Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A missed chance to argue the case

Socialist Organiser no. 505, 1 November 1991 · scan p. 5 · about 899 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

North of Ireland?

"Troops Out" should be linked to agitation to promote a democratic Benn: "The solution is Irish self-determination settlement Tony Duncan Chapel rev last week's Channel Four TV feature on Ireland. T to use TV to put the his was a rare chance case for British withdrawal from Ireland.

What's more, the interviews and commentary were done by Geoff Bell, a supporter of the Trotskyist fortnightly Socialist Outlook.

Sadly, however, the programme went little further than the stock-in-trade of *Daily Mirror republicanism" and conventional Catholic Irish nationalism.

Bell set the programme up as a three-way confrontation of views. First there was the policy of Labour and Conservative leaderships - clearly shown as identical; then the views of US Senator Joseph Kennedy, of Seamus Mallon MP from the mainly Catholic Social Democratic and Labour Party in the Six Counties of Northern Ireland, and of relatives of dead soldiers; and, finally.

the results of a MORI poll of 2,000 people in Britain carried out for the programme.

Bell presented us with Labour and Conservative leaders quite united and complacent over Ireland. Tory Peter Brooke said how *helpful it is that it is not a party political issue". Labour spokesperson Kevin MacNamara tearfully praised Thatcher's "brave efforts in solving the crisis through the Anglo-Irish agreement.

Neil Kinnock blathered: *if we could reunify Ireland in 50 years or make that border irrelevant, I'd be a happy man".

Aided by Labour's leaders, the Tories have done nothing to bring peace closer. Indeed, through repression, discrimination and the ongoinitians have wrecked ise in the Six Counties, which has the worst poverty rates in Western Europe.

Pack Up The Troubles also showed that much of the responsibility for deepening the divisions in the Six Counties lies with Britain. Tory MPs Peter Brooke, Michael Mates and Humphrey Atkins smugly refused to criticise the way that the Tories backed up the Unionist thugs who created the basis for the partition of Ireland in 1921. The old Anglo-Irish Protestant landlord class was then still a power, linking the British Tories with the Protestant Ascendancy in Ireland.

The 1921 partition was an undemocratic settlement, followed by 70 years of discrimination against the Catholic community in the Northern state.

The poll commissioned for the programme shows a high level in Britain of support for withdrawal and of concern over Britain's role. 55% are concerned at Britain's human rights record - and so we should be, since the UK has been taken to the European Court of Human Rights more often, and found guilty more times, than any other state. 65% agree that British politicians are not doing enough about Ireland. 47% think there is no difference between the parties on only 20% think ference.

But the programme chose to present its positive ideas through the figure of US Senator Joe. Kennedy.

Presented through the programme as the voice of reason, he justified talks with Sinn Fein because *you don't have to deal with them if you beat them, but I can't see that Britain will beat them, so you have to talk."

Britain has proved unable to beat the Protestant militants, too. Much more fundamentally, talks — and a democratic settlement - are needed between the different factions and communities in Ireland. Without such a settlement, self-determination for the Irish people as a whole is just words. But Kennedy - presented uncritically by Bell - poses the issues in the fashion of the bourgeois Irish-American politician he is: realistic dealings between Britain and an Ireland supposed to be essentially all Catholic and "green".

What about the fact that Ireland is not all Catholic and "green". - that it has a large compact minority (the majority in Northern Ireland) which is bitterly opposed to a "green" Catholic Ireland? The programme tried to define that Protestant (or Anglo-Scots-Ulster) minority out of the picture.

To argue that a British withdrawal does not risk a bloodbath, Bell quoted strange set of supporters. The IRA were quoted as promising a ceasefire if there was withdrawal. But what about the 40,000 armed members of the 97% Protestant UDR? Bell assumed that they would be disarmed prior to withdrawal!

Cambridge Professor Bob Rowthorne informed us that the paramilitaries would "disappear completely". Ian Paisley was quoted as being for a referendum on withdrawal - as if that suggested that he would peacefully accept losing!

It all added up to a wildly unbelievable set of frail predictions. The troops have played no progressive role in Ireland, and most British people see that. 37% see no difference, and 36% think things are worse, in the Six Counties because of the troops.

But there are also two Irish communities with paramilitary forces. At the moment they are fighting a war for reasons that will not leave on the same boat as the British troops, even if those reasons arrived on those boats, which they didn't.

Bell showed through his poll that 23% of British people are for immediate withdrawal and that most people are for withdrawal within a four year period. But he only evaded the basic fact that makes that mass mood in Britain no more than a passive, chauvinistic feeling of being "fed up" with Ireland, and which makes most Irish people more sceptical about withdrawal: that unless the two Irish communities can make a political settlement with guarantees for democratic rights, then peace cannot follow withdrawal.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 505

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →