Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Yugoslavia: bloodbath after the thaw

Socialist Organiser no. 507, 14 November 1991 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,015 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

The Serbs and the Croats are very similar peoples.

They are divided by dialects, not by distinct tongues. Yet the civil war in Yugoslavia is the worst of all sorts of war: a "race" war.

It is a war between two peoples who have an ingrained hatred of each other, bred from a history of conflict and war from which the memories of terrible deeds still reverberate in the minds of the present generation.

It is perfectly understandable that the Serb minority in Croatia should refuse to let themselves become part Grahens BEnÁn Vladimir Derer Terry Engleson Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sectiens)

Doroth yaMacedo Joes Maitno John Miriray John Nichblsea Peter tcheN Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross section of th lett who are opposed to une Labourdi ty's witch-hunt against Socialist мен prepsed n не кам: с віл Enesponsint of Whee thosso opi of the Advisory Editorial Board. of a Croatian state which has seceded from Yugoslavia. In World War 2, half the Serbs in Croatia were murdered by the fascist Ustashe movement, allied to Nazi Germany. Fear was palpable among the Serbs in Croatia before war broke out, as they saw Croats using World War 2 names, Slogans and symbols and were faced with demands to swear loyalty to Croatia and victimisation in their jobs when they were slow to comply.

It is understandable, in the light of history, that Serbia should refuse to leave the Serb minority at the mercy of the Croatian majority. It is understandable that they should fight to stop that happening, and it was a certainty that they would.

Croat secession from Yugoslavia was bound to spark conflict unless it was accompanied by an agreed peacetul secession of the Serb majority areas from Croatia, and guarantees for the rights of Serbs elsewhere in Croatia.

Yet that was easier said than done, for not all the Serb areas in Croatia are adjacent to Serb territory. And the idea of accepting Serb secession would outrage every Croat nationalist. They seceded from Yugoslavia in the name of self-determination; yet a people like the Croats seeking self-determination for themselves often sets its face like stone against the right of secession for minorities. within its chosen area.

It is almost always thus. The struggle for their own independence tends always to blind nations to the rights of other peoples making a similar claim on them.

Exactly the same double standards can be seen from the Serbs. They claimed to be defending their own people in Croatia, but had already suppressed the rights of minority areas, including overwhelmingly Albanian-populated Kosovo, in their own territory. Now hey are plaınly trying to carve out nd grab for Serbia as big a part or Croatia as they can, irrespective of who lives there.

All these difficulties, and the Pandora's box of nationalism "Socialists have to insist again and again that the only possible and acceptable solutic will be the democratic one proposed by the Bolsheviks - self-determination for all nations, autonomy for all minorities, equality for all."

unleashed the break-up of by Yugoslavia, added up to the strongest argument against Croat secession and for the maintenance of the Yugoslav federation.

Yet the Yugoslav federation has now broken down irretrievably. Nothing but military conquest will bring the Croats back to federation with Serbia. It follows then that socialists champion the right of Croatia and the right of the Serbs in Croatia to secede.

The terrible possibility Yugoslavia is no more than a small rehearsal for similar bitter ethnic and national conflicts all across the former USSR. The attempt by the one-million strong Chechen-Inguish people to leave Boris Yeltsin's Russian Republic is only the latest stirring in the nationalist cauldron.

Yeltsin's threats to respond to secession with military force -taken together with his earlier talk of revising the borders between the Russian Republic and the other republics of the ex-USSR - shows how easily Yugoslav-type situations can erupt in the USSR.

Everywhere in the former Stalinist world, the most malignant nationalism has sprung back to life in the newly open climate. The only possible answer is the one given by the Bolsheviks in 1913: "In so far as national peace is in any way possible in a capitalist society based on exploitation, profit-making and strife, it is attainable only under a consistently and thoroughly democratic republican system of government... the constitution of which contains a fundamental law that prohibits any privileges whatsoever to any one nation and any encroachment whatsoever upon the rights of a national minority.

*This particularly calls for wide regional autonomy and fully democratic local government, with the boundaries of the self-governing and autonomous regions determined by the local inhabitants themselves on the basis of their economic and social conditions, national make-up of the population, etc".

The Russian workers' revolution of 1917 started to solve the national and ethnic conflicts according to the application of consistent democracy between the nations and fragments of nations. Stalin overthrew Bolshevism and returned the peoples to subjection for decades. He deported entire peoples (including the Chechen-Inguish).

Nothing was solved by the Stalinist policy. Now the price is being paid.

We cannot change that at will. But socialists have to insist again and again that the only possible and acceptable solution will be the democratic one proposed by the Bolsheviks - self-determination for all nations, autonomy for all minorities, full equality for all.

Despite all bourgeois propaganda, Bolshevism was not the cause of the problems the East European and USSR peoples face now. Stalinism was.

Bolshevism is the solution to these problems.

La pation fathe wowin class is also the emancipation of all Moan DeM sex or race."

Karl Marx Organisen PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA WASHEsk M63.917961 LAT вми нерокаси MondeN Editor: John O'Mahony Papachedalm W. Popura onsett PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the ost Office Articles do not necessarily reflect the views of Socialist Organiser and are. in nerwise stated

Scan page 4

BEHIND THE NEW

----- pull-quotes -----

Ardensony Editombad Boand

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 507

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →