Why Trotsky would have supported the ban on the CPSU
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
was surprised to see Duncan Chapel protestsing at the ban on the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (letters, SO 503).
Is Duncan aware of the position_Trotsky took on his question?
Back in 1938, during the discussions on the Transitional Programme within the Fourth International, Trotsky becanfe involved in a controversy with Joseph Carter, who later became one of the leading figures in Max Shachtman's Workers' Party.
Carter argued that the slogan *Drive the bureaucracy and the new aristocracy out of the Soviets!" was incompatible with the Fourth International's commitment to socialist democracy. "There does not appear to be any valid reason to establish an a priori disenfranchisement of entire social groupings of present-day society. Disenfranchisement should be based on political acts of violence of groups or individuals against the new Soviet power"
Trotsky replied replied that Carter was posing the issue in the wrong way. Carter's views, argued Trotsky, "express a formal, juridical, purely constitutional attitude on a question which must be approached from the revolutionary-political point of view. It is not at all a question of whom the new soviets will deprive of power once they are decisively established... the question is how to get rid of the Soviet bureaucracy which oppresses and robs the workers and peasants".
Trotsky underlined the absurdity of Carter's position. "How can the bureaucracy be overthrown and simultaneously given a legal place in the organs of the uprising?"
Events have vindicated Trotsky on this point. Though the "organ of the uprising" proved to be the Russian Parliament, not Soviets Or factory committees, the decisive act in the August revolution was undoubtedly the banning and breaking up of the CP.
Socialists should be dancing on the grave of the CPSU, not bleating about the loss of its democratic tights.
Max Gordon, Walworth. 45-50 days every year up to the age of 55. Groups such as Yeshgvul have been established to support conseripts who refuse to serve in the Occupied Territories.
One of the most significant success stories of the Israeli left is the women's movement. It has managed to break out from isolation, and has drawn in women from the more liberal groups into a more active struggle against the occupation.
On my recent visit to the Occupied Territories I joined play.
The fight for socialism has to be based on workers unity. The resolution of national conflicts is important because national conflicts are an obstacle to workers" unity. A just peace in the Middle East is in the interests of workers of all nationalities.
Possibilities for united action by Palestinian and Israeli Jewish progressive forces may be difficult, if not remote, but they are important.
Scan page 15
Link London weighting to national pay janiser