Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[the wary Among those who have reason to…]

Socialist Organiser no. 507, 14 November 1991 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 1,389 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

the wary Among those who have reason to remember Robert Maxwell with bitterness are the National Union of Journalists chapel at unig the academic publishing company Pergamon Press. They were sacked after a one day ing Life and cut many jobs. He strike in protest against Maxwell hen got the union leaders to fight sacking an employee without uspatinenth ing the disciplinary procedure. single-union deal. The "Pergamon 23" are now in NGA union cretere the third year of their strike. This Cony Dubbins believed (or so the inancial Times reported) that this the Dutch publisher Elsevier as year they saw Pergamon sold to ive and take". But in fact Max- Maxwell tried to raise cash to fob off the banks. Undaunted, relude to Murdoch's move to the strikers are continuing their campaign for reinstatement, and Stre sses agamsiminiom are working on getting support from the Dutch unions against the new owner Honecker, Nicolae Ceaucescu and General Jaruzelski. It is unlikely that he made much money from those ventures, but Pergamon's translations of Soviet and East European scientific research were highly profitable.

In 1981 Maxwell bought the British Printing Corporation, Britain's biggest printers but then almost bankrupt. By vicious unionbashing, he restored it to profit. In 1984 he took over the Mirror group of newspapers.

In summer 1985 he issued an ultimatum to the print unions: he would shut down the Mirror unless they agreed to drastic cuts in jobs and changes in work conditions. By January 1986 he had blackmailed the unions into agreeing to 2,100 job cuts.

It was the same sort of operation as Murdoch did through his move to Wapping, but with less drama. Maxwell was to use similar unionStalin contemplates Lenin's corpse: was Leninism no alternative to Stalinism? the dangers to the revolution were people themselves to create a new not just from outside Russia, but society by their own efforts. were also from developments inside Appealing to the population of Russia. These were the danger of Russia, Lenin declared: "Comcreeping bureaucratisation, of the rades, workers, remember that creation of a Soviet "organisation from now on you yourselves are adMany of Lenin's critics see his help you if you do not unite and major fault in the theory of the take over all state affairs." vanguard party. He believed - so it In so doing Lenin argued that the is said - that a party of profes- masses would be creating a new sional revolutionaries was the only type of state. In his words: "a new way the working class could change type of state, without

Scan page 10

I think there is a misinterpreta- force, without a permanent army, tion of Lenin, both by his sup- which replaces bourgeois porters and his antagonists, when it democracy by a new democracy, is said Lenin only saw two types of causes the labouring masses to act class consciousness - firstly, trade as vanguard, confers upon them union consciousness, limited to legislative, executive and military What is to be Done? he argued is all Up to that point I am very much own; secondly, socialist con- socialism he was advocating. But Bill Lomax, author of Hungary 1956, an inspirin study of the Workers' Councils and the anti-Stalinist revolution, takes the debate on the meaning Leninism. He argues that Leninism can provide no alternative to Stalinism. Bill was speaking at the 'Stand Up For Real Socialism' event on 2nd November eninism in power was not real socialism. Consequently Leninism does not provide the basis for a real alternative to Stalinism.

Did Lenin lead to Stalin? From one point of view, obviously yes.

Without Lenin there probably would not have been an October revolution, because there were very few people in the Bolshevik Party who believed that a socialist revolution was possible in Russia in 1917.

Without Lenin it is questionable whether the Bolsheviks would ever have come to power. And so without Lenin Stalin would never have found himself in a position to usurp and create a tyrannical system.

But then if Stalin's parents had not had sex we would not have had Stalin or Stalinism - so were Stalin's mother and father responsible for the terror and purges and the gulag?

In fact, Lenin was no more responsible for repression in Russia in the 1930s than were Stalin's mother and father.

The curse of Stalinism was the historical situation. Russia found itself in at the beginning of this century: the economic and social conditions and Russia's position in the global economy. I hope all Marxists would agree with this.

Where I disagree with Socialist Organiser is that I would argue that the necessary pre-conditions for socialism — the social, economic, cultural and psychological preconditions — did not exist in Russia at the start of the century. Paradoxically, the necessary pre-conditions for capitalism did not exist either.

Both Lenin and Trotsky, at different points, recognised that the orthodox Marxist view, that Russia was ripe only for a bourgeois-democratic revolution was wrong. In the early years of the century, Russia was not even ripe for that type of revolution.

The view of the liberals and the Mensheviks, that it was possible to have a liberal capitalist developmment in Russia, was a big illusion.

Equally, the view propogated by Lenın and Stalin, that the conditions for capitalism were not ripe, but perhaps the conditions for socialism were, was also false.

It reminds me of the person who goes into a bar saying, I have not got enough money for a pint of mild, but perhaps I'll have a double gin and tonic!

In order to establish a socialist society we need a higher stage of development than that needed for a capitalist society.

That is the major problem for the Marxist movement of the 20th century. Russia was not ripe for a socialist revolution. What Russia was ripe for was an authoritarian, bureaucratic, largely state-owned development.

The argument "did Lenin lead to Stalin?" is in fact completely academic. Something like Stalinism was almost inevitable in the Russian conditions of the first half of the century.

he possibilities for the development of capitalism in Russia in 1917 were very similar to capitalism's prospects in the Russia of 1991. They were very limited.

The paradox and tragedy of 1917 is that the factors which made the Bolshevik revolution possible - the limited possibilities of bourgeois development - also undermined the chance of success of that revolution after Lenin came to power.

Lenin, however, was far from being unaware of the situation. Once in power I think Lenin struggled valiantly, in theory and in practice, to realise socialist aspirations. I want to argue that he did not succeed in doing so.

Towards the end of his life Lenin, more clearly than the rest of the old Bolsheviks and Trotsky, recognised man", the danger of Stalin.

itself into a revolutionary force.

bread and butter issues, which in power." the workers can achieve on their sciousness, which he argued had to be brought to the workers from outside by socialist intellectuals organised in a vanguard party.

In fact Lenin recognised that in a revolutionary situation, when workers became involved in revolutionary struggles, the workers often ministering the state. No-one will bureaucracy, without a police supporter of Lenin and the "It was in the spirit of radical democracy advocated in State and Revolution that forced to seek one breathing space after another in the hope that the international revolution would come to save them.

Soviet Russia was turned from being the spark of international revolution to the bastion of international revolution. In other words, it had to be defeated at all costs.

It is a mistake to believe that the notion of "socialism in one country" originated with Stalin, Almost all the Bolsheviks were in favour of trying to build socialism in one country. On the other hand, very few of them believed that the attempt could survive for long, let alone be completed, without the international revolution.

But in the interests of defending the isolated socialist state, the first steps were taken that contradicted the original socialist ideas. Some of these steps date from the earliest days of the revolution.

Is early as November 1917 a national congress of factory committees was banned from meeting. Demands for workers' control previously supported by the Bolsheviks were now

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 507

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →