Adam Keller on what's behind the Madrid peace conference The biggest split yet between the US and Israel
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
In the evening of 26 October an enormous crowd gathered at Tel-Aviv's Municipality Square demonstrating for peace. People continued streaming out of buses which arrived from all over the country.
Careful experts estimated that there were at least 80,000 people.
One speaker read a letter from Abie Nathan, written in his prison cell. Accompanied by wild applause she added: "Haim Herzog, President of the State of Israel! | call upon you to use your authority and pardon Abie Nathan on the very day of the Madrid conference. It is an abomination to continue imprisoning Abie Nathan for his meeting with Yasser Arafat, while the government itself enters into negotiations with the Palestinians"
The convening of the Madrid conference is the result of six months strenuous diplomatic effort by American Secretary of State James Baker.
The most decisive stage took place in early September in Washington DC when President Bush took on - and defeated in a head-on collision - the powerful Jewish lobby and its following on Capitol Hill.
Bush's intervention prevented the approval of $10 billion in housing loan guarantees to Israel. The discussion of the guarantees is put off until January or February 1992.
It now seems likely that, even then, a condition will be attached to the guarantees strictly limiting - if not altogether forbidding - Israeli settlement activity in the Occupied Territories. Moreover, it is quite possible that similar conditions will be attached to the regular American aid to Israel, $3 billion a year — hitherto, the least controversial item on the congressional agenda.
Already a senate committee failed to approve a request for an additional $200 million in military aid to Bush's displeasure with the Shamir government was displayed in other ways as well, such as loud protests when Israeli planes carried out aerial reconnaissance of Western Iraq (and in the process, violated the airspace of Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Saudi Arabia!)
Former Israeli Foreign Minister Abba Eban — a man usually not given to superlatives concluded *This is the worst crisis ever in Israeli-American relations"
with Shamir may have provid- resident Bush's confrontation ed PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat with the decisive argument needed in order to obtain in the Palestine National Council and other PLO bodies an overwhelming majority in favour of Palestinian participation in the Americanbrokered conference. That decision required the Palestinian leadership to swallow several bitter pills.
The American conditions excluded the PLO from any official role in the conference; restricted the Palestinian participation to half of a joint delegation with Jordan; and excluded East Jerusalem Palestinians as well as Palestinians from the diaspora from being delegates.
In fact, the PLO had to accept all of the procedural preconditions posed by the Shamir government.
However, while complying with the letter of these conditions, the Palestinians managed, to a major extent, to circumvent them. Little doubt was left that all the decisions on the Palestinian side are being taken by the PLO and that Palestinian negotiators Feisal Husseini and Hanan Ashrawi were acting under Arafat's authorisation and instructions.
Thus Yitzhak Shamir, heading the most right wing, nationalist government in Israeli history, finds himself compelled to do what all his predecessors avoided - engage in negotiations with what is, to all intents and purposes, a PLO delegation. His denials that this is so only add to the confusion and disarray in the government circles and among Likud supporters.
n 1977, the opening of official relEgyptian peace negotiations was preceded by secret talks in Morocco, where the basic principle - Israeli withdrawal from Sinai in return for Israeli-Egyptian peace - was agreed upon, even before President Sadat set foot in Jerusalem.
There are indications Our series Labour's y the early ' continued present Madrid Conference is being preceded by such a prior understanding; on the contrary, it seems that Shamir is likely to make all possible efforts to sabotage the conference from the outset.
Shamir's government vehemently proclaims its intention to hold on to the whole of the Occupied Territories and - in token of this - to continue constructing settlements and changing the demographic balance in the territories subject to negotiations.
Unless resolved, the settlement issue in itself can cause a break up of the talks within days of their opening. And should Shamir be somehow made to accept a settlement freeze (in return for a lifting of the Arab trade boycott on Israel?), numerous other pitfalls wait ahead.
The task of pushing the conference forward would fall, in the first place, to the Americans. It is they who brought it into being, despite the formal pretence of equal American-Soviet co-sponsorship.
As the inhabitants of Panama and Iraq can testify, George Bush is no apostle of peace. He is a cool and calculating politician, whose assessment of the Amercian national interest would seem for the time being to coincide with some of the aims of the Israeli peace movement.
Whatever, the politicians and diplomats get up to, it is up to us -the peace-seekers in Israel and elsewhere - to maintain and increase our pressure and our struggle.
Abridged on the left and outh movement 1960s will be next week