How not to build a Broad Left
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Further to the article in SO 503 on child abuse, in Stafford, where the "pindown" scandal that hit the national headlines was centred, the new Children's Act cannot even be implemented due to a lack of cash.
According to David Livingstone, the district manager of Stafford Social Services, the Act requires substantial extra spending, but not an extra penny has been forthcoming from the government. Money is needed to deal with existing problems, but Stafford is in desperate need of a family centre to "enable us to work with families rather than just step in when problems reach crisis point."
The new Act requires social workers to work more closely with families in crisis, but Mr Livingstone says he is "concerned about how we meet the requirements of the Act. While we welcome its emphasis on working closely with parents, we have to ensure sufficient staff and resources. The government may say money for social services is included in local authority grants, but it is just not enough."
As SO's article says, it has taken a major piece of legislation to put children's rights on the statute book, but this is far from enough. We need a government that is prepared to implement, in more than words, such vital social legislation as this, but most of all we need a society in which such things are unnecessary in the first place.
Steve Revins Stafford A "pin-down" room where children in a local authority were jailed in solitary confinement when they fell foul home in of staff return to ane vlare wiere a had taught and apologise to the children and their parents.
The villagers were understanwatershed for Wittgenstein in shlk conservative attitudes he grew small human beings punitive, violent, possessive 1w na SeBH YVIL tgenstein, anyway.
EVE=ON THESTERT reparations are now well advanced for the merger between NALGO, NUPE and CoHSE to form a giant new superunion for the public sector.
This union will be the largest TUC affiliate, and made up predominantly of low-paid workers. A very large slice of its membership will be women. It will have great potential.
If the new union mobilises its membership effectively, it can really do something to wipe out low pay, and thus not only help its own members but also give courage to the millions of low-paid part-time workers who are presently outside the trade union movement.
In this situation you would expect that the left would be doing everything it can to be well placed when the new union comes into existence. You would expect left-wingers to be putting forward serious proposals for really knitting the union together, focussing on issues like how to control the national "The merger between NALGO, NUPE and CoHSE will be the largest TUC affiliate... The left should be putting forward At a Broad Left "conference" this spring, addressed Fby Socialist Worker editor (and NUJ member) Chris Harman on why socialists should leave the Labour Party, critical speakers from SO were prevented by the chair from having their say. SWers explained that anybody wearing an "End the Ban" (by the Labour Party on SO) t-shirt was bound to make a sectarian speech! In other words, the SWP treated the Broad Left as their private property.
The latest Broad Left bulletin provides another sad example. There is no intelligent analysis of the merger, or the local government pay ballot defeat. Instead, we get a front-page lead on the defeated Moscow coup that could have come straight from Socialist Worker, and a reprint of the SWP's "Open Letter to Labour Party members" urging them to give up the fight in the political wing of the labour movement.
Where the bulletin does try to relate to the trade-union concerns of NALGO members, it gets hopelessly lost.
For example, the ballot defeat is explained as all the fault of the leadership. "Unfortunately the NALGO leadership tailed to organise the action necessary to win".
But workers have voted for action in ballots run by equally bad union leaderships. Why did they vote against this time? A serious explanation would have to come to terms with several factors: the role of the national and local leaders, the general low level of trade union militancy, the recent defeats suffered by council workers in local battles, and the changed circumstances since the 1989 pay fight (i.e., the recession)...
Socialist Worker is now trade unions that are the exact opposite of what it was saying a few years ago.
In the early '80s, the heyday of the dreaded "downturn" theory, a whole series of "objective factors" - the slump, the strength of the officials, and the bureaucratisation of the top layers of the shop stewards' movement - were said to make a serious fight impossible.
For instance, in 1982, just six weeks before the biggest dispute in the history of the NHS and the public sector, the SWP wound up *their " rank and file paper Hospital Worker and the group round it. Their "downturn theory" told them that there was no point trying to organise the rank and file, so they didn't even try. Six months later, more workers took solidarity action to support the NHS workers than had struck to free the Pentonville Five dockers in July 1972, at the high point of the modern shop stewards' movement.
Now, less than ten years and many defeats later, nothing but the cowardice of the union leaders explains anything. SW has turned full circle.
The SWP looks more and more like Gerry Healy's crazy Workers' Revolutionary Party in the years just before it went completely mad. It has attempted to turn the NALGO Broad Left into an appendage of "the party" in just the same way as Healy ran the All Trades Unions Alliance as a satellite of the WRP.
That makes it all the more strange when Socialist Worker denounces the OIL's decision to form an Offshore Workers' Union by comparing it to the Communist Parties' ultra-left attempts to form breakaway "Red Unions" in the early 1930s.
But perhaps it is not so strange. After all, why bother with the trouble of building a whole new "Red Union" when you can have your own sectarian "Red" Broad Left with a lot less effort?
----- pull-quotes -----
proposals for really knitting