A fascination with upper class traitors
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Television ike the whole of the British media for the last 40 years, Alan Bennett is fascinated by Britain's bizarr crop of upper-class traitors, the gilded youth of the British bourgeoisie who went over to Stalinism in the 1930s, when capitalism seemed to be going down the spout.
He wrote a play about the actress Coral Browne's strange encounter in Moscow with exiled British traitor Guy Burgess.
Now he has written one - A Question of Attribution (BBC1) - about Sir Anthony Blunt, the upper-class intellectual snob who was, it seems, the Stalinist masterspy, and who then lived on, even after he was unmasked, in freedom and comfort, pursuing his other career as the master of Queen Elizabeth's vast collection of paintings. He was knighted for that work.
Bennett stumbled upon a brilliant metaphor for the whole business of the unmasking of the successive layers of upper-class British Stalinist spies — Burgess and Maclean, "the two" , who went to Moscow in 1951; then Kim Philby, "the third man" who hung around in Britain until 1963; then "the fourth man", Ban, cal, lately, the fifth An "Old Master" in the possession of the Queen and under the curatorship of Sir Anthony Blunt was discovered to be a fake; in addition to the two visible figures in the picture it was discovered that there was another hidden figure that had been painted over, and behind that yet a fourth figure, detectable only on x-ray photos.
In A Question of Attribution, Blunt and the Queen discuss the painting.
That people are still fascinated by the British upper-class Stalinist spies is understandable. Not only is the story a reminder and proof, no doubt frightening, of the deep collapse of morale experienced by the British ruling class in the '30s, it also encompasses in a uniquely LT plays Harlem king-pin dramatic form the story of the surprisingly large part of that bourgeois generation who fell for the "Great Illusion", the "God that failed", Stalinist "Communism"
Unknown numbers of bourgeois and petty bourgeois people flirted, more or less seriously, with "communism" and socialism, and a few with Trotskyism. Most of them quickly retraced their steps, especially when capitalism pulled itself together again for the great slaughter of World War 2. Those who had joined the Stalinist secret services could not go back; they were caught and hooked.
And it was a true tragedy: for they must have been among the most serious and selfless ones. They too must have experienced dawning realisation that they had been conned by Stalinism, that they had sold their souls to the devil. There was no way back -unless they were caught!
Blunt was unmasked in 1964, soon after Philby flew the coop and got safely to Moscow. He was interrogated, debriefed, and then.. allowed to get on with his career! The ruling class's old boy network protected him - or was it merely protecting itself, hushing up yet another scandal?
It is indeed a fascinating piece of recent history. It is salutary for socialists to keep it in mind that those traitors to their own class mistakenly thought, when they signed up with Stalin, that they were crossing over to ours. For that they deserve respect.