Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Is the 500th anniversary of of America in…]

Socialist Organiser no. 504, 24 October 1991 · scan pp. 12–13 · Anne Field · about 1,163 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Is the 500th anniversary of of America in 1492 draws closer, controversy over his alleged achievements continues to escalate in the United States, as well as in Latin America and Europe.

Columbus first achieved national stature in America with a book published by Washington Itving in 1828. In the aftermath of the war of 1812 against Britain, the search was on for non-British heroes for America. Columbus, at least as portrayed by Irving, seemed to fit the bill - an Italian sailing under a Spanish flag who allegedly displayed true American virtues.

Columbus got another boost in the later nineteenth century in the controversy over Darwin's theory of evolution, which came under sustained attack from the church.

Not unjustifiably, the Darwinians wanted to portray the church as hostile to any scientific advance. As "proof" , they arguer that when the church was dominant in the Middle Ages everyone believed that the earth was flat, until Columbus "proved" otherwise.

In fact, flat-earthers were as scarce in the Middle Ages as today. But the controversy established the myth that Columbus proved that the earth was round.

Columbus finally achieved official recognition as a national hero in 1934 when the American President declared 12 October (the date on which Columbus sighted land on his voyage of 1492) to be an annual national holiday.

In 1965 Columbus was back the limelight as his pedigree as "discoverer" of America was challenged by Yale University, which claimed that the "Vinlai Map" allegedly dating from 14 showed that the Vikings were! acquainted with America long before Columbus sailed.

The chairperson of the Columbus Day Parade in Chicago denounced the map as a "Communist plot" "You can almost see the Russian influence in the title, " he said.

John Linday, then campaigning for Mayor of New York (which has a substantial Italian-American population), equated any criticism of Columbus with denigration of the Italian musician Toscanini. According to an Italian-American politician in Cambridge, Yale's claim was an attempt to "disgrace the Italian race of America"

Fanfani, the Italian foreign minister, summoned a special meeting of the Italian diplomatic corps in America in order to defend Columbus - by comparing him with Newton.

Many people before Newton had had an apple fall on their head, argued Fantani, but Newton was the first to discover gravity as a result. So, too, however many other people had travelled to America before Columbus, he was the first to discover it.

Given that Columbus thought he had reached India, this was a rather weak argument.

In 1973 a book by Simon Wiesenthal provoked disbelief rather than controversy when it claimed that Columbus was really a Jew who, under the pretext of working for Spain, was really planning to set up a Jewish state in any lands he discovered, in order to provide a refuge for Jews facing persecution in Spain.

There was another upsurge of controversy in 1978, when President Carter declared 9 October to be Leif Ericson Day, in memory of the Viking who "discovered" America.

*To dilute the importance of the discovery (of America) by the courageous Genovese navigator, the Admiral of the Ocean Seas, is insulting to millions of Americans of Italian dissent," wrote the Supreme President of the 250,000-strong "Order of Sons of Italy in America" in an open letter to Carter.

The latest controversy is much more serious than its predecessors.

On the one hand it challenges the mythology that has been spun around Columbus as an individual - pointing to his anti-semitism, his activities as a slave-trader, his medieval ideas about an imminent Apocalypse, and the falsification of his logs on his voyage. (To make it appear as if he really had reached Asia, Columbus inserted extracts from Marco Polo's accounts of his travels to China in his logbook.)

On the other hand, it points to the consequences of Columbus's "discovery" of the Americas: genocide in Latin America ana, In later years, in North America, the transatlantic slave trade, and the North-South divide which continues to exist today.

"Columbus's voyage was an important moment in the beginning of the age nation-states and of colonial expansion. The plunder of the Americas and the enslavement of millions of Africans was not the fault of one man, but the form taken by the development of capitalism as an international system Some Italian-Americans have again rallied to the defence of Columbus (although it is doubtful whether Columbus was Italian in the first place - he never wrote a word in Italian, and wrote even to his father in Spanish).

According to one ItalianAmerican, in a book specially published for the "Columbus Quincentenary": "There is no evidence to show that Columbus did any physical or psychological harm any Jew, or, for that matter, to anyone else... That Columbus suc ceeded in his voyage of discovery is to his credit and to the benefit of all of us who have come to America...No man has yet done for the world what he did. But he continues to be denigrated."

Yet the other side of the latest Columbus controversy is not without its problems, too. In many ways it is ahistorical. Columbus's crime is not that he was White European Male, as some enthusiasts for the "Politically Correct" movement in America pose the issue. And it is foolish to make Columbus bear the blame personally for all the crimes committed in subsequent centuries.

Columbus's voyage was an important moment in the beginning of the age of nation-states and of colonial expansion. The plunder of the Americas and the enslavement of millions of Africans was not the fault of one man, but the form taken by the development of capitalism as an international system.

Capitalism did indeed, as Marx put it, come into the world dripping blood from every pore. But even to "blame" capitalism is offbeam.

In 1492 it was not materially possible to organise humanity worldwide as a cooperative commonwealth which creates comfort, security and freedom for each individual. The meagre level of industry, technology, science and culture did not allow it.

Today it is possible - if only the working class can take power. It has become possible through capitalism. The feudal or other tribute-paying economic systems before capitalism were every bit as brutal as capitalism, but they promoted industry, technology, science and culture much less.

If Columbus gave a boost to capitalism, he gave a boost to exploitation, colonial oppression and genocide - but also to the possibility of an effective movement against exploitation and oppression.

Progress and vileness are inextricably linked in the history of the last 500 years — and we cannot undo that. To go back over that history, awarding praise or censure to individuals on the basis of whatever late 20th century moral system you prefer, is less than useless. What we must do is seek the lessons in history which help us to go forward.

Scan page 13

Socialist Organiser No. 504 page 13

----- pull-quotes -----

agreed A tale upon

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 504

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →