Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Socialists answer the New Right

Socialist Organiser no. 506, 8 November 1991 · scan p. 10 · about 2,588 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

From page 9 dispose of unsuitable material, what every socialist or communist ruler who has come to power has found is that large numbers of human beings are extremely unsuitable. That is why a lot of people die. In some cases tens of millions of people die when the project of constructing a Marxist society is embarked upon.

I am obviously not saying that Marx told people to kill. It is just a matter of combining this philosophy with absolute revolutionary power.

f the rulers of a country start taking an interest in political theory, god help you, they should not. But if they do, they should read Plato or Rousseau or St Augustine. If they read Marx, get out, trouble is coming.

The Marxists, supposedly on behalf of the proletariat, take the power to improve the condition of the poor. This is the promise made by all the Marxist rulers. This has also been betrayed by all the Marxist rulers. Every revolution is betrayed.

An interest in the poor is an unhealthy taste. It may be that the people with an interest in the poor are philanthropic and care sympathetically for these people.

If you go through France you often see pictures of St Martin, the French saint who, coming across a poor man who was shivering, gave him half his coat. But it is difficult to imagine Ulyanov doing this. What they would say is that the pain and shivering of the poor is part of the machinery of changing the system.

If it is not a philanthropic and loving interest in the poor, we have to go back to the rather Platonic attitude of Marx. People are understood to be the matter of society. The point, for Marx, is that the proletariat are so far outside of society that they are less marked by the prejudices and illusions of bourgeois society and are therefore the matter out of which the new society will be constructed.

The interest in the poor is one of the most significant features of revolutionary parties. These parties are actually looking to exploit the poor.

I am trying to draw out the contradiclions of socialism. For exampie, socialists purport to hate capitalism and to love socialism. In many places, socialist societies have arisen which, despite what John O'Mahony says, were plausibly socialist. People defended the socialist sixth of the world with enthusiasm.

No-one in a capitalist society ever wanted to live in these places. The numbers who want to leave socialist societies for capitalism are very great indeed.

The Vietnamese boat people are not trying to leave for China or Cuba. They go to Hong Kong, a great bastion of capitalism.

A Marxist in the West imagines him or herself to be an independent-minded struggler against all the bourgeois illusions which are thrust upon them. The others are lost in false consciousness. The Marxist has the true consciousness.

When, however, the revolution actually arrives, the Marxists settle very easily into being aparatchniks. The independence of Marxists, the illusion of courage, comes from the fact that you have the splendid destiny of actually living in a capitalist society.

Another contradiction is notionally the doctrine dof the liberation of the proletariat from their working class condition. They will eventually become socialist. If the members of this working class decide they do not want socialism, they are simply abused as traitors to their class.

What appears to be liberation is in fact a prison. A proletarian, in Marx's terms, better think proletarian thoughts, supplied for them by the bourgeois Marx. There is an attitude of imprisonment inside the pretence of liberation.

A further contradiction: Marx's theory deplores the supposedly atomis/condition of people living in capitalist society. The notion is that we are all so cut off from each other that we are all selfishly grabbing for our own benefits in a rat race. Now, it turns out that after what John O'Mahony calls the "Stalinist system" that these collectivist systems atomise far more thoroughly than anything under capitalism.

There are so many informers and secret police that people are afraid to talk freely. All institutions of civil sociely - trade unions, churches and so on - have to be instruments of the one single system of socialism. Socialism is unity or solidarity.

Finally, revolutionary Marxist doctrine is for the moment dead, although I can see many forms of socialism and collectivism coming up on the horizon.

1 am reminded of a story Arthur Koestler tells in his autobiography. It is from his communist days in 1942. He was working in Germany for a communist newspaper in danger of being closed down by the Nazis. He says they used to tell the story of a Chinese executioner whose duty it was to cut off people's heads. He was a perfectionist whose dream in life was to cut off a head so perfectly that the person would not realise it had happened.

Years passed. One day a prisoner said: when are you going to do it? The executioner smiled and said: just kindly nod.

Koestler said they used to say to each other: just kindly nod. That is my message to you socialists.

Marx was a terrific individualist. The question up: your sociate argument. here is a lot of trying to your socialist arguments.

You say life is pretty dull and drears in a capitalist factory. That may well be right. All I can say is that not many people flee from capitalist factories into socialism or socialist countries. A lot of people from other countries and other systems try to get in. The problem the capitalist system has is not people fleeing from the horrors of it, but trying to keep people out who want to get in.

One speaker talked about mass movements for struggle and liberation The biggest mass movements are movements of immigration of individuals moving from situations they hate to situations they prefer. Often they have illusions, but by and large America, that hated dollar sign of capitalism, is an immense success story. Again, the problem is not that people want to get out, but that peopl are trying to get into it.

The lady who said as long as we'r oppressed we will fight and struggle" will find struggling doesn't really get you anywhere.

If you imagine you are in a class war then I suppose you engage in the things called fighting and struggling. But fighting and struggling is a metaphor. What you are actually doing is sitting around here, listening to me, or each other, or other people. You're not actually out there doing any real fighting.l You may occasionally go on a demo. But you largely live in a fantas world, describing what you do in terms of military metaphors. It would be even worse if you actually did it, because it wouldn't produce anything Out there in the world, there is an econmic system. I hate the word "system" because it is extremely misleading in many ways, but whatever happens, 55 million Britons are producing buildings, food, beer, vast numbers of things.

That is presumably helping somebody to do something. Whether fighting helps them to do anything is another question.

The chap who suggested I misrepresented Marx said Marx was a terrific individualist. The question then becomes no longer what is socialism, but what is individualism?

A lady said it would be nice if everybody could go to the opera and Covent Garden. Most people would be bored stiff by the opera. And to sit in the library at the LSE, I imagine, would not be a madly popular option either, except for those poor cripples like myself who have a taste for that sort of thing.

The notion of individualism involved here is simply that people have a k You might call it consumer socialisi - an idea that the future will be for everybody what an inhabitant of Mayfair with two houses in the coun try now lives.

That's not anybody's very serfous conception of the future.

A socialist conception of human beings, as I understand it, is an organismic one. A man said that Mars believed that there was a human nature — people need food, they need shelter. Of course, Marx certainly agreed that human beings are organisms.

The contrary view which, in fact, derives from Christianity, however remote it may be from the theology, that life is a challenge. It includes what some economists call positional goods. In other words, it includes quite a lot of things which logically cannot be universalised. The things called capitalist privileges cannot be given to everyone, because to some ex tent they result from competition, and in competition some people win and some people lose.

The good thing about capitalism is that it is so extensively pluralistic that some people winning in one direction are losing in terms of some other set of values.

I think death is quite an important thing to think about in this context. I would emphasise that what I am concerned with is states not in war, and the instance of the Gulf War seems to raise quite separate issues. The question here is what kind of society people want.

Adolf Hitler wanted a racially pure society, and he was a collectivist, exactly like Stalin.

The image you have of people is of great masses; collectivists even talk of elites and masses.

The word masses is a contemptuous expression, I take it. It indicates a lot of people who have no significance except that an awful lot of them have weight.

Any collectivist view of that kind seems to me to dispose people who also are in the situation of having a of power over them to move very rapidly to the view that you cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs - and people who have a lot of power have a strong disposition to make omelettes.

As they say in Moscow these days, it's easy enough to turn an aquarium into a fish soup, anybody can do that the real trick is how you turn a fish soup back into an aquarium.

John O'Mahony sums up Or Minogue says it is fantasy to talk about "fighting" and "struggle". But Mr Minogue is fighting the class struggle in one way, and on whatever. That seems to me to be what MarxWe are talking about changing the sm says about how we relate to death basis of life from one where individu During the Russian revolution - at development, individual liberty, in- a certain stage of the bloody, brutal tellectual development and so on are civil war, and the wars of intervention the privilege of a minority. We're in - you could say that such state favour of indidivualism. We want organs as the Cheka became death more individualism. We want all the obsessed. people - all the working class - to If we do say that, we must do it have the chance to develop as in- critically, and look at what created dividuals. We advocate a different ar- atmosphere in which they could rangement of fundamentals in society slaughter people so casually or so to allow that to happen. recklessly.

We locate the reason why capitalist It was created by the bourgeoisie society has immense potential for do- World War 1. ing the sort of things we want, but Now how do the people who defend doesn't do what we want, in the conthis system get the right to talk about tradiction between the social means of socialist bloodlust? The first great production and their private ownershi massacre in relation to a communist by capitalists, and all that follows revolution didn't involve communists from that in the way of keeping the murdering bourgeois. It took place in workers down and exploiting the Paris, after the Commune in 1871. workers.

Ten to fifteen thousand of our people We are for individual development.

were murdered in cold blood after the We see the road to that as being the bourgeoisie won. destruction of the system we live in, We want to fight the culture that is which individual development is death infected. reserved for a very small minority.

Capitalism has possibilities, but it Now, Hitler, Nasser, Ben-Gurion cannot realise them because of the and Clement Attlee were all class structure. Capitalism grew up in "socialists". So "socialist" is rather the womb of feudalism, and it is a fas meaningless term. But our definition that socialism - for all the pressures of socialism is the Marxist definition.

that socialists may feel - is ripening Marx's analyses of socialist in the womb of capitalism. possibilities within capitalist society in Real capitalism is not thriving indicated that socialism comes after addividualistic capitalism, but massive vanced capitalism, and was impossible monopolies, a concentration of social in conditions like Russia.

wealth, that is actually not social at a We can use two ways of judging but the property of a minority. what Marx believed to be socialism, Socialism is about converting that and what the working class experiencsocial wealth into socially controlled ed — to look at the alleged socialisms, property. and then we must define them as simp ly not socialism. In the capitalist world of today, we They were not socialist according to can already see the outlines of future the Marxist premises which pre-date capitalist conflicts — possibly future the modern labour movement, and capitalist world wars, almost certainly pre-date the Russian revolution, and capitalist trade wars. The old way of they were not socialist according to the putting the alternative before way they treated the people. humankind - the choice between As for Mr Minogue's argument socialism or barbarism — is still with about death - I don't think Marxism uS. believed that human beings are so We are fighting for a socialist, many battery hens, which is how I humane, democratic control of the vulgarise what I heard Mr Minogue means of life, which can lead to a tremendous flowering of real, mass You can argue that human life is human liberty, individualism and selffundamentally tragic. We are leaves development. the biological tree. We will cease to Those who advocate the worship of ist very quickly, all too quickly, and the established fact, and the hidden we become conscious of the reality hand that supposedly guides capitalism that our lives are fundamentally tragic. are as remote from reason as the But what do you conclude from friends of some pagan cult. that? Do you conclude that nothing is The Aztec priests cut out human of any importance? If you are hearts for their gods. The Thatcherites religious, you may think that nothing with 12 years of rule have cut out an is of any importance except waiting awful lot of human hearts. They have for the future life. But if you're not created mass poverty and barbarised religious, what do you say? part of a whole generation of young What you do say if you're a people. reasonable being is that you make this We represent the future. The class life better, not just better in the sense struggle cannot be contained. It cannot of better for yourself, but better for be beaten. It is necessary to the human beings in general. You capitalist system. If capitalism lives, so transform this life. does socialism.

----- pull-quotes -----

*The chap who suggested I misrepresented Marx said

then becomes no longer what is socialism, but what is individualism?" Kenneth Minogue's summi

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 506

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →