British policy in Ireland has failed
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-11-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
The various policies of British governments on Ireland have failed. Partition, strip searching, plastic bullets, and "supergrass" trials have all failed.
The whole world is having peace conferences - but there will be no conference for Northern Ireland. All the people get is a continued British presence.
The whole world seems to be in favour of "troops out": Russians out of Afghanistan and Eastern Europe; Serbs out of Croatia. But when it comes to British troops in Ireland there is a double standard.
Foreign intervention is not che way to deal with minority questions.
In Britain there is a ban on Sinn Fein speakers and the media's coverage of Irish events is subject to tight censorship.
The proposal for "troops out" and for self-determination for the Irish people has been recently backed by a MORI poll of British people.
I have proposed British withdrawal to the Commons - in 1983, in 1987 and in May 1991 in my Commonwealth of Britain Bill.
We should demand that the bloodshed be stopped. We have always been told that the current level of bloodshed is necessary in order to prevent a wider level of bloodshed. This is an old imperialist excuse: "We are in Ireland to keep the peace"
It is not the real reason. In fact, in the past, Winston Churchill offered De Valera Irish unity if Ireland came into World War 2 on Britain's side.
The fact is that the imperialists were in Ireland to occupy, ravage and partition. Now they are there to conto withdraw" trol.
The partition of Ireland was forced by the bullet. The British gerrymandered a border. The solution is Irish self-determination, but this cannot take place until the British withdraw. There must be an Irish solution to the current situation, not a British solution, The relations between Protestants and Catholics inside a future united Ireland are for the Irish people to decide — not for us. In fact, there is already a Protestant community in the Republic. No-one has suggested that their rights have been tampered with.
Will there be a bloodbath after British withdrawal? But there is a bloodbath already. After the British leave the loyalists and nationalists -or Protestants and Catholics - have got to learn to live together.
Tony Benn was speaking at a press conference organised by the Troops Out Movement in London on 24 October.