Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Reissued version of 'Spartacus' A brilliant film of slave revolt

Socialist Organiser no. 506, 8 November 1991 · scan pp. 13–15 · Jean Lane · about 2,976 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Thomas J Pat Spartacus reissued version of spartacus opened this week. Stanley Kubrick's film of slaves revolting in the midst of the Roman Empire was a revolutionary film when it was made in 1960, and it has stood the test of time as a masterpiece.

It begins in 73 BC, in a gladiatorial school near the Italian city of Capua, where a thirdgeneration slave who has previously worked in the mines, Spartacus, is being trained as a gladiator. He leads a revolt, which spreads from the gladiators at the school to most of the slaves in the surrounding part of Italy.

The gladiators functioned almost form a revolutionary Spartacus, originally a book written by Howard Fast in 1951, was later translated to film by Dalton Trumbo. Both were witch-hunted in the McCarthy era. Fast served a year in jail, and had to get his book published himself. No publisher would do it commercially, at first.

If you were a slave in that era, you were no longer a person, you were property. You could be sold, bought, killed, or eaten. Whatever your masters wanted to do to you they could do it and they would do it.

One of the reasons the revolt was so successful was that the gladiatorial school had created a group of trained fighters, who, once freed, were like an army. And, at the beginning, the komans were contemptuous, thinking a slave revolt no credible threat to their Roman Republic.

There had been, and would be, many slave revolts.

The gladiators functioned almost as a political party at the beginning of the revolt, deliberately going round and rousing the slaves to form a revolutionary army.

The film is full of hatred of slavery, and that hatred has a real emotional power that comes through in the film.

Given the politics of Fast and Dalton Trumbo, it is unlikely that the feeling against slavery, which in the film targets chattel slavery, is only a hatred of the ancient form of slavery. It is hatred of modern wage-slavery that, disguised but vibrating, radiates from this film. Kirk Douglas plays Spartacus Trumbo was just coming out of a ten year period of being blacklisted. The one really off note in the movie was presumably put in by Trumbo to placate the witch-hunters. At the beginning, a narrator says that Christianity was soon to create a new and better society in ancient Rome. It did nothing of the sort!

But, apart from that, the film is lett-wing. For example, the revolt in the gladiatorial school is sparked off when a black slave who has Sat 9 November BBC2 9.30pm n 1971, the editors of the "underground" paper Oz were charged at the Old Bailey with obscenity.

BBC2 has dramatised the trial. It you are inclined to tavour cen soring "pornography" and other beaten Spartacus in the arena refuses to kill him on the order of Roman nobles. Instead, he attacks them. It is a true parable of what a proper human being should do.

In America at that time (1960), this was a powerful message for the blacks. America had its own version of near-apartheid, and the black civil rights movement was picking up speed.

This film is very long - only the second I've been in that had an inSCHOOL ISSUE things that you dislike, take this chance to look back to when the censors were still very powerful. termission — and drags a bit at the end. But I will not forget for a long time the powerful scene where the slaves are beaten and the survivors are rounded up and faced with The Romans offer them their lives if they will identify Spartacus. Spartacus is about to sacrifice himself for his people when the person he is chained to shouts, "I am Spartacus". Then another slave says, "I am Spartacus"

Then another, then another, until the entire hillside is full of men shouting defiantly, "l am Spartacus"

Spartacus is no longer a man. He is a people. He is an idea. A person or a hero may be bought off or killed, but once an ideal grips a people, a community, or a class, once they really believe in that ideal, you would have to kill all those people to kill that ideal. If even a few people survive, the ideal survives, and may spread and take root again in the minds of many other people.

Spartacus is brilliant. Go and see it! Television Hast week, investigated the eart of the Matter on TV argument surrounding the Sara Thornton case, as well as those of Amelia Rossiter and Kiranjit Ahluwahlia who murdered their violent husbands.

A life sentence is automatic for murder. However, it is possible to get a sentence reduced to manslaughter due to provocation. This means a sudden and temporary loss of control. Since the woman had time to get away from her violent husband, find a knife, come back and then stab him, provocation could not apply. According to Hananna Siddiqui of Southall Black Sisters, after 20 years of violence, walking away and getting a knife is not necessarily a cooling-off period, but one of fear and desperation.

Campaigns on Sara Thornton's behalf argue that the law does not reflect women's experience and is based on double standards.

It does not reflect women's experience because it assumes a fight ween equals as eg, in a pub, which usually not the case in domestic The woman is often weaker, lacks, confidence, has children to shield and, in any case, responds to violence in a different way.

Based on double standards, because a man who kills his wife will be treated as, at most, "having gone too far this time", but often with sym-l pathy and leniency due to the inconvenience he has had to put up with from a nagging and drunken wife.

Thus, a man may be deemed to have been "provoked" if he kills his wife for moving a mustard pot. But a woman is more likely to get "diminished responsibility". Violence is accepted and expected in men, but not in women.

Those who argue against the law being changed often do so on the grounds that provocation means sudden loss of control, that to widen the time in which a provoked person can murder would be a charter for revenge killings.

This is the reason why, horrible as it is, 20 years of violence, being hit with a hammer, burned with cigarettes, rape and death threats to the woman and the kids cannot be taken into account. The law has to be above emotion, must not be swayed by history, and must stick strictly to the facts.

Does this mean that, when a judge gives a suspended sentence to a man who kills his wife for moving a mustard pot, he did not take into account and treat with sympathy, the years of nagging and drunkenness he had had to endure? I think not.

It could conceivably be argued that it is the misuse of a just law on behall of sexist judges which is to blame. That the law as it stands could be meted out more evenhandedly.

But only if you are dealing with a situation of equality in the first place. Just as working class people do not have equality under the law because they cannot afford representation, so women do not have equality under the law because they are not in reality equal citizens to start with.

All women suffering domestic violence, and working class women particular, who cannot defend themselves at a specific time of violence, cannot leave because of fear of reprisal or because of lack of money or through fear for their children, cannot get equal access to a law which, because of its interpretation of provocation, excludes them.

This is not arguing a special case. The law on many occasions takes people's personal circumstances into account before sentencing. Mitigation, a person's history, reports from social workers, etc., are brought into accoun in many court cases, including those ol men who murder their wives. Women who murder their husbands should be given the same consideration.

According to the programme, in the last vear, 15 men have been killed by their wives while 70 women have been killed by their husbands. Yet 40% of these women are convicted of murder compared to only 25% of the men.

Either this is because women are naturally violent in a more premeditated way than men or it IS because they are treated unfairly und the law, I suggest the latter.

Scan page 14

North Korea is today almost a pure Stalinist state. Even so, it was right for socialists to support the North Koreans against US imperialism MP xam Noca tons November osted bynshefieldso mo -The Isl T Tran most repressive the world.

3 10-100 SISel30S.

Mitte brrowen *uop amic regime in s one of the brutal and dictatorships in Since its ascent to power in 1979, it has systematically attacked all the democratic and social gains of the Iranian people achieved through the great many sacrifices made om Wheeter (SO! 105)

Tre-raises an import Want question for iocialists, It split and WHATS-ON Timeschem homember fastemen URMe nc funaal ne spaat 1ck LOwie Saturder 9 Nowernher Essen eN Miery i Cente, Sueder iD Nomender during the revolution.

In this country, the reports about this situation in Iran by the mass media have left a lot to be desired. Indeed, the reports themselves, and their so-called opposition to the Islamic regime, have appeared only when the British government has sought to put pressure on the Iranian regime out of its own self-interest. Otherwise, they have forces of Trotskyism 40 years ago — the Korean war and the attitude socialists should have taken to it.

Today, North Korea is almost a pure stalinist state Twesda/_12 ovember man pociety and on idlire miloster Wellmesrew B 0030 40S.

Thursday i lovember , Bitinen Filen 16 orember Satnadey 16 Nomenber Loadion Spalem I ember had no problem in supporting the reactionary politics of this regime and in covering up the arms sales by the West (especially from Britain).

Now, with the release of British hostages from Lebanon, the normalisation of relations between Iran and Britain has speeded up. This could mean increased arms sales and consequently more repression of the working crowned with something that looks like a hereditary monarchy. In 1950, the stalinist North Koreans invaded capitalist South Korea. Then the US (under the flag of the UN) intervened in the Korean civil war.

Six months later, so did the Maoist Chinese. In 3 years of war, most of Korea was levelled to the ground. At one point, when US generals came close to invading China, the world came close to a nuclear World War 3.

Even so, it was right, 1 think, for socialists to support the North Koreans against US imperialism, then smarting over the "loss" of China and uncertain whether to take on the role of old-fashioned colonial imperialist You did not have to have the illusion that Korean stalinism was "progressive" to support the Koreans' right to self-determination.

Of course, Gerry Healy, like Michel Pablo and Ernest Mandel, his mentors then, had illusions in expanding stalinism, believing it to be the expanding "world revolution"

ism have just picked up a copy of your leaflet 'Stand Up For Real Socialism', unfortunately not in time to attend your conference.

The case for a socialist revolution to replace capitalism remains as strong as ever.

In the Third World, capitalism today means increasing poverty, misery and hunger, imposed in order to meet the in terest payments demanded by international banks.

In the advanced capitalist countries unemployment is high and rising, and the welfare systems won by decades of working-class reform effort are everywhere under attack. In Eastern Europe and the USSR, the rush towards capitalism will turn millions into paupers.

Capitalism can inflict defeats on socialism and the working class. It can never abolish the working class, and so it can never abolish the class struggle and the ideas of socialism. class in Iran.

This is why we think that the British Labour Movement should do all in its power to oppose the Islamic regime and expose the hypocrisy of the present government in its attitudes towards this reactionary regime.

Amin Kazemi, the Campaign Against Repression in Iran (BM CARI, London WCIN 3XX)

What a shame then that those like Tony Cliff of the SWP, who did not have such illusions, failed to stand by the right of a small country to self-determination against imperialist invasion.

Cliff rediscovered his Leninist principles for Vietnam - which in principle was identical to Korea - in the '60s, when they were a lot easier to live with. He now seems eagerly to scan the political horizon for a Khomeini or Saddam Hussein to support for their "anti-imperialism"

Gerry Healy was a muddlehead and then a scoundrel. He was able to gain the position he did, because for a while he was in Britain the defender of important Marxist principles.

Tom Macara, New

Editor's note: Jack Cleary's series on the Trotskyists in the Labour Youth Moveme will be continued week However, I am full agreement with your statement. I would be very interested if you could send me more details of the nature and aims of your campaign.

Dave Backwith, Bristol fo The Alliance for Workers* Liberty was set up in May this year. It declared then: We need a crusade to clarify and restate the ideas of socialism, free fron all taint of Stalinism, and to help the political reconstitution of the working class.

That crusade is even more urgently needed now. The AWI is supporting the Stand Up For Real Socialism campaign launched by Socialist Organiser. It strives to tie together work in that campaign with daily activity in the trade unions and workplaces, in anti-poll-tax groups, in colleges, and on the streets; and to link all that activity with a drive to educate ourselves politically and organise a stable, cohesive, ale contingent of Marxists.

Contact the AWL c/o P O Box 823, London SE15 4NA. In this interview with Cecilia Garmendia (translated and abridged here from the French socialist weekly Rouge), Tomas Borge, the sole surviving founder-member of the Sandinista Front, argues that the collapse of Stalinism was a step forward for socialism.

ersonally, I rejoice Pat the events in the East: we have won the right to start again, but now we will star from correct positions, and we will not take any more blind alleys.

The revolutionaries no longer have reasons to go wrong from a strategic poin of view, as in the past.

We have gained from the events in the East. The time of bureaucracy and authoritarianism, and of absence of freedom of expression, has gone. The grey colours with which socialisn had clothed itself have been burned.

We must start to sew the most beautiful clothes for socialism, starting, of course, with nappies of all colours! Socialism must be reborn.

Of course, imperialism is more aggressive. It reckons it has won. It does not know that the fall of the Berlin Wall and of the East European states, instead of being a victory for it, will eventually constitute a loss for it.

The fall of the Berlin Wa constitutes the beginning of the stage of the destruction of imperialism, even if that prediction seems madness today. The first stone of capitalism has fallen with the Berlin Wall.

n Nicaragua, the revolution took advantage of an exceptional moment. A knot of contradictions permitted ou victory, and we knew how to cut it at the right moment.

But soon facts intervened which complicated the development of our revolution and of any change in Central America. Reagan's coming to the presidency of the United States was linked with the victory of the Nicaraguan revolution. He represented the choice of an expansionist and violent The events in the East have not had great ideological consequences Nicaragua, but they have had great effects in the economic field. However, they have had political effects for the majority of the international left, and, of course, the Latin American left.

The electoral defeat of th Sandinista Front only coincided with the overturns in the East at the level of dates. We did not lose the elections because of the fall of the Berlin Wall.

whe maintenance of the T internal unity of the Sandinista Front, despite the contradictions of our revolutionary process, which has been complex and marked by breaks, has been essential for Sandinism.

That unity is the vertebral column of the survival of the revolution. Despite the worst mistakes and errors we have committed, we have been able to maintain the cohesion of a strong organisation with an enormous social influence...

The political strength and the great resources of the Sandinista Front are used to defend popular interests and the gains of the revolution...

Besides, the government - and I say advisedly the government and not UNO [formally the ruling party; but in fact the government of Violeta Chamorro depends also on the consent of the Sandinistas] — is not trying today to dismantle th gains of the revolution. When the government, for example, vetoed the laws voted by the Assembly on property [reversing expropriations carried out after the 1979 revolution], contributed de facto to defending those gains.

It does that, with a certain political wisdom, starting from its understanding of reality and of the relation of forces, as well as in line with the agreements which it has been forced to make with the Sandinista Front.

Scan page 15

Socialist Organiser No. 506 page 15

----- pull-quotes -----

a political party at the beginning of th revolt, deliberately going round and rousing the slaves

The trials of Oz Periscope

NO BAT TWEETEO

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 506

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →