Foot in the door? Or sell-out? Proyota's new
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
• No shop stewards. Toyota workers will be "represented" by a joint worker/management board which • A "no intention to strike" commitment from Bill Jordan — which is, apparently, not quite the same thing Of course, AEU leaders Bill Jordan and Gavin Laird will argue that the deal was the best they could hope for under the circumstances. Another union would have Willis propounds the benefits of "Social Partnership" at this year's TUC The Toyota deal tells us what all this talk really means stepped in to offer the same terms to Toyota if the AEU had refused. Nissan's Yamoto plant on Tyneside has no ut the fact remains that the deal represents a massive Backward a an has already ben sate upon t engineering and has already been seized upon by For bosses to reject the current claim for a 37 hour week in their plants. And, of course, not a single Toyota worker The deal gives the AEU "bargaining rights" and access to the workforce for purposes of recruitment. But the experience of Nissan's first Tyneside plant (where less than five per cent of the workforce chose to join the AEU suggests that workers will not join a union unless they see it actually winning concessions for them. Far from winning anything, deals like these undermine gains that have been Deals like these might represent a "foot in the door" in plants that would otherwise be non-union. But so far unions like the AEU, EETPU, and TGWU have signally failed to use their "foot in the door" at greenfield sites to open up those doors to effective union organisation.
Might it not be better to tell employers to stuff their "beauty contests" and then campaign around issues like shorter hours once the workforce is in place? But perhaps that sounds too much like "old-fashioned" ', "nonconsensual" trade unionism to appeal to the likes of Bill roduction at INSIDE Derby plant will not THE UNIONIS start until next year. The bulk of the workforce has yet to be recruited. But their union representation has already been decided. The AEU won Toyota's "beauty contest", outdoing the TGWU, GMB, MSF, and even the EETPU in grovelling before the bosses.
The AEU/Toyota single- By Sleeper union deal includes such historic breakthroughs as:
• 39 hour working — despite the fact that the AEU itself led a three year campaign to make 37 hours the norm throughout engineering.
will not take votes.
a no-strike deal.
union recognition at all.
has been consulted about any of this.