Wittgens Trotskyist? Martin Thomas reviews
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
14O2 NATIME AMERICANS discoverthe New Worlo....
HEY!
A GREAT PLACE THISLLEE LAND AND DESTROY CULTURE!
EUROPE Book "Ludwig Wittgenstein:
Tas Ludwig Trotskyist? Offhand, the question seems ridiculous.
Wittgenstein who died in 1951, was the most influential philosopher of the 20th century in the English-speaking world. He originated two major schools of thought, *logical positivism" and "linguistic analysis"* both of which are generally associated with hostility to any "philosophical" criticism of established society.
Personally he repudiated both schools, but tended (as Monk shows well) towards mysticism and even hostility to some sciences rather than o greater radicalism Tet in 1946 - so Monk reports -Wittgenstein's response was "gympathetic" when his friend Rush Rhees. told him he was considering joining the Trotskyist movement.
Wittgenstein objected only with conventional banalities — a philosopher, he said, should retain a freedom to think inconsistent with the discipline of a revolutionary political party and Wittgenstein, an extremely prickly character, was the last person to resort to such flim-flam if he had deeper objections. Rhees was not only a friend but also one of Wittgenstein's most trusted philosophical co-thinkers.
If Wittgenstein really did move close to Trotskyist views in the last years of his life, it was the end of a very long journey. Born in 1889, he was the son of one of the richest industrialists in Austria, and as a youth conformed to the suthoritarian, sexist, patriotic and anti-semitic politics of his social class with no "philosophical" detachment at all.
An awkward, unhappy character, he disliked the bland, conventional hypocrisies of his class, and had a romantic admiration for the supposedly industrious, straightforward and frugal working classes. In 1919 he gave away the whole of his huge inheritance to other members of his family.
But he was still very conservative. He was frightened and disgusted by the real workers and peasants he met (at technical school, in the Austro-Hungarian army during World War and as a village school-teacher after the war). He was frightened and disgusted too, by the liberal and socialistic ideas of his philosophical mentor, Bertrand Russell.
In the 1930s he admired the Soviet Union, and went there hoping to exchange his life as a philosophy lecturer at Cambridge University for that of a manual worker in the USSR. (The Soviet government fobbed him off).
But his attitudes here were still scarcely left-wing. He told Rush Rhees that "tyranny doesn't make me feel indignant"; objecting to a friend serving treacle with suet pudding, he recommended life in the USSR as being without treacle or similar indulgences.
The Nazi persecution of Jews probably drove Wittgenstein leftwards. As late as the early 1930s, he was extremely anti-semitic. Then his family, though long assimilated, was classed as Jewish under the Nuremberg laws. His wealthy relatives in Austria were eventually able to buy special exemption, but the shock made Wittgenstein drop his anti-semitism.
In World War Il his attitudes shifted further: he volunteered to be a hospital porter, not a soldier, and he was critical of nationalism. In the 1945 General Election he strongly supported Labour. The USSR's military occupation of his native Austria may have completed his disillusion with Stalinism.
And, probably as important, his previously very uptight attitudes to sex oosened up.
Such was the result of the agonising efforts of an intense and keen-witted man to grapple with what he called "disintegrating and putrifying English civilisation",
----- pull-quotes -----
the duty of genius", by Ray Monk, published