Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Those who do not learn from history are condemned to relive it The seedbed of today's

Socialist Organiser no. 504, 24 October 1991 · scan pp. 10–12 · about 3,598 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

was anti-kennis

he Labour youth moment of the early '6Os was the seedbed of the modern British Trotskyist movement. This article, part 2 of a series, surveys the different factions in Labour's Young Socialists in 1961-2. The Labour Party was right-wing and intolerant; it still kept control over the YS, but with difficulty; the major boost for the left came from the big and active campaign for nuclear disarmament; the biggest left group in the YS was "Keep Left", linked to the SLL led by Gerry Healy, and the future SWP (led by Tony Cliff) and "Militant" (led by Ted Grant) also had some support.

While frantically organising to defend their paper, and their existence within the Labour Party, Keep Left supporters also turned outwards to build mass working class YS branches.

A turn was made away from inwardlooking small discussion-circle type branches, towards organising branches which combined social activities for working class youth with some often elementary politics.

Wigan YS, existing in a small and dull town richly endowed with Labour Clubs and their facilities, was the pioneer here. Organising dances, the original nucleus of half a dozen politicos soon recruited 300 youth to the YS.

Keep Left had previously opposed attempting to compete with the social facilities available under capitalism' • Like the other tendencies, it had a sectarian-propagandist bias towards comparing and discussing line' and fine points of theory and analysis, rather than taking its political line into the working class youth to fight for it there.

The 'mass YS' policy provoked the hostility and jeers of other YS leftists, more concerned with having exclusive circles of friends and congenial fellow 'thinkers' than with organising working class youth. In fact, it did prove possible in many areas to 'refine' from mass YSs a hard core of working class boys and girls who developed politically and got involved in campaigns and struggles. The policy meant that the hard-core Keep Left supporters had to transform themselves from smug, bookish contemplators and 'thinkers' into people who could talk on all the varied levels required to the real raw material of a YS movement - working class youth; take up their concerns; draw them into activity. It was often very difficult — for some people it proved impossible - but it was an antidote to the sort of frozen impotence that gripped the Labour Party youth sections in the later '60s and, under Militant control, all through the '70s and early '80s.

A spokesperson for the Keep Left tendency put the policy like this: "Building large YS branches, initially from socials, is not easy... Anyone who thinks because he can quote from volume 2 of the Selected Works of Lenin that he is better than the young working class boys and girls who come to rock and roll, is not just on the wrong foot — he is on the wrong planet. We must realise that these young people are potentially the future leaders of the labour movement"

The policy allowed Keep Left to mobilise working class youth, and, ultimately, it explains how they came to dominate the YS. In the context of a bitter three-way fight in the YS, the 'raw youth' were, it is true, often counterposed to the sort of discussions of issues and political perspectives which were essential to the development of a realistic as well as a militant youth movement.

And, in the exigencies of the faction fight, Keep Left cadres may too often have been manipulative with the "raw youth". But that was caused by the intense factional warfare and Transport House harassment; it was not something intrinsic to the drive to turn out to working class youth. It was that drive which marked Keep Left out as a serious revolutionary tendency.

If in the end nothing good came of this policy, and little was consolidated, it was because of the weak side of the Keep Left/SLL tendency, which led ultimately to a grotesque degeneration: that is, to its he first YS conference did take place at Easter 1961, and was relatively free of restraints.

Through 1960 Labour Party youth groups had multiplied almost threefold, and by Easter 1961 721 YS branches were registered. 381 delegates attended the conference. Free political discussion was allowed, contrary to the initial Labour leadership blueprint for the YS.

A National Committee was elected by conference on the basis of regional blocks of delegates simultaneously electing a representative from each of 11 regions.

The conference was a prolonged battle battle between the Labour leaders and Keep Left for influence over the non-committed delegates.

The conference voted 222 to 97 against NATO and for unilateral disarmament. A vote of no confidence in Hugh Gaitskell was carried by 189 to 113. Roger Protz, the editor of the official YS paper, New Advance, circulated a personal statement against the bureaucratic running of the paper.

The witch-hunt of Keep Left continued. Right-winger Ray Gunter denounced Keep Left for once criticising Aneurin Bevan, recently dead and already a labour movement saint. In Bevan's lifetime, Gunter had tried to have him expelled! Demagogy won, and by 172 to 148 a motion deploring the attack on Keep Left was lost. Only one Keep Left representative was elected onto the National Committee, Liz Thompson.

In the heat of the conference, a number of the left currents disagreeing with Keep Left decided to pool resources and publish a new journal. Young Guard began to appear six months later, in September 1961.

This split in the left had big consequences. Most of the supporters of Young Guard considered themselves Marxists. In Young Guard, Rebel, the paper of the Cliff tendency, amalgamated with Rally, the duplicated publication put out by the Labour Party supporters of Ted Grant's group through Walton Young Socialists. The 'Nottingham Tendency', forerunner of Socialist Outlook, which had recently separated from Grant was involved. Left reformists from New Left Review and the Voice of the Unions also enlisted.

New Left Review was then a journal of those such as EP Thompson, Stuart Hall (now a guru of Marxism Today) and Doris Lessing who had split from the CP after Hungary and, essentially, moved to the right of the CP's nominal revolutionary politics.

The war between Keep Left and Young Guard was from now on to be often as bitter as Keep Left's war with the bureaucrats.

Despite its coalition character, politically Young Guard was in fact heavily a Cliff group paper. In 1962-3 it was perhaps the main paper of that tendency, together with International Socialism journal. Labour Worker (it became Socialist Worker in 1967) which they also published, was narrowly syndicalist by comparison.

All the successive editors Jemonstration, Trafalgar Square, October 1962. The Cliffites echoed the pacifism of these demonstrators with Paul Fant savina: "Retter 'all hands off Cuba" imperialism were Cliffites. One of them, Gus Macdonald, is now head of Scottish TV. The Grant tendency did not withdraw from Young Guard until September 1963, but was little in evidence politically (though one of its people, Keith Dickinson, was business manager).

1961-62: Keep Left versus Young Guard W Keep Left and Young Guard! hat divided the two groups, Keep Left believed in building a serious Marxist organisation within the labour movement, and that the time to work at it was at hand.

So, in theory, did the Grantites, but Young Guard's majority rejected this idea. Many Young Guarders considered Stalinism to be the product of Bolshevism, and a Leninist Party' to be a Stalinist abomination. (Some of the features of the Healy organisation reinforced them in such ideas.

The Cliff group's propaganda centred around such ideas. For example, in 1960 Tony Cliff published a big pamphlet on Rosa Luxemburg in which he declared that Luxemburg was right against Lenin in being suspicious of sharply-defined, centralised organisation. When he reissued the pamphlet in 1968, he was again a "Leninist". The than 'more rockets for the Cuban workers'. " The Cuban people were being asked to surrender to discussion and argument on the issue was reprinted unchanged from the first edition; only the concluding sentence was changed, and now it said that Lenin was right against Luxemburg on organisation!

The Healyites and the Grantites belonged to mutually hostile international associations — the Healyites adhered to the "International Committee of the Fourth International" set up by J P Cannon in 1953, though they began a process of splitting with Cannon in 1961; the Grantites were the official section of the Pablo-Mandel "Fourth International" until 1965.

The Grantites and the Healyites had a position on Stalinism of "critical support" and "make a political revolution"; the Cliffites considered the Stalinist states to be "state captans s de me very cau ur capuaust nanitaliot" at tha varu and of canitalict historical development, as distinct from the others, who saw them as "post-capitalist"

The Cliff group had started in 1950 as a Leninist, Fourth-Internationalist group (70 strong at the beginning, though by 1958 it was 20), disagreeing with the others on state capitalism". It circulated the magazine of the American Shachtman group (the Independent Socialist League) through the '50s. By 1960 it was politically very decayed, organised as a loose federation, recruiting youth on opposition to the Healyites* "toy-town Bolshevism", by which they meant the self-proclamation and posturing that today's SWP lives off. At the centre of the loose

Scan page 11

A Red Army battalion recovers after a battle during the civil war. After the civil war Lenin argued that trade unions were still very necessary - in the conditions - to defend lett federation, as it grew in the 1960s, was a "state-capitalist" sect around Tony Cliff and Michael Kidron, but there were other strands too: as late as 1968, some prominent ABU militants in Manchester resigned from the organisation because it opposed the invasion of Czechoslovakia by the USSR and the Warsaw Pact in August 1968!

The Cliffites explained war as being tied to capitalism because arms production kept capitalism going. This was the "permanent arms economy" theory, a shibboleth for the group then hardly less central than "state capitalism" , but long ago abandoned. They took it from the Shachtmanites.

From it they developed a bland, pacifistsocialist conclusion that socialism was necessary and that CNDers should come into the workers' movement, ie. the Labour Party and YS.

They produced New Year greeting cards in 1963 with the same slogan as the CP: *For Peace and Socialism' . Both Russia and the USA, they argued, were equally capitalist. Third World struggles might perhaps be supported, but were not centrally important. They would redefine themselves during the Vietnam War: but if someone had proved then to Tony Cliff that he would support Iran in the Iran-Iraq war, and then laud the revolutionary significance of Iraq's conquest of Kuwait, he would probably have hanged himself!

Keep Left explained the drive to war in the traditional terms of Leninism: Imperialism produced war. They considered support for the colonial struggles of decisive importance. Moreover, states like the Soviet Union and China were, they said, not capitalist, but degenerated and deformed workers" states. Socialists should take sides with them against imperialism. Ordeney was beat sucon nice ot bviously the Young Guard with the CND and Committee of 100 which, led by Bertrand Russell, organised mass sit-down protests against nuclear weapons. They could recruit from that milieu and from those generally "socialist" but not committed to building a fighting organisation here and now.

The defence of the Soviet Union was a major issue in the YS. The Cliffites, pacifists and Tribunites said to the Trotskyists: You have no right to oppose British capitalism's H-bomb unless you oppose Russia's. The Grant tendency agreed with Keep Left on the question, but threw their weight behind the Cliff group. Young Guard carried the Cliff line while the Grant group kept their mouths shut.

In the Cuban missile crisis of 1962, when President Kennedy was threatening to drop H-bombs on Cuba if the USSR did not remove rockets which the Cuban government wanted in Cuba, (there had been an American-backed invasion 18 months earlier at the "Bay of Pigs"), the Newsletter came out with headlines: 'Say No to Yankee War', 'Hands off Cuba!', 'Defend the USSR'. Young Guard shouted: 'Our demand is 'All hands off Cuba". But without the Russians' "hands' , (serving the USSR's interests), the USA would have squashed the Cuban revolution!

In Young Guard, a certain Paul Foot explained the Cliffite pacifist view, during the controversy that followed with Dave Ablitt of the Nottingham group (the Grantites were, as usual, silent) as follows: Better "all hands off Cuba' than 'more rockets for the Cuban workers'". This meant surrender of the rights of the Cuban people to control their own island to the power of imperialism, if imperialism upped the stakes enough. It was a good explicit expression of the crass pacifism in which the Cliff tendency dabbled at this period.

Paradoxically, the pacifist/CND period prepared the way for its own inversion and for the overthrow of one of the dogmas on which the Cliffites founded their tendency. When the Vietnam War flared up, with the giant American war power trying to pulverise the Vietnamese, there was a great revulsion in CND circles, and many swung behind the slogans 'For the NLF'. The Cliffites did too, effortlessly, in 1965.

In principle it is impossible to separate Vietnam from Korea, opposition to support for which led to Cliff's separation from the "orthodox Trotskyists" in 1950. And Vietnam, like Cuba in 1962, could have led to nuclear war.

inally, Young Guard disagreed with Keep Left on the need to fight the bureaucracy in head-on conflict.

On the contrary, John Palmer, a leader of the Cliff tendency, put it like this in 1963: *The onus is on the YS to find a relationship with our Party which will radically reduce those frictions and clashes which are leaving such a bitter heritage in the ranks of young people joining the YS. One thing must be made clear above all. There is no future for the YS outside the Labour Party; our only hope is to find a relationship even more close to it than at present, but one which will allow us essential freedom as a youth movement"

Which is quite a tall order given the right wing policies of the Labour leaders, then soon to be in government carrying our vicious attacks on the working class. A tall order — if what is meant is a fighting socialist youth movement. The point is that Young Guard had a rather cosy view of the future.

The Cliffites did not believe much could be done (until they developed a perspective of industrial work, in the mid-60s). Capitalism was stable, and would remain so for many years. This view is now sometimes presented in mythology as the Young Guard coalition being realistic, as against Keep Left, which foolishly tended to consider a major crisis of capitalism as more or less always imminent (or in progress). In fact, Young Guard were no more realistic in their assessment than Keep Left.

Believing that capitalism was indefinitely expanding and stable, they were bitterly disappointed after 1964 that the Labour government did not deliver reforms to the working class.

The Young Guard tendency did have more of the character of a real youth movement than Keep Left, because of its looseness, lack of a driving purpose and lack of discipline.

Keep Left youth were driven; and essentially they were a hard faction, led by a highly disciplined and centralised (indeed bureaucratic) organisation, vigorously warring with the Labour Party leadership and the general softer left while at the same time striving to build the organisation in the raw The assessments of immediate reality made by the Healyite SLL were often wrong. Yet their urgency about building an organisation was not wrong; on that, they were entirely right. The 1960s would soon produce a resonating series of major class struggles, which would reach a tremendous level in the '70s. A serious, democratic, realistic and responsible Marxist organisation could have shaped those struggles and ensured more stable working-class gains from the series of victories we won.

The Marxist organisation, working in the trade unions and Labour Party, could at least have become tens, perhaps hundreds, of thousands strong. The SLL was geared to such developments, the others were not. The tragedy for the YS youth and for the rank and file members of the SLL was that the SLL leaders, who had an unbreakable stranglehold on the organisation, were not up to the job politically, and not up to it personally or morally either. Drunk with limited success, they turned themselves into a destructive sect and then into something worse. But that was still a while in the future, after the SLL had won the majority in the YS. EPT workers' interests.

Did Lenin really favour a monolithic state? Check for yourself by reading this extract from the minutes of the Bolshevik party congress in 1921. The civil war had just ended, but the workers government was in terrible straits. The country's economy was shattered; famine was abroad; the working class was dispersed and exhausted; the people who had sacrificed so much to win the war against Russian counter-revolutionaries and foreign invaders now wanted improvements quicker and bigger than the government could possibly achieve. At this black moment decisions were taken which later served as stepping-stones for Stalin: the banning of the left-Menshevik opposition, the formal prohibition of factions within the Bolshevik party, the conquest of Georgia. Desperate to restore the economy, some Bolsheviks, notably Trotsky, proposed the creation of "labour armies", to tum the discipline forged within the Red Army towards the revival of industry. This is what Lenin said.

omrade Trotsky commits a mistake. According to him, it is not the role of the unions in the workers' state to protect the material and spiritual interests of the working This is a mistake. Comrade Trotsky tall about the "workers' state". Excuse me, this is an abstraction. It was natural for u to write about the workers' state in 1917; but those who now ask, "Why protect, against whom protect the working class, there is no bourgeoisie now, the state is a workers' state" , commit an obvious mistake. Not altogether a workers' state; that is the whole point. This is where Com rade Trotsky makes one of his fundament: mistakes.

We have now passed from general principles to businesslike discussion and decrees, and we are being dragged away from the practical and businesslike. This will not do. In the first place, our state is not really a workers' state, but a workers" and peasants' state. And from this follow many things. [Bukharin: "What kind of state? A workers' and peasants' state?"]

Organiser

nin really favour a And although Comrade Bukharin behind me shouts, "What kind of state?" I will not stop to answer him.* Those who care to, let them recall the Congress of Soviets which has just come to a close, they will find the reply in that.

But more than that. It is evident from our Party programme — a document with which the author of the "ABC of Communism" is familiar - it is evident from this programme that our state is a workers' state with bureaucratic distortions. And we should have stuck this sad - what shall I call it, label — on it. Here you have, then, the reality of the transition. Well, the state has in practice taken this form; does that mean that the trade unions have nothing to protect, that we can dispense with them in the protection of the material and spiritual interests of the entirely organised proletariat?

No. That is an entirely wrong argument theoretically. It carries us into the sphere of abstractions, or of the ideal which we shall achieve in fifteen or twenty years' time, and I am not sure that we shall achieve it even in that time. We are confronted with reality, which we know very well - that is, if we do not allow ourselves to become intoxicated, to be carried away by intellectual talk or abstract arguments, or by what sometimes seems to be "theory", but what in fact is a mistake, a miscalculation of the specific features of the transition. Our present state is such that the entirely organised proletariat must protect itself, and we must utilise these workers' organisations for the purpose of protecting the workers from their own state and in order that the workers may protect our state.

* In speaking of the discussion of December 30, I must correct another mistake I made. I said: "Our state is not really a workers' state, but a workers' and peasants' state." Comrade Bukharin immediately exclaimed: "What kind of state?" And in reply i referred him to the Eighth Congress of Soviets, which had just closed. Reading the report of that discussion now, I realise that I was wrong and Comrade Bukharin was right. I should have said: "A workers' state is an abstraction. Actually we have a workers' state; with this peculiarity, firstly, that it is not the working class population that predominates in the country, but the peasant population; and, secondly, it is a workers' state with bureaucratic distortions". Anyone who reads the whole of my speech will see that this correction does not affect my argumer or my conclusions.

Scan page 12

SIFORGMAN TURAL FRONT

----- pull-quotes -----

SES, PEACE

FEASTUMEET HANDS OFF CUBA CANDIMARIOVER CUBA WEEWAT NOIT Mact FE PIECECT

Did Le monolithic state? WHAT THEY REALLY SAID

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 504

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →