Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Battle of the Somme

Socialist Organiser no. 506, 8 November 1991 · scan pp. 11–12 · Sean Matgamna · about 3,794 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

TIDE The big framed, coloured certificate on our wall in Ennis (which is in the West of Ireland, about 20 miles from the Atlantic) puzzled me for a long time when I was very small.

To the left of the fireplace, near the picture of the Sacred Heart of Jesus, it was decorated at the top by a circle or semi-circle of little flags of different sorts. It was the inscription I could not make sense of. It testified that John O'Mahony "had given his life" in July 1916 "to defend the liberty of his country"

No, it was not my uncle's name — my own name, too, in English, in memory of him — that confused me, but the reference to "his country". Which country? John was in the English army. England was not his country, or mine; and England's army was not the army of Ireland, his country.

I could not identify the Empire flags on the certificate, but I knew the Irish tricolour, and that was not there.

At first I was just puzzled; later, as I learned official 26 Counties history at school, I became vaguely ashamed and angry. My uncle John died "defending his country" just a few weeks after the English army burned the centre of Dublin and killed 15 of their captured prisoners of war in cold blood. They were the heroes who, with the earlier Republicans and the Irish saints and missionaries of ancient time and of our own time, were held up to us as embodying the highest ideals of Catholic Ireland.

I was uneasy, but pitying too. John was real to me. I knew his face. On the staircase there was a big framed old-fashioned sepia picture of a couple posing in a photographer's studio. The man, though he had a broad mustache and was in uniform, looked a bit like my father; the woman was bareheaded, in a long-skirted tight-bodied dress. Good-looking people in their twenties, both of them looked out at you boldly, not afraid of anything, it seemed.

It was a wedding picture. John and Bid were married, then John's leave was up, and he was gone — for good. And I knew Bid. She, the handsome, bold-eyed woman in the photo, was a tall, strong-boned, gaunt-faced old woman, one of the few women in the town who still (in the early '50s) dressed not in a coat but in the old-fashioned long black tasselled shawl. She never remarried. She had had a husband for one week.

Is I got older, I could make more sense of my father's stories. John got drunk one evening, broke some windows, in a fight perhaps (I can't remember), and the magistrate press-ganged him into the army.

But the magistrates and the others who wielded the pressures of the established order did not recruit the hundreds of thousands of Irish men who joined up.

Sometimes it was "*economic conscription". In places like Ennis, a market town with almost no industry, the town poor eked out a living as best they could, hiring out as drovers at fairs, doing building work, cutting firewood in the woods outside the town and hawking it, cutting hazel saplings ("scollops") and selling bundles ("barths") of them for use thatching houses. They were not quite a modern proletariat on which society lived, nor a proletariat like the one in ancient Rome which could (as Marx put it) live off society, but something in between.

John's brother Bob was carrying an enormous bundle of scollops from the woods on his back down miles of country road into the town one day, and having a back-breaking time of it as always. He stopped to rest against a wall, and there and then decided that the army was "better than this'?. He survived, shell-shocked. One of the wounded, being wheeled away from the horri of Irish men fought - and were slaughtered - in the Fil the British Army His younger brother Gagen followed him and went through the war unscathed, only to be crippled by a hand-grenade when fighting, probably for mercenary reasons, on the wrong side in the Irish civil war of 1922-3.

My father and another brother escaped the pull to go too only because they were still children. But they did not escape the loyalties. To my childish exasperation, not even the struggle for Irish independence and the terrorist campaign of the Black and Tans to repress the elected Irish secessionist parliament which declared Ireland a Republic in January 1919, about which my father would tell stories from his experience, eradicated those loyalties. The ordinary British soldier, my father would say, was decent enough, and would try sometimes to stop the Black and Tans ill-treating people.

He would tell a story about himself aged 14 and his half-blind father being cornered and bullied by sportive Tans on a country road, and "rescued" by ordinary soldiers. Apparently this was a common experience, and a common feeling about the soldiers.

Nor was it only for economic reasons that men went off to kill other "young men they did not know" and with whom they had no real quarrel. Everywhere in the armed camps of the nations - in Germany, Britain, France, Austria — there was delirious enthusiasm for the war.

It was a break in the dull routine. Men who were to be destroyed in the clash of enormous de-personalised military machines, who would go out "over the top" for as long as they lasted against machine guns which scythed them down like corn standing in a field, went off to the army with images of war as gallantry, adventure, and personal initiative. They died in their millions.

in Ireland people of all sorts and classes flocked to "the colours" By April 1916, when the Rising in Dublin led by Connolly and Pearse began to change the course of Irish history, 150,000 Irish men were in the British army. By the end of the war, over 200,000 Irish were fighting under British flags.

The historian Roy Foster sums up some of the reasons why. "Town labourers predominated over agricultural labourers, often encouraged by unemployment at home and the prospect of a generous separation allowance for their families; Belfast provided a higher proportion for reasons of proletarianisation as much as Protestantism".

In the north of Ireland, the men who had organised in the Ulster Volunteer Force and armed themselves, backed by the Tory party, with imported German guns on the eve of the war to resist the British Liberal Government if it tried to coerce them into a united Ireland, joined up en masse. In Catholic Ireland many thousands had organised and armed themselves in the Irish Volunteers to back Home Rule, and if necessary fight the Northerners. They joined the British Army "Some of them helped drive Britain out of Ireland: the most successful Republican field commander in Ireland's through the entire Worl soldiers returned embittered, and many them turned to communism, pursuing new definition of freedom" too, in their big majority, to prove that a Home Rule Ireland would be "loyal" to the Empire. That is what their leaders told them to do.

They met, Northerners and Southerners, Catholics and Protestants, Nationalists and Unionists, far away in France, and found that they could after all unite - in the mass graves of places like Ypres and the Somme.

Orange and Green were united not in the brotherhood of an all-Ireland national identity, and not by the benign white with which those who designed the Irish tricolour in the 1840s had linked the Orange and the Green, but by the red of England's army and by their blood.

The battle of the Somme was ending just about now - after four months in which nothing was decided one way or the other - exactly 75 years ago.

Over a million men died in that battle alone, most of them workers from the slums of Berlin, Paris, Manchester, London, and similar places. Many thousands of them were Irish. A great compact mass of them, 12,000 strong, were Ulster Protestants. The men who had first come together to fight Home Rule, and if necessary England, perished en masse fighting Germany on behalf of England.

Yet that great slaughter helped to transform Ireland. It was not only the 1916 Rising that changed the course of Irish politics. It was the attempt to force conscription (introduced in Britain in 1916) onto Ireland which united Catholic Ireland behind the Sinn Fein coalition, which won the November 1918 election on a platform of secession from the United Kingdom.

In the last half of the war, recruitment in Ireland fell off dramatically. According to Foster, "By 1917, figures prepared for the Cabinet showed that the percentage of the male population represented by enlistment was down to 4.96 in Ireland, compared to 17% in England, Scotland and Wales"

The Rising, with the cold-blooded killing afterwards of some of those who surrendered, was no doubt one reason for this. The young men of Ireland turned from "defending the liberty of their country" to attempting to win it from those with whom they had far greater reason to quarrel than they ever had with Germany.

Some of them helped drive Britain out of Southern Ireland: the most successful Republican field commander in Ireland's war of independence, Tom Barry, had gone through the entire World War in the British Army Everywhere in Europe, soldiers returned embittered, and many of them turned to communism, pursuing a new definition of freedom.

Poor John O'Mahony, one of millions who died in the great senseless imperialist slaughter, and the other Irish dead, were past learning.

Scan page 12

Ted Grant analyses the Walton fiasco tionary parties outside of the time, given the Organiser The decision of the majority of Militant's The decision of the majority of Militant's leaders to make a turn towards SWP-style "party building" is an important event for It has thrown Militant's organisation into a profound crisis. Amongst the opponents o the new turn is Ted Grant, the founder of The minority resolution, which Grant, together with Rob Sewell, presented to the mid-July meeting of Militant's leading committee, echoes Socialist Organiser's criticisms of Militant's decision to stand against Labour in the Walton by-election. Other things in the resolution are far from our politics. We print the resolution here as a service to the left.

we are to develop the organisation and prepare the ground for the future, we have a duty to seriously weigh up all our actions in the light of experience and learn the lessons of our mistakes.

Those who fail to recognise their errors or admit mistakes, stated CLIULD Trotsky many times, will never be able to construct a viable, healthy organisation.

To characterise the Walton result as some type of 'victory' is to completely misread the situation and miseducate the ranks of the organisation. Our first responsibility is to tell the ranks what it is, and not what we would like it to be. To dress up a setback in this fashion is the worst kind of deception for a Marxist organisation.

In making these criticisms, we do not for a moment take away the sterling efforts and sacrifice of the cdes involved in the election campaign who fought against all the odds to secure an electoral victory.

The problem lies squarely with the false politics of standing independently. The policy was rushed through the Central Committee after it was given a completely exaggerated, and therefore erroneous, view of the position in Walton. The majority of comrades, unfortunately, allowed themselves to be influenced mainly by subjective considerations, i.e.

their hatred of Kilfoyle. It is true that Kilfoyle is a gangster, but this is the case with most of the right wing candidates nationally.

The argument, used by the majority to justify their position, that we must orient our work for the next period "independently' is nothing new. We have, to a great extent both nationally and internationally, been forced to do so by the collapse of Left reformism, the boom, the swing to the right by social democracy and the virtual collapse in many countries of Stalinist parties.

But our orientation towards the mass organisations was crucial. To ut up a candidate in Walton was to break with the method, perspectives and theory formulated over forty years. As is the suggestion now that, despite the defeat in Walton, candidates may be put up in Scotland and elsewhere.

great part of the political capital of the tendency in Britain and internationally was the fact that we were conceived as a component part of the labour and trade union movement. We were entirely different to the sects, who try and create phantom 'mass' revolurionary parties outside of the ti experience and consciousness of avnarience and consciousness of the masses.

part from a few countries the A classical conditions for entrism have not existed for forty years. This was certainly the case in Britain. All our trade union and political work has to be determined by our orientation towards The classical conditions for entrism will undoubtedly arise during the next epoch — two, three, five or even ten years - as the crisis of world capitalism, and especially British capitalism, unfolds.

These conditions are:

1) A revolutionary or semirevolutionary crisis.

2) The leadership of social democracy loses complete control of the Party.

3) The masses move to left reformist or even centrist conclusions -there is a social ferment within the party. The lett membership becomes open to revolutionary and Marxist ideas.

4) The subjective factor is present to take advantage of the situation.

But by putting up a candidate or candidates this work is jeopardised. It can lead to a complete miseducation of the new layers, especially the youth, who may move towards us in "To characterise the Walton result as some situation and miseducate the ranks the organisation. " the next few years. It is a complete miseducation of the cadres, who can draw dangerous conclusions. They can become ultra-left and adventuristic, this in its turn rapidly leading to passivity and substitutionalism.

There could be an argument tor an independent revolutionary party, though incorrect. But to put forward the idea of an 'alternative' or 'real' Labour Party would necessarily be still-born. To be neither fish, nor fowl is to get the worst of all worlds. A few years ago we had a good laugh at the expense of the Lambertists (an alleged "Trotskyist' sect) in France who tried to create a substitute Socialist Party. Like the Lambertists, the attempt to create a 'substitute' Labour Party in Liverpool can only end in tears.

The perception of many workers in the trade unions — who regard the Labour Party as their party -would be that of regarding us as alien to their political aspirations.

The propaganda in the Multant over the last four weeks would reinforce this impression.

Up to now workers have recognised that we are organised, but as a component part of the Labour Party. But now the setting up of an 'organisation' or Party in Scotland will break this view. The illusion that such an organisation or Party could gain affiliation to the Labour Party, like the Independent Labour Party (ILP) or the Co-op, is false and even dangerous.

The ILP and the Co-op, despite the former adopting a centrist policy for a time, had an affinity Militant's erstwhile guru, Ted Grant Party accepting the affiliation of a Marxist party or organisation.

Now if before or after the general election Kinnock launches a mass. purge nationally the results could be disastrous. Formerly if mass purge was launched we would have retained the sympathy and support of wide layers in the Labour Party and trade unions. Now they would be indifferent. If you have an independent party or organisation go ahead and organise it. You can paddle your own canoe without being linked to the line of Labour.

The argument that when the conditions for entrism arise we can switch policies will not hold water. Youth and industrial workers, miseducated by an 'independent' orientation would not be prepared to change. We would have a crisis in the organisation of massive proportions. Moreover it would be very difficult to get back under these conditions. At the same time we would lose many if not most of the new movement.

Our greatest gain over a period of decades was that we became a crucial and component part of the left. Despite the collapse of the left in both the trade unions and the Labour Party, we would have been strategically placed to become an important and even dominant part of the left.

At best this has been jeopardised by the ultra-left binge in Liverpool and now in Scotland. The full effects of the defeats in Liverpool and nationally will be shown in the next few years. As predicted the 'Broad Left' did very little apart from our own comrades. Now it will fall apart. The Broad Left in any event comprises around 400 people 100 in Walton, 300 in the rest of Liverpool.

The mistake of the majority stand that the left' in the trade unions and Labour Party was running in advance of the broad mass of workers. Now the entire Liverpool Labour Party and trade unions have been handed over to the right wing for a number of years.

The Liverpool organisation will have to maintain two apparatuses - the 'real' Labour Party and Militant. The Labour Party nationally has been reduced to a skeleton. But it is not Labour which will 'wither on the example of Pilkingtons in the early 1970s, when the selling out of a strike by the national leadership of the GMBU under Lord Cooper led in desperation to the setting up of an 'independent union' . This was supported by the SWP, WRP, CP and the Tribune lefts. We alone opposed it and pointed out the consequences. The majority of workers not support it and the employers and union bureaucracy joined together to smash the union.

Unfortunately many of the Liverpool comrades, on the basis of their success in the council elections, thought they could repeat this on the parliamentary plane. Instead of most of the leading comrades of the tendency firmly opposing this they capitulated to this mood. This will have grievous consequences for the tendency in Liverpool and nationally.

That is the lesson of the attempts to create independent 'left' Labour Parties in the pre-war and post-war period. All such efforts were doomed to failure. This new adventure on the part of the Liverpool comrades will inevitably fail, and will have as a spin-off a bad effect on the Liverpool organisation which right up to the present has to be subsidised by the national tendency:

The new layers in the trade unions, even with a right wing •The action has undoubtedly played into the hands of Kinnock, Kilfoyle and Rimmer, who were able to rejection of the organisation by the workers of Walton.

Labour government will not orient toward us but towards the Labour Party in order to change it. Far from being a 'detour' , it is a blind alley to which the comrades are being led.

The argument that there was no alternative to standing is false from beginning to end. The fact that 500 workers attending Eric Heffer's funeral wanted a candidate to stand showed the lack of objectivity and sense of proportion of the Liverexaggerat exaggerated views and expectations given the response from the workers gressed, reports varied from Rorystantal vote, do neto lo,hen 'neck and then votes, 5,000 votes, then lastly to 3,000 votes. Of course this change was not alluded to in our public material and seemed to disorientate our comrades and supporters.

Big concessions were made to the non-comrades in the Broad Left: not to sell papers openly, no Militant leaflets on the official canvass. Recruitment was not seen as the priority despite the majority targets of doubling and trebling membership On Merseyside. Everything was subordinated to maximising the vote. Even the programme we stood on was not a revolutionary one. There was no explanation of the capitalist crisis and the need for a socialist planned economy, etc. The programme we offered the workers of Walton wa: in effect a left reformist one.

Our ideas were sacrificed to reserve the 'unity' of the Broa Left - which refused to participate in the campaign in any case. It appears now they are preparing to attack us for undermining the campaign. The argument that if we had refused to stand the rest of the Broad Left would have nominated a candidate is specious. We had a majority of the Broad Lefts and could have exerted pressure against this. In reality we pushed the issue. On the other hand if a splinter 'Broad Left' had stood we could have disassociated ourselves from them. We could have supported the official Labour candidate while criticising Kilfoyle and the local and national bureaucracy of the Labour socialist and revolutionary police Party and putting forward a There is nothing 'new' in this. have maintained this position in contra-distinction to the sects for nany years. A campaign of educa tion of our tendency in Liverpoo could have prevented the fiasco of Walton. In the next period we could lose members and supporters in Liverpool as the futility of maintaining a dead 'real' Labour Party becomes obvious to all.

"or the last decades we have been criticised by the sects for alleged 'passivity' and 'adaption' to the bureaucracy because we refused to break with the Labour Party. We laughed at this stupidity. Now for want of a better argument the majority have adopted the same spurious criticism of the minority. A continuation of the tried and tested policy of Marxism is hardly passivity.

We have been to the fore in advocating that the tendency takes initiatives and independent work, but always with the proviso that all the work is subject to our general orientation, perspectives, strategy and tactics. The action has undoubtedly played into the hands of Kinnock.

Kilfoyle and Rimmer, who were able to portray the result as a victory for them and a rejection of the organisation by the workers of Walton. It will now be used, as was predicted beforehand, as the excus for a purge in Liverpool and elsewhere.

In order that we can avoid disastrous mistakes of this type in the future, necessary to recognise the reality of the situation and draw out all the lessons concer-

----- pull-quotes -----

war of independence, Tom Barry, had gone

War in the British Army. Everywhere in Europe,

type of 'victory' is to completely misread the

portray the result as a victory for them and a

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 506

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →