Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The art of negotiation

Socialist Organiser no. 506, 8 November 1991 · scan p. 15 · Alan Fraser · about 587 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

Negotiation is a muci used word in the field of industrial relations. We often hear certain union leaders are skillful negotiators, and it is because of these skills that we achieve good agreements from management.

The question arises, should we rely on well-trained skillful negotiators to get things achier ed, or is it a case of relying on the militancy and action of our members? The short answer is that we need both.

Whether you are a steward, safety rep or branch secretary, lot of your time will be spent negotiating with management. It is therefore a skill that need to be learnt. But it is importan to put it into context.

The issue of negotiations reminds me of an experience I had whilst I was on a trade union studies course at the LSE. During the course the Industrial Relations Department decided to organise a negotiating role play, between shop stewards and those in the Business Studies Department (potential managers).

The Business Studies people would be stewards and the shop stewards would be managers. We would be negotiating a wage claim with one condition - that no strike action be taken. The results of our shared experience would then be fed into a computer and used as a role model. All in the interests of shared experiences and learting negotiating skills.

Eventually we got our briefEveryone was looking forward to arguing the ins and outs of the issue. However, the (the tutors) hadn't bargained of Jimmy (a Glaswegian shop steward) with many years experience. His part in the role play was as managing director for the company.

The "stewards" came in, sat down, and outlined their case in a detailed manner, then sat back and waited for Jimmy's response. Jimmy sat there for a moment, looked at them, and then growled, "Get to f***, go on f*** off, you're getting The "stewards" were shocked and so were the tutors. They said, you can't do that. Jimmy just sat there and repeated the same message several times until they left. The negotiating role play was due to last all day. Jimmy kyboshed it in three minutes. All the real stewards just sat there laughing. Eventually the tutors asked Jimmy what was going on and what were his reasons for stopping the role play.

Jimmy replied: **Firstly, 1 am not in the business of teaching potential managers how to screw the working class. Secondly, on the question of shared experiences, they haven got a clue what it's like for workers on the shopfloor, and therefore have no experiences we have! And we understand the needs of workers.

*Third, before you academics go away and write your theories about negotiations, you need to learn one fundamental lesson. That is, any dummy can be a manager, but not anybody can be a shop steward. Being a shop steward and a good negotiator means having commitment, determination, and ability to represent your members."

Clearly, what we need to recognise is that good negotiators are not about theories or clever people, but are a fusion of the experiences of stewards and the rank and file. Yes, if you are a shop steward and want to be a good negotiator you need to learn to identify problems, do your research, find out facts, and collect information, You need skills such as interviewing the members, getting their support, using arguments. note-taking, analysing documents, using the law, and articulating ideas. We need to know how to work with other

----- pull-quotes -----

STEWARDYS CORNER

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 506

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →