Lessons of the Judge Thomas affair: The reality of America's democracy
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
The idea that our belief that ours is democratically organised society, are the two great myths of modern capitalism.
But these myths fall apart and dissolve into nothingness in the workplaces of the capitalist world.
With few exceptions, in workplaces people are not equal, but cogs in a hierarchy run by capitalists (or governmentappointed managers). A world in which private capital allows a few to own the means of production on which the lives of millions depend can have little room for workplace democracy.
Everywhere, some have power over others. Everywhere in our society there is exploitation and degradation, more or less disguised, more or less openly brutal.
And where ever men have power, Advisory women are sexually pursued, harassed, coerced and exploited. It is the norm in our society.
The women's liberation movement has made people more aware of it, and some ashamed of it, but has so far been able to do little to change it.
It is all too probable that Judge Clarence Thomas, George Bush's candidate for life membership of the US Supreme Court — which has a central political role, and is in many ways more powerful than Congress — did use his power over a subordinate woman colleague, Anita Hill, to harry her sexually. We do not know. We cannot know.
The TV circus in which Thomas was accused by Anita Hill was not a trial. It was, as Thomas himself told his tormentors, more like a high tech lynching. He did not get "due process" - a properly conducted trial - and, in the outcome, neither did Anita Hill. The apparent rejection of her charges by the powerful Senate committee which went ahead and appointed Clarence Thomas a Edward Kennedy: spot the hypocrite justice of the US Supreme Court, seems to leave her branded a liar.
But it was not only and not mainly either Professor Anita Hill or Judge Clarence Thomas who came out of this attemped high tech lynching bloodied and discredited. It is the American bourgeois democracy.
Here we saw a radically sick system in operation. A conservative black man, the President's candidate for the Supreme Court, was almost destroyed for alleged sexual misbehaviour by a Senate committee which included Senator Edward Kennedy, notorious for such things!
Thomas - the stooge candidate of the brutally racist Republican Establishment - finally triumphed over his accusers by trumping their charges of sexism against him by charging them with racism!
Thomas's future really was at stake, but it was all a great insincere pantomime, played with demagogy and insincerity on both sides, in which both sides used the battle Anita Hill: caught in the political crossfire cries of sectional interests and pressure groups as so much convenient small change.
This is a political system in which rich members of the bourgeoisie like Edward Kennedy pass for "liberals" the best there is in a bourgeois political world where money counts for everything. A system in which there is a known minimum price for the chance to win a Senate seat: currently $25 million, which is what an effective media-conducted campaign costs.
It is a system currently open only to the rich, or to those financed by the rich. It is a system in which vastly expensive personal political beauty contests between personable candidates who share a profound agreement on everything that matters, has brought "politics" into such disrepute that — in the world's most important democracy - not much more than one third of the electorate bothers to vote.
People know that, whoever wins the election, the plutocracy is always the real winner.
That political system now holds a terrifying mirror up to the people of Britain. In the last decade, British politics has taken giant strides towards "Americanisation" - that is towards electoral contests from which almost all real political content has been emptied out, and all real decisions are made behind the pseudo-democratic facade by the rich and their top civil servants. In the USA many such key decisions are made by the Supreme Court!
The long dominance of Thatcher, a "conviction politician" disguised this process, at the same time as speeding it up by way of compelling fainthearted renegade socialists like Kinnock to accept the essentials of Now that Thatcher has gone, and Major provides the Tories with a slightly softer and slightly more human face, we are left with a political system in which only such things as Labour's wavering and too timid commitment to preserve and - perhaps - repair the NHS, divides the parties where policy is concerned.
The Kinnockites are helping push British politics closer , to the American model with their craven acceptance of a Labour-Tory consensus based on the Thatcher counter-revolution. Thereby they betray not only socialism - to which they no longer even claim any allegiance — but democracy, too,
----- pull-quotes -----
society people are socially equal, and the