Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists must use their brains o ali s ]Murphy's rejoinder to

Socialist Organiser no. 507, 14 November 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 1,032 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

of payment by piece-rate, long denounced by Marx as the most vicious form of capitalist exploitation, had been introduced. "Taylorism", the American system of labour discipline, earlier denounced by Lenin as "man's enslavement by the machine", was "For Lenin, the superiority of socialism over capitalism is that 'socialism create:

much higher productivity of labour'. In plain words, increases rate of exploitation and the extraction of surplus value... What Lenin seems to be saying here is that socialism is the highest form of capitalism. He does not seem to be concerned that, except in name, status of a work would be hardly different to that under capitalism. brought into Soviet industry. These systems were used with the clear support of Lenin.

Under the New Economic Policy, with the introduction of private trade and private enterprise, Lenin came to rely more heavily on capitalist techniques and exploitaion of the labour force.

This was justified by the statenent that: "the revolution demands hat in the interest of socialism the -lasses unquestionably obey the ingle will of the leaders of the labour process."

Believe it or not, socialism became increasingly defined as the best method for increasing the productivity of labour. "Socialism" Lenin was to declare, "is nothing but state capitalist monopoly which has been turned in the interest of the whole people, and therefore ceased to be capitalist monopoly."

This is a nice piece of conjuring. But if I had been a Soviet worker I would not have been impressed. For Lenin there was no longer any room for workers' control under socialism. Rather he calls for "less chatter about industrial democracy. Industrv is indispensible, democracy is not. Industrial democracy breeds some utterly false ideas."

Finally, for Lenin, the superiority of socialism over capitalism is that "socialism creates a much higher productivity of labour" • In plain words, increases the rate of exploitation and the extraction of surplus value.

Socialism for Lenin is no longer a question of transformation of the relations of production; no longer the abolition of wage-labour and slavery of the worker to the machine; no longer a question of the emancipation of the working What Lenin seems to be saying here is that socialism is the highest stage of capitalism. He does not seem to be concerned that, except in name, the status of a worker under such a system would be hardly different to that under capitalism. Nor does Lenin seem to recognise that such a system would inevitably place power in the hands of a new managerial class of specialists, experts and administrators - a new class of slave drivers.

I agree most forcefully with Angelica Balabamov, an Italian Communist who spent the early years of the revolution in Russia. She wrote a generally sympathetic account of Lenin, with the judgement that his life was one long tragedy, that he desired good but created evil, and that he used or suggested methods that could not fail to produce deleterious effects on the movement to which he dedicated his whole life.

Leninism was not the same as Stalinism, but Leninism did not provide an alternative.

The beginning of Pat Gary Kent creates the impression of a reasoned analysis of the situation in Northern Ireland. But after two paragraphs it's the same old story. It's all the fault of the British imperialists.

IRA violence is a symptom of the British presence. A response to repression by the British State. If the Brits withdraw, the problem is solved.

In his opening paragraphs Murphy criticises the "IRA's choice of a nationalist (his emphasis) military campaign" as an "essentially inappropriate counterproductive weapon". In his fifth paragraph he switches tracks. The "paramilitaries are a product, a symptom... not the cause" . He accuses Kent of falling into "the oldest of liberal traps, the para-militaries are terrorists" , whereas Murphy identifies the State as the real terrorist. The IRA are just reacting.

Murphy's second method for shifting the line of his argument is his selective use of language. Instead of writing of the IRA having a choice, he now writes of them being i symptom. They are not a "cause" of violence, they are an effect. This enables him to shift from criticising them to justifying them, and then coming down on their side in the argument. The fact is, as Murphy said in his earlier paragraphs, the IRA chose. Symptoms don't have a choice.

The point to note here is that the IRA of which Murphy writes is the Provisional IRA. In 1962, the original IRA made a change in policy, from 'physical force' to constitutional politics. A minority disagreed and some left, others became inactive. The IRA played an active role in the creation of the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association. In 1969, the IRA split. The precise issue need not concern us here. But the upshot of this was that there were now two IRAs. The Official IRA and Sinn Fein committed to 'armed struggle'. Why is it the Provisionals who are blessed with the euphemism, a 'symptom'. Not their own fault.

The Provisional IRA has declared that its "armed struggle" is setting the agenda in Northern Ireland. It will continue until the Brits and Unionists submit. They must therefore be responsible for the consequences of that 'agenda' They are a 'cause' despite Murphy's protestations to the contrary.

Murphy's potted history is not only, inevitably, inadequate. It is downright misleading. For example, he makes no reference to the role played by the ultra-left in sidelining the Civil Rights Movement.

The first priority for socialists is not, as Murphy proposes, "supporting moves to reunify Ireland". It is to gain an understanding of the situation which is not based merely upon a simplistic nationalist point of view. "Over 80% of the Irish people put peace before unity" Irish Times, Dublin, 23/4/1991. *The majority of Catholics in Northern Ireland wish to remain in the United Kingdom", public opinion poll, 19/2/1989.

Socialists must use their brains, and not be stampeded into a policy which could lead to a major disaster for these islands.

Bert Ward, Middlesborough A divided working class

Scan page 12

Those who do not learn from history are condemned to relive i liser N DEPTH

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 507

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →