Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

What does the collapse prove about Stalinism?

Socialist Organiser no. 506, 8 November 1991 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,704 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

CITis Anther sambored The Directics of bow" and editor of the English edition of Marx's and Engels' "Germarallenlogy. queries=SO suconchusnows aa bow muc Stalinistsburenucracies beng wulingwlassess anTon Rigby replies. The columns of SO are open to other limited parallel to a certain stage of surplus product opened the depfla bureaucracy's road to power." AUTOET nemoi This is the only way available to test The bureaucracy was no longer for form always naturally corresponds to a alkynan obgeaton вн SKT Trotsky merely a *gendarme in the definite stage of development in the makes the same point. "The holds the innermost secret, the hidden опів жимите сина. eEl nomenklatura controls the surplus pro- foundation of the entire social struchymi ure and hence also of the political Chris only obscures reality it to itself. In other words they are exunbearable, strain on the *degenerated It strikes me as very strange reason transformine bourgeois society. or the bourgeois misinterpretation of Marx- what kind of workers state has no in- bureaucracy are exploiters but then Why? ransformed into its opposite when i olitical democracy and an exploitative for tear this would make the socialist accordance with which one accurately a class is amplified when you consider truth. The term class merely helps in l cuts the historical facts."

World War capitalism first revived and Chris obscure? I think it is the whole surplus as the "hidden secret" of "*the turn underlines the necessity of an unStalin used terror to back-up forced stal, me analysis rocuses cleary ou which unpaid surplus labour is tion. When the terror slackened off, surplus: determines the relationshin of ruler develoomenor are s oductive torces.

and ruled, as it grows directly out of more in 60 (not 70) years than the old bureaucrats want the full-scale it could secure either by the exercise of upon it as a determinant.

ETE UCECEL force or of its authority or by direct based the entire formation of the epochether or not this means we of the August coup and the banning of intervention in economic relations. In economic community growing out of the matter of the national surplus pro- he productive relations themselves, From the vantage point of 1991, it duet the bureaucracy and the petty Likewise. It is always the direct rela- a capital "Pr" is, 1 think, a matter of Stalinism was and is. nothine bat a alliance to enmity. The control of the tionship of the owners of the condicOMMONS iN his continuig discussion respond to your article on Stalinism partly because I was myself tempted with this position in the past.* But I find it weird that you adopt it at the very moment history refutes it! Let me explain.

The namank-la surplus product and appropriates a Chris Arthur's letter raises Trindionshenleftto ouramanis ever the ecs he troumen rawed It is just not possible in 1991 to resurrect Trotsky's 1939 perspective that "Either the Stalinist regime is abhorrent relapse in the process of Stalin regime is the first stage of a new facts of historical development say otherwise.

Decaying capitalism did not colrevolution at the end of the Second then enioved the longest and most exStalinism didn't collapse either. But in the long run it lost out in historical competition with capitalism.

system lost much of its dynamism.

the CP has cleared the road for this seems to me perfectly clear that large slice of it to itself. In other words, they are exploiters. Why not then, you ask, say they are a ruling class! Is not this step a mere technicality? So it seems.

But in truth everything hangs on this "technicality" . Trotsky wriggled every which way to avoid this conclusion, calling the bureaucracy "ctate naracite" a "nolitical caste", etc. Why was he so frighten- MAnn *The proof of necessity lies in human ky's prognosis was too final and closby attempting to fit it into a 50 year old scheme. This is the reverse of the The materialistic method is of historv, but as a tinished stencil in But what feature of reality does traction and control of the social Fi you look at one of Trotsky's last works, his untinished biography of the bureaucracy's control of the The bureaucracy took for itself that part of the national income which ed of calling the Stalinists a ruling class? And he was frightened — he was terrified.

The reason is that, as he points out, once we admit that a previously unknown mode of production has sprung up with its associated class structure then our entire historical perspective is in ruins! We had argued that the choice was socialism or barbarism. Now it seems capitalism is succeeded not by socialism but by this new thing, wnatever it is; call it bureaucratic collectivism" with Shachtman.

If it is more progressive than capitalism then we face "centuries of deformed workers' states" — except of course they couldn't be that if they last centuries. If it is less progressive then history can regress. Either way socialism becomes a utopia.

Fortunatelv Shachtman turned out to be wrong and Trotsky has All this puts tremendous, in fact formula: after all dementen eass organisa 01s. 10 The case for calling the bureaucrac Volume Ill about the extraction of the entire social structure • That is, as consuuuno une mos Dase real underpinning both classes and the "The specific economic form in DUELDCO OUR OF BIC BECE OrOdUCCES and therewith its specific political form been vindicated. That Stalinism could so rapidly vanish up its own arsehole proves that it was after all a sui generis self-aborting monstrosity and not a genuine new mode of production. (I take it you would not be so childish as to argue an entire epoch could be over in 70 years).

Predictably, every tendency claims to be vindicated by current events. As an impartial observer I award the palm to Hillel Ticktin and the Critique comrades. Their analysis was the only one remotely connected to the real world.

* See under pen name Biro, "Workers' states — problems of transition", in Bulletin of Marxist Studies;

and improved version under my name:

"The Soviet Revolution", in Krasso, N (ed), Trotsky: the Great Debate Renewed, St Louis, Mo: New Critics Press, 1972, pp 151-191.

tions of production to the direct proways and means of labour and hence elanonship, un suore, or te specie form of the state in each case." ing indeed for Chris to accept that the away rom came tem a class perspective a ritopia.

Nothing could be further from the compromising working class hostility mode of production exist for only 70 vears? Well, I would say that Marxist measure historical development not b the hands on the clock but by the humanity managed in the entire feudal should award Stalinism the title Mode foth nege few nes or striking; employer-imposed ballots ot unions; restriction on union representatives entering workplaces; extended working hours; company-by-company con tracts to replace industry-wide conditions; and reduced powers to the state Industrial Relations Commission, traditionally seen by unions as an "independent arbiter" or "umpire" in disputes.

The new Labor Council called the strike, because they could not ignore this threat to union organisation (on which they depend) and because unionists are fed up with the Liberal government.

The strike was remarkably wellsupported despite the blunders of the leadership. Exemptions were granted to emergency workers, the staff of the New South Wales Parliament and the Labor Councilowned radio station.

The strike was postponed by a week when it was discovered that members of the International Olympic Committee would be in Sydney. Labor Council did not want to jeopardise Sydney's bid to host the Olympics.

There were no rallies Ог demonstrations organised in Sydney, on the grounds that the strike by transport workers would have made it too difficult for people to attend.

Labor Party leader, Bob Carr, attempted to sit on the fence, stating opposition to the Industrial Relations Bill, but also saying that "this strike should not have to happen -NSW can't afford it"?

He didn't blame the government for the strike, or give the strike his support - except by declining to be interviewed by scab journalists on the day of the strike.

In Parliament, NSW premier, Nick Greiner taunted Labor as to whether they supported the strike. Two MPs raised their hands to show support, but not one spoke in Parliament.

The left has been nearly invisible throughout. There does not seem to be any united front left or rank-and-file campaign in the unions or ALP against Greiner's Bill.

The Socialist (ISO/SWP) and Green Left Weekly (paper of the Democratic Socialist Party, formerly SWP) have given poor coverage. Socialist did put the strike on their back page, and declared this showed the power of the unions. DSP thumbed its nose at Labor for failing to back a green independent candidate for Parliament, who (the DSP says) might have tipped the vote on the Bill.

The general strike shows how strong opposition is to Greiner and suggests that workers may well fight very vigorously if the Bill is used to penalise unions. The left should be taking advantage of this, instead of lying doggo.

Scan page 8

The New Right sees the collapse of Stalinism as a signal for spouting ever-mo anti-socialist ideas. At the Stand Up For Real Socialism conference last weekend, we attempted to answer them. John O'Maho debated Kenneth Minogue o the London School of Economics. John 0'Mahony spoke first are discussing *Is ed on a series of misrepresentations. According to the Marxist notion of socialism, we have something in common with Minogue. We do not want state socialism. Marxists believe that ultimately society will be organised without coercion.

The real roots of bureaucratic tyranny in British capitalist society and in the USSR lie in the fact that both these types of society are ruled by a minority. This minority cannot tolerate real democracy, only - as here - shallow forms of democracy. These societies cannot allow self-rule by the people.

Because self-rule cannot be allowed, we get bureaucratic rule — although the levels of bureaucracy differ Marxists believe that once the rule of the bourgeoisie is smashed and the self-rule of the people is a YAENKKKGAPKATA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 506

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →