a paper the selling of which merited expulsion from the Labour Party increased the tension, the rancour and the -justified - feelings of persecution of the Keep Left youth.
"hev were at the mercy of Gerry Healy ureaucrancally entorced tantasies and delu sions of grandeur.
In retrospect it can be seen that the decision to defy the ban and continue Keep Left was a decisive turning point for Keep Left and the YS. It succeeded spectacularly in maintaining the forces of Keep Left and even in building up the YS in defiance of the witch-hunters and bureaucrats. But it implied a YS separated from the Labour Party, and in the next two years, step by step, the logic spelled itself out.
Keep Left put forward policies for the YS that more and more implied casting off the links with the Labour Party and having the YS act as an open outright revolutionary party. This in turn meant that, to maintain the organisation's momentum, all sorts of pretexts for agitation and action had to be sought or invented. It pushed the forces of Keep Left more and more into a selfsustained mental ghetto, and encouraged unrealism in assessing the state of the labour movement. Ultimately it led the SLL into counterposing its own small "party" , and a small segment of youth whose radicalisation went quite a way ahead of the working class and even of the militants of the working class, who were looking hopefully towards a Labour government after a dozen years of Toryism in power, to the actual development of the real labour movement.
When there was a very big radicalisation of youth in the late 1960s, the SLL cut itself off from that too, mistaking its own wishes for reality and going over into a style of politics reminiscent of third period (ultra-left Stalinism. Ultimately this was to lead to the more or less complete self-destruction of the entire cadre of the old Trotskyist movement, for the second time in 15 years, and to Trotskyism not being capable of capitalising on the great opportunities for the growth of a revolutionary party that emerged in the late '60s and early "70s.
Keep Left's policy in the YS only reflected the political crisis of the Trotskyist movement. We can only deal briefly with that crisis here. The SLL had been the British representative of the tendency led by James P Cannon, the founder of American Trotskyism. Despite terrible weaknesses, faults and errors, after 1949 no other group deserving the name Trotskyism - if Trotskyism is irreplaceably an attempt to build a movement, and it has to be — existed in Britain. In the early '60s the SLL was in the course of breaking with Cannon, who, with remarkable perception, diagnosed as early as mid-1961 that the SLL was off on an "Oehlerite (ie. sectarian) binge". Disappointed by the reversal which Gaitskell inflicted on the Labour left and the Tribunite left's failure to fight seriously, the SLL began more and more to counterpose itself artificially to the labour movement, expressing itself more and more in a formalistic leftism and a destructive organisational sectarianism.
The discovery that a YS movement could be maintained and built against Transport House after the proscription of Keep Left led them to forget how limited were the forces involved in the YS, compared to the task for Marxists of transforming the labour movement. The SLL's break with its international mentors gave free play to the SLL leaders' characteristic wishful thinking and tendency to mistake their own desires and assertions for reality. Responding to both the impatience of the ex-Pers with Labour Party work, and the patience and experience of Cannon, Healy had added the experience of a valuable innovation to the arsenal of the movement, by forming an open organisation without abandoning entrism. In the early '60s he cut loose from Cannon.
Healy's make-believe and irresponsibility was to dominate the YS, especially 1963-64.
More than any mistakes in assessment and analysis, more even than their political subjectivism, it was the bureaucratic nature of the SLL which led them and a section of the YS to destruction. A democratic organisation allows the correction of mistakes, reassessment, the removal of leading people who persist in costly errors or pernicious practices. The SLL had a savagely repressive internal regime which excluded all but a very small group of the top leaders, or maybe all but one person, from effective policy-making and initiatives. This situation had been generated by the long drawn out factional struggles in the Trotskyist movement of the '40s. At the end of the '40s, most of the cadres deserted the movement, leaving the Healy faction, which had fought a five year struggle for an orientation to the Labour Party, in control. It was a period of massive defeat for the Trotskyists throughout the world, which took its toll everywhere. It threw the British Trotskyists back to a sectarian and authoritarian form of organisation of the sort often to be found in the workers' movement in period of immaturity, weakness or defeat.
In the early 1960s, the influx of raw young people freed the Healy leadership from the limited restraints imposed by the relatively educated and experienced cadre of the earlier period, those who had been formed politically in the battle against sectarianism. The dictatorial Healy regime, vigorously asserting its prerogatives at every point, linking its subjectivism and wishful thinking with the politically healthy impatience of the youth, and at the same time building its organisation with considerable ability, locked itself more and more away from reality and from any consideration about reality it did not want to face:
everything in the structure of the organisation was designed to do this as completely as the leadership should want to. There could be no feedback from the membership other than what the leadership wanted to take into account.
As time went by, Gerry Healy would want to take less and less into account except his own fantasies and appetites, locking himself into an infantile solipsism, and the organisation first into grotesque sectarianism towrds the labour movement and then, in the "70s, into lucrative mercenary political odd job work for Libya, Iraq and some of the Sheikhs.
The story
Scan page 13
known, and then in 1968 the struggle she had recently had with Stalinist armies snuffed out herself to make her finally read the Alexander Dubcek's "socialism anti-Stalinist writings of Arthur with a human face" in Koestler, the author of Darkness at Czechoslovakia at the same time as Noon, who broke with Stalinism in the French CP betrayed the great the late '30s. Yet she was formally workers' strike movement of 1968, well educated, and had then been in they were left with the sour and and around the French Communist bitter taste of disgust and Party for thirty years!
thereserves county counel andowners. the nastier footage at the scene The 70-year life of Yves Montand was inextricably entwined with the history of the left wing of the working-class movement in Europe.
He was born in Italy in 1921, the child of Communist parents. He went with them to France in his infancy when they fled triumphant Italian fascism.
After working on the docks in Marseilles, the young Montand became a singer and then a movie actor. In the mid-'50s he played in movies such as The Wages of Fear, a tense account of men driving unstable gelignite in primitive trucks over rough roads.
Montand and his wife and cothinker Simone Signoret became very prominent French Stalinist celebrities. They were dining with Nikita Khrushchev in the Kremlin on the night 35 years ago when Khrushchev sent the tanks to crush the Hungarian Revolution!
In the '60s and '70s Montand played in a series of radical movies, mostly made by Costa-Gavras and written by Jorge Semprun.
The first of them, Z (1963), depicted the murder of the leftist Greek MP Lambrakis, a key event in Greek politics in the turbulent years before the army colonels coup of 1967 which imposed seven years of military dictatorship on the country.
In The War Is Over (1966: directed by Alain Resnais and written by Jorge Semprun), Montand played an emigre official of the Spanish Communist Party in exile - someone who had, in parallel to Montand himself, grown up and begun to grow old in exile. He is weary, but he keeps going, making dangerous trips into fascist Spain.
Just as Z reflected the hopeful mass-CND "new left" politics of the early '60s, and The War Is Over reflected the rise of ultra-leftism and Maoism in the later '60s, Stage of Siege (directed and written by Costa-Gavras) reflected the influence of Guevarism and guerrilla warfare in the left-wing politics of the early "70s.
Based on a true story, it dealt with the capture and killing of an American official and torture expert - played by Montand - by the Tupumaro guerrillas of Uruguay.
Then in the early '70s, in another Costa-Gavras film, L'aveu ("The Confession" , written by Semprun), Montand played Artur London, a Czech Stalinist who was one of the group around Czech Communist Party general secretary Rudolf Slansky tried in the heavily antisemitic ("'anti-Zionist") purge trial of 1951.
They were tortured into confessing and then hanged (like Slansky) or jailed (like London, on whose memoirs the film was based).
L'aveu, a fine and true film, depicted a far-gone state of exasperation and hatred of Stalinism. It reflected the evolution of a whole layer of European leftwing intellectuals. The writer, Jorge Semprun, was one of a group of ex-CP intellectuals which included such political writers as Claudin.
They broke, slowly, over T years, with Stalinism, not in the direction of real socialism but towards bourgeois democracy.
Montand went with them, after many years as a prominent public face of the French Stalinist movement.
Liberal bourgeois democracy was seemingly stable, and it was expanding. The decrepit and decayed fascism of General Franco, imposed on Spain by a bloody civil TURAL FRONT war in the '30s, gave way peacefully in the mid '70s to a liberal bourgeois democracy, crowned by a restored monarchy. The Stalinist parties were rotting and disintegrating. The working-class movement had been ground down and weakened by Stalinism.
In those conditions the tired and the disillusioned - and the conscience-stricken, as Montand seems to have been - do not move to the left.
Montand's move to the right was far from complete, though. He came out against the Gulf War earlier this year - as he had come out, and at considerable risk, against France's wars in Indochina and Algeria in the '50s and '60s -and at the age of 70 campaigned against France's part in this latest bloody imperialist atrocity. Rosenor 's gen ration. adicals of Montand's spent their political lives in and Owen around a powerful malignant sect, the Stalinist French Communist Party.
It took their commitment to socialism, their hopes, their youth, and their spirit of revolt, and harnessed them to the interests of the USSR abroad and to the service of a passive, sterile, time-serving and organically right-wing bureaucratic party at home. It gave them nothing back, neither victories, nor the hope of victories, nor even a stable self-respect-inducing sense of honourable struggle.
As the truth about the USSR became more widely arly in June this year, the Operations"'.
Organiser disorientation.
Politically, most of them had neither knowledge of the real history of the socialist movement to fall back on, nor belief in a new start. They went, when they cut the cable with Stalinism, with the temporarily dominant currents, to the right.
Their state of mind - and the reason why their break with Stalinism, when it came, proved sterile for socialism - is perhaps best portrayed in an interview which Signoret, Montand's wife, gave to an American socialist magazine in the earl 1970c She told her interviewer about the
----- pull-quotes -----
Party conference, the right wing reversed the policy on unilateral nuclear
which fought without hypocrisy for the right ę HO
Out of 420 arrests, 241 were charged Esouth Yorkshire police attack. The central motive which lay behind the despite the fact that no law public paid out t420,000 to miners in miners; they had o be broken and Cinem