Truth, lies and polemic Rivers of rubbish
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
TIPE Biblical scholars have, I understand, Ba terrible time of it working out what some of the long-vanished early Christian groups believed.
They have to rely on such chance survivals as the "Dead Sea Scrolls". Most of the rich history of the competing Christian groups is lost: the victorious Catholic Chris tians, entwined with the Roman and later states from the early 4th century onwards, suppressed their opponents and left little trace of them and their beliefs except factional slanders and lies. Mostly we don't know what they believed.
If all the files of Socialist Organiser were to be destroyed and future historians of British socialism had to rely on the comments of our "socialist" critics, they would face a similarly hopeless task establishing what Socialist Organiser believed in.
Examples of grotesque misrepresentation are legion. Some are products of emotion blended with incomprehension. For instance, on issues of national or communal conflict, like those in Northern Ireland and in Israel/Palestine, we base ourselves on thi Marxist idea of consistent democracy, and take as our model the application of that idea by the Bolshevik party in the vicious cauldron of ethnic and national conflict in which they operated (and which is now bubbling furiously again: anybody on the left still capable of thinking about Ireland should look at the Catholic-Protestant conflict through the prism of events in Yugoslavia).
We reject the demonisation of Israeli Jews and Northern Ireland Protestants; we say there is right on both sides and that no national or ethnic group forfeits its right to exist because it is, for now, an oppressor or a would-be oppressor; we advocate mutual accommodation and a common struggle of the working class in the conflict-ridden peoples, based on support for the oppressed and mutual guarantees against fear of future oppression. Thus we propose a federal Ireland with local autonomy, and two states for the two peoples in Ignorant of the ideas of historical Marx ism on questions like this; delirious with vicarious "Third Worldist" national and communal chauvinism distilled from sympathy with those presently oppressed; religious in denying that such peoples can ever be chauvinistic, the sectarian left denounce us as supporters of the oppressors as "pro-imperialist", or as people who lac the moral fibre to withstand the pressure of... the Labour Party!
Thus the SWP, not just in offhand heated exchanges but in an official document written by junior guru Alex Callinicos, accuses us of supporting the Israeli state's terror in the West Bank and Gaza! They seem unable to comprehend what we are on about. Some of the incomprehension, no doubt, is our fault; but communication is a two-way enterprise.
Or take the Falklands war. We opposed that war. But we did not, like the "anti-imperialist" left (and much of the Labour left), support Argentina; nor did we dismiss the claimed rights to self-determination of the British population of the Falkland Islands, 400 miles from Arge tina.
Since the Falklanders oppressed no-one, the islands were not a British base for oppressing anyone, and the British had been there 150 years, long before the modern Argentinian state existed, we saw no reason to back the claim to the islands of Argentina, which was then in the grip of the fascistic self-aggrandising junta who invaded the islands.
But we were, by any standards, against Thatcher's war of prestige and nostalgic gunboat imperialism. Throughout the war we carried on SO's masthead a variant of Karl Liebknecht's and Rosa Luxemburg's slogan in World War 1: *The enemy is at home". But ask any sectarian today, and you'll hear that SO did not oppose the Falklands (sorry, "Malvinas") war.
Then again: SO, which tries to be an open paper, carried an article by the then MP Reg Race advocating economic instead of military sanctions against Argentina. Th same issue of SO opposed that idea editorially — on page one. Nevertheless the sectarians say: "SO called for economic sanctions". And so on.
All that sort of thing — and there is a vast bulk of it — is compounded from incomprehension mixed with malice and hysteria. And then there is the outright lying and falsification.
one of the worst examples is a pamcirculation for over a decade, by the SLL/WRP. It alleged that Workers' Fight (a grouping in which some of us now involved with SO were then active supported the deployment of the British army in Northern Ireland.
It had a picture of British soldiers searching a man in Northern Ireland with his hands in the air, and the caption seemed to blame us, and me personally, for it. In fact Workers' Fight opposed the deployment of the troops in 1969 (though who was right and who was wrong in the debates of that time, and to what extent, is a complex question). When the SWP (then called IS) supported the deployment of troops, the Workers' Fight grouping inside IS organised an opposition to that policy, and, after a heated campaign, forced them to reverse it.
I co-authored a pamphlet which helped change people's minds and went round the country speaking and debating on it; I moved the resolution at the IS National Committee in May 1970 which reversed the policy. Before that I had happened to be a member of the council which, between August and October 1969, ran Catholic Derry behind barricades to keep out the British Army. When the people now in John Hume's SDLP moved that we remove the barricades and let the British Army in peacefully, the local leaders of the left backed the motion — they felt we were in a complete impasse — and I moved the defeated motion of opposition to letting the British Army take over "Free Derry". My amendment rejected the right of the committee to liquidate "Free Derry", and proposed that the issue be put to a mass "Examples of grotesque misrepresentation are iegion. Some are products of emotion blended with incomprehension And then there is outright lying."
meeting of the people who lived there.
Later, the Workers' Fight group becam the only British left group to have its hea quarters raided by armed police in conner tion with Ireland (in September 1973: the WRP "college" was raided by police in 1975, after a member had complained about ill-treatment there).
But still, we, and myself in particular, were branded as supporters of the British Army in Northern Ireland in 1969, and we had a direct responsibility for what the British state was doing in Northern Ireland! Or so the WRP said.
Everyone knows the Healy WRP were liars. But so is the IS/SWP. In the mid-'70s SWPer David Widgery edited a Penguin book on The Left in Britain, consisting almost entirely of old IS/SWP articles. In it he defined WF as a group which "proposed the repartition of Ireland". It was a lie.
It might be argued that some of the things we said then might — if X happen that way, and then Y this way - have ler to a repartitioned Ireland. We did not ad. vocate that, we did not want it, and nothing we proposed was meant by pamphlet Who are the International Socialists?, written by Cliff support for the troops. achieve that. Yet the story still circulates.
Or take this more recent example:
an article in Socialist Organiser rejected Militant's claim to be the political heirs of Eric Heffer.
"Rivers of blood" separated Heffer, the consistent anti-Stalinist, from Militant, wrote Anne Field. Militant "regards the now-collapsing Stalinist states as workers* states and even supported the Soviet Union's bloody occupation of Afghanistan." (Emphasis added; and there are examples other than Afghanistan of Militant's enthusiasm for Stalinism, thougl none so terrible).
At least two publications have denounce Socialist Organiser for equating adherence to the theory that the Stalinist states are "degenerated or deformed workers' states", perse, with sharing responsibility for the Stalinist "rivers of blood"!
A broadsheet entitled *Revolutionary In ternationalist League" (R.I.L.), given out at Labour Party conference put the anti-Socialist Organiser canard like this: Socialist Organiser said "rivers of blood" lay between Eric Heffer and Militant because "they regard the East European states as deformed workers' states". Full stop! That would indeed be strange - and indeed very cur-like — since we ourselves were "workers' statists" when we took the opposite view to that of Militant on Russia's "Vietnam War" in Afghanistan!
R.I.L. is on the extreme idiocy wing of kitsch Trotskyism (the same publication called on the - mainly Kinnockite - conference delegates to "disrupt" conference and force a way in for Nellist and Fields!)
The lie seems to have originated in Workers" Press", published by one of the saner splinters from Gerry Healy's WRP. There the sentence from Anne Field appeared in full quotes, but with a full stop after "workers' states" and the example of Afghanistan simply lopped off, with no indication of a cut.
The author of the "Workers' Press" effort was a certain Charlie Pottins, who used to lend his name — and his status as a Jew and a member of the all-too-tolerant Jewish Socialists' Group (JSG) - to some of the foulest anti-Socialist Organiser polemies produced against us by the Healy WRP. Themselves subsidised by Arab governments - Iraq, Libya — and paid by them to spy on Arab dissidents and prominent Jews here, they used to have crazy articles accusing us of being in a "Zionist conspiracy" with Reagan and Thatcher!
(The episode, in passing, demonstrates with wonderful irony the advantages of principled Leninist politics over everything else on the left. The JSG is a rather strang and loose political group, organised round an ill-defined Jewishness rather than precis Matgamna's group, together with all the opportunists and revisionists, supported the intervention of British troops in N Ireland precisely on the terms of the division of the working class N Ireland.
political ideas. Here, their a-political solidarity with Pottins meant that they allowed themselves to be used as camouflage for Healy's WRP, who were the paid agents of various Arab governments, agents whose brief included the task of spying on prominent Jews in Britain. A blinkered a-political self-definition as "Jewish" led these Jewish socialists into an unwanted — but, for the Healyites, very useful - association with mercenary antisemites, who were nothing less than potential pogromists. The JSG may not recognise Leninist politics, but Leninist politics recognises the JSG!)
"A 'Trotskyist' archipelago, with little dialogue between the different atolls...
*Workers' Press" is sectarian and disoriented, but it has made strenuous efforts in the last 6 years to slough off the ly. ing practices of Healy. So why this misrepresentation of Socialist Organiser? What purpose is served? Maybe they need to send Charlie Pottins back to the deHealyisation centre, and preferably for life!
This great bog of myths, half-truths, and lies, cynical or hysterical, of which I have surveyed a few patches here, testifies to the ideological decay of the left.
It presupposes a world of closed groups, the "Trotskyist" archipelago, with little dialogue or exchange of information between the inhabitants of the different atolls and little desire or demand for it — a demand, on the contrary, for myths and lies and the sustaining half-truth, and a keen eagerness to believe stories that the people of the neighbouring island go around with their heads under their arms because their ears are three feet long. It testifies to a political world way below the standards of truth and objectivity of even the serious bourgeois newspapers. It presupposes a mental world where people don't want to know, or — and this is the point, I think - cannot afford to let themselves know if they are to sustain their commitment and their conviction. They cannot afford to let themselves think.
It is a world in which the citizens have lost the battle on the ideological front against bourgeois society, and have retreated into private political worlds of their own, hidden behind protective barrier of myths, lies and special pleading to protect them from the often painful choices of the real world. A healthy revolutionary socialist movement would engage critically and creatively with that real world, going out to take on the ideological battle rather than sheltering behind lies, myths, and demonisation of those who refuse to put their own eyes out.
Scan page 11
Life on the Gaza Strip. Continuing harrassment and discrimination for Palestinians Organiser