Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Marx believed that socialism can only come out…]

Socialist Organiser no. 506, 8 November 1991 · scan pp. 8–10 · about 2,596 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Marx believed that socialism can only come out of advanced capitalism

because of the collapse

of Stalinism in the Soviet Union. The question should be: what, if anything, did the Soviet Union have to do with socialism?

But there is a more immediate reason why we are discussing this issue in Britain. For ten years the British working class has suffered a series of defeats. If we had not had those defeats we would not have the climate of ideas we now have, and we would not be discussing issues in this way. Quite likely, there would be euphoria in the labour movement about the collapse of Stalinism.

We are Trotskyists. We are in the Trotskyist tradition. Unfortunately, "Trotskyism" today means very little. You need more information other than the word itself.

To us it means that we are people who stood against the rise of Stalinism. We are the people who were in Siberia. We were in the death camps. We organised hunger strikes in Stalin's prisons. We tried to defend the Soviet working class. We defended working-class freedom in the USSR in the 1920s.

We are also the people who made the Russian Revolution. We are not attempting to ingratiate ourselves with the bourgeoisie. We are the people who shot the Tsar and who used the state against the capitalists. We stand for genuine Marxian socialism.

The idea that Stalinism has anything to do with socialism is basreality, we will not have a state in any of the old senses. We will not have the type of bureaucratism characteristic of Stalinism.

Marxist socialists believe that socialism can only come out of advanced capitalism. It could not come from anywhere else. So Trotsky and Lenin did not believe that you could take a backward part of the world, cordon it off and build a utopian socialist colony.

Marx laughed at people with basically similar ideas — people who wanted to build socialist colonies in America.

The Russian Stalinists tried to build a vast quasi-utopian system counterposed to capitalism. That collapsed because it was not possible to take a backward country and overtake the power and the might and the wealth of the bourgeoisie in the world.

The Bolsheviks led a workers" revolution in a country where socialism was not possible. They were right to take power. They wanted to see a European and a world movement where the workers took power. They wanted advanced, capitalist Germany to be taken by the workers. Germany was actually ripe for socialism.

In 1917 socialists understood that socialism was not state tyranny. Socialism was the elimination of the capitalist system, of wage slavery and the substitution of a system of a co-operatively organised society with real democracy.

One of the central criticisms Left Oppositionists, Trotskyists fought against demonstrations such as the one pictured above, Revolution, to defend the Soviet working class Marxists make of capitalism is that it develops ideas it cannot deliver. Capitalism suffers from a giant flaw. Capitalism means private ownership of the social means of production, so equality is impossible in capitalism.

We have formal equality - for example, equality before the law. But economic inequality disrupts and destroys equality.

If, ten or 15 years ago, someone made a socialist speech like this, the speaker might well be saying that it does not matter if the democracy in Britain is suppressed, and it would not be'a bad thing to have a Stalinist system. I am not saying that.

I think the sort of liberty we have in capitalist Britain is worth defending against the stormtroopers of capitalism. In all probability, in the future, the stormtroopers will come - as they came to Germany under Hitler and in Chile under Pinochet i would concede that the capitalism we have in Britain is better than Stalinism. It is neare to socialism. Yet Nevertheless, British democracy lis a great deal short of real self-rule.

The Russian revolution was made by Marxists with the full knowledge that socialism could not be built amid backwardness. Those facts do not lessen the triumphalism of the bourgeoisie or lessen the pressure on fainthearted socialists. Nevertheless, the collapse of Russian Stalinism vindication ism.

Mr Minogue attacks the bureaucracy we find in Britain. Minogue attacks the waste of a welfare state, in fact superimposed on the capitalist system.

But, to a considerable extent, when Minogue attacks these things - calling them socialism - what he is actually attacking is the evolution of capitalism. The sort of statism which has been attacked by the so-called libertarian right is itself the product of capitalism.

Monopolies developed across the world, and the state and industry began to combine - for war and the plundering of colonies — a century ago.

Into this development have come the demands of the labour movement, for example, for welfare reforms. Desirable and good goals — like a welfare state - have been strangled with bureaucracy arising out of the conditions of a class society.

Much of what Minogue attacks is bureaucratic capitalism — which he then blames the socialists for. This is a species of ideological cardsharping. About the ng cia no nd there is more cheating Stalinism. Stalinism did not exist in the world on its own. During the long period of Stalinist rule in various countries, the bourgeoisie was the dominant world force. They are now realising their domination with the collapse of Stalinism.

Throughout this period many of the horrors of Stalinism can be traced to capitalism. For example, there are few things more terrible than the rule of the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia. They treated a large part of their own people as Hitler treated the Jews.

Yet how were the Khmer Rouge produced? This psychotic social formation arose after the modern, democratic power of the US bombed Cambodia into the Stone Age. Stalinism cannot be taken in isolation from capitalism.

Even Stalinism in the Soviet Union did not happen in isolation from capitalism. Fourteen states, including Britain, invaded Soviet Russia between 1918 and 1921. That was one of the factors which led to the rise of Stalinism.

One argument we meet is this: despite all the imperfections of capitalism, nevertheless this system is the best we can get. "Antiutopianism" is very fashionable now.

If we want to achieve a better society we are "utopians". And, comrades, "utopianism" is dangerous! Apparently it leads to Jacobin terror and Stalinism.

Marxists do not condemn capitalism totally. The Communist Manifesto contains a vast paean of praise, by Karl Marx, to the capitalist system. He says the capitalists have done wonderful things.

Capitalism is progressive in history. It creates the conditions whereby capitalist ideas of liberty and equality can actually be realised. From this point of view, capitalism has been progressive.

In previous epochs of history class society was necessary. In ancient Greece, when Aristotle argued in favour of slavery, he was truly arguing for a necessary condition 'of their civilisation.

I would concede that the capitalism we have in Britain is better than Stalinism. It is nearer to socialism. Yet capitalism is still a dog-eat-dog system.

Capitalism can work. It can continue for a long time. But only by destroying large parts of the means

Scan page 9

r the New Right «Socialism is a type of perpetual vingin™ of production and creating unemployment, by going into wars.

We hear about the horrors of Stalinism. I do not excuse them. But in this century we witnessed the near destruction of European civilisation - by forces arising from capitalism.

"It is arguable we cannot completely do away with the market. Who needs to do such a thing? But what we can do is eliminate the private ownership of the means of production and wage slavery, and introduce real, democratic selff you walk from the London School of Economics, where Mr Minogue works, down Kingsway or the Strand, you find people asleep in doorways. In Lincoln's Inn Fields there are over I00 people camped. We live in a world where homelessness is normal.

We live in a world where culture is degraded by the profit motive. Where the mass of the population are not educated to have the possibility of realising self-rule.

All these horrible situations are rooted in the fact that there is private, minority ownership of the means of production and everythiing is geared to justifying and maintaining the minority's rule.

Capitalism has its horrors, too.

Right now, we can see the outlines of three great trade blocs emerging: America, Japan and European. If capitalism once again slows down, and there is no reason to presume it will not, there is the possibility of the collapse conditions of the i930s. The nightmare scenarios is a 1984-world with three great warring powers.

Capitalism is not a stable system. Capitalism is progressive, historically, allowing the creation of a working class. But then the working class must actually seize its historic destiny and put itself in conscious control of society.

It is arguable that we can not completely do away with the market. Who needs to do such a thing? But what we can do is eliminate the private ownership of the means of production and wage slavery, and introduce real, democratic self-control.

Is socialism dead? No - and it will not be until capitalism is dead. Socialism is a product and an answer to capitalism.

The capitalists can win victories in the class struggle, but they cannot eliminate the working class. The class struggle will continue and the workers' movement will revive. Socialism will revive.

We are witnessing the purging of socialism of all the crustations of Fabian statism and Stalinism. This is the purification of socialism.

We are seeing the opportunity for real socialism to expand. This is not the end of history. This is a new phase of history where real socialism will have a far better chance than when our heroic comrades took power in Russia in 1917. Kenneth Minogue replied to John O'Mahony lot depends on definitions.

A There are a lot opal ed words: capitalism, socialism, workers' power, democracy. These have been shuffled like packs of cards.

When John O'Mahony says "Stalinism was never what socialists believed to be socialism" he is simply wrongThis is a matter of historical fact. Great numbers of people fought for the defence of the Soviet Union as. the homeland of socialism. It is only as the project has more obviously failed that they gave it up.

I was struck by a story from the Tiananmen Square episode. It was repeated in Moscow. In both cases some luckless person said: "Now I know what fascism really means"

Now why did these people choose the word "fascism"? These people were communists, not fascists.

I think this illustrates one of the ways in which socialism is a type of perpetual virgin, never touched by experience. In Islam, the reward of warriors going to paradise is to meet women for ever econstituted as virgins. Socialism is like this.

John O'Mahony says that socialism is sometimes regarded as an ideal which is too good for us. It is a marvellous idea which we can not actually achieve. O'Mahony believes it can be achieved.

I believe revolutionary workers' socialism is pretty dead. All forms of socialism ought to be dead. I would like to see a stake through its heart. It has caused more death, unpleasantness and boredom than almost any other doctrine.

Socialism involves a curious conception of society: a society in which there are no rich or poor; no aristocratic or bourgeois; no people dying for love or dreaming of getting rich; no scandal, gossip, monarchy - all the things which keep us enthused. We have little comrades slotted into a society where their needs are perfectly satisfied.

This happens not to be the type of world I would like to live in.

If we ask: what is the opposite of socialism?, the obvious answer is "We live in a world where homelessness is normal" capitalism. Capitalism is one of those packages containing everything.

Capitalism contains the experiences in this hall, a type of socialism within capitalism. All over Britain you will find Hari Krishna people trying to worship at Stonehenge. You find a vast number of activities.

The point about capitalism is that a great number of people do a vast number of different things with a great number of conflicting beliefs. This plurality distinguishes capitalism from socialism.

"Individualism is almost unavoidably the type of life you live in a modern society. What peop themselves from others; select thei clothes, wear jewellery which contrasts with others"'' You have to believe in socialism in order to live in a socialist society. You do not have to believe in capitalism to live in a capitalist society. According to quite respectable opinion you better not have a religion in a socialist society. The Russians set up the League of the Godless to remove all the nonsense from people's minds.

The contrast is therefore between socialism as a single way of life, right through society, and capitalism as immensely plural.

o, how did the notion that Marx, recommending a single way of life to a set of people who were already accustomed to a great plurality of ways of life, for rhetorical purposes had to present capitalism as a unity.

Marx said: you may think you are as free as the birds, but in fact capital determines everything about you — it is a single system. This is a major mistake underlying Marxism.

If you ask: what is the opposite of socialism?, the answer is individualism.

Individualism is almost unavoidably the type of life you live in a modern society. What people in modern society do is to distinguish themselves from others; select their clothes, wear jewellery which contrasts with others. In thousands of ways individual endeavour is central to humans in a modern societyWe go through these vanities then we die. Dying is important, people think a lot about it. What did Marx say about death? He writes a single sentence: death is a biological accident. This is an interesting comment which tells you a lot about Marx.

The way I would interpret it would be to connect it with other texts where Marx says there is no such thing as human nature; this is an ideological mystification, humans are essentially historical creatures without any essential nature.

What I take Marx to mean is that a human being is social input plus organic transferances. Man is simply matter on which society makes its imprint.

Marx's view is that a human being is the matter out of which societies are constructed. Now this is a significant part of Marx's doctrine. I think Marx imagined a communist society to be rather like a giant computer. Every individual, no longer alienated, would have the great power of society available.

By contrast to the present world, what he hated about capitalism is that we as individuals are alienated from each other, we have shames. It is the thing Christians mean by original sin.

Some types of socialist are people who have a vision of society and who think that the only valuable thing is a society which is lived in a certain sort of way. In order to do this there has to be "engineering". Just as in any fabricating you may well want to Continued over on page 10

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser No. 506 page 10

----- pull-quotes -----

capitalism is still dog-eat-dog system"

in modern society a is to distinguish

capitalism as a single thing ever get going? The answer is

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 506

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →