Stop backing Labour and being sectarian
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
have read one issue of SO and would be interested to find out more about you. There are a couple of points which I disagree with you about, and I would like to hear your comments on these.
Firstly, your position seems to be very pro-Labour, and although you acknowledge that it is not a proper socialist party, you call it a working class party, and call on your supporters to campaign for Labour in the next general election.
I don't know how you can quote from Karl Marx and support this bourgeois organisation at the same time, and I view Labour as a greater setback to socialism than the Tories.
During Tory governments, workers are led to believe that a Labour government will solve all their problems. Disillusionment with Labour was one of the things which made the National Front so powerful in the late "70s.
Under Ted Heath's Tory government in the early "70s, there was great solidarity between trade unions. Under the following Labour government this was broken down and there was an increase in scabbing, as the workers mistakenly thought that it was their government.
The reason why Labour is such a setback is because the working class believes that it is their party, something which they can have mistakes on about the Tories Socialists should be recruiting from the Labour Party and trying to show the working class an alternative to it.
If people ask you who to vote for, they should be told not to vote for anyone and join an organisation on the left. What, in the long term, has decades of jumping between Labour and Tory governments done for the working class?
There have, of course, been improvements in the 91 years Labour has existed. But these are the concessions made by capital to the working class, which have been going on since the 1830s, even when there was no democracy at all for the majority, and certainly no Labour Party.
The second issue is sectarianism - which, unfortunately, you seem to be guilty of. Naturally the SWP is chosen as it is one of the largest organisations on the left and it is less sectarian, meaning it won't respond to your criticisms with a counter-attack on you.
If you have any criticisms, why don't you just write to the SWP? I have also found something in your newspaper which can only be described as hypocrisy. On the front I see the slogan "Unite the left". Great, but how can you seriously expect to achieve this when you print a letter calling Tony Cliff of the SWP "a cynical, lying old creature"?
Constructive and comradely criticism is fine, but statements like these can only divide the left.
Jonathan Bowen Colchester unity by fighting for the harmonisation of terms and conditions between blue and white collar public sector workers.
That is what you would expect. And some people on the left are doing just that.
For example, Bury NALGO is to host a conference on November entitled Organising the Left for the New Union. They have enlisted the support of some CoHSE and NUPE activists for the project, and it looks like it could go well.
But the biggest opposiBion wrong me tied in te the unions involved in the merger - the NALGO Broad Left - is busy making itself as irrelevant as possible.
Since the Socialist Workers" Party (SWP) seized control of the Broad Left in a coup last year, they have provided a highly educative example of how not to build a broad rank-and-file trade union opposition.
Scan page 15
NDUSTR Socialist Organiser