[The decision of Tand file based Offshore Industry…]
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
The decision of Tand file based Offshore Industry Liaison Committee to form themselves into a new unior for offshore workers is potentially one of the most positive things to have happened in the British trade union movement for many years.
If the offshore workers despite adverse circumstances, succeed in their aim of establishing a solid industrial union with real strength on the rigs, and substantial control over health and safety matters, it will be a substantial victory for all working people.
The offshore workers will have shown that workers can effectively organise even in the most difficult of situations.
This will give courage to union activists across industry where a clear majority of the workforce are no longer unionised. It could be the start of a revival for trade unionism.
Yet some people on the left, particularly Militant and Socialist Worker, have come out against the offshore workers' union.
You would think that selfavowed Marxists with no base in the industry would have to nave preity strong reasons for standing against the course of action that the majority of working class activists in the field have embarked upon. Bu that would be too modest for Militant and Socialist Worker' - Militant said the offshore workers' union was a big mistake because "The task is still to replace the so-called leaders at the head of the official unions"
So Militant are telling activists in the OILC that a real breakthrough for offshore workers must wait until we hay a rank and file movement in th GMB, AEU and EETPU, strong enough to kick out Edmonds, Jordan and Gallagher. That is, a rank and file movement across the great bulk of manufacturing industry!
Sadly, such a movement is not on the immediate agenda. To tell a refatively compact ar autonomous group such as thi offshore workers to hold back in their industry [where the balance of forces is not so much in the bureaucracy's favour] until such time as a broad movement does exist is te preach passivity and cowardice.
And it's one rule for th rank and file, anothe for the "Marxists"!
Militant supported and spr sored the counterproductive pointless 'breakaway' from t Liverpool Labour Party whi led to the Walton by-election fiasco, an adventure that onl helped to weaken and divide left in the Labour Party and provided an opportunity for mass expulsions.
If Militant are to be consi tent, they are saying that a f dozen of their disorientated supporters and friends meeti in a pub room have the righ be supported unconditionally matter what desperate gamb they propose, whereas the pr ple who shut down the Nort Sea for two summers in a ro deserve to be lectured from 1 sidelines.
Socialist Worker agrees wi Militant. It uses two main arguments against the offsh workers' union.
Firstly, "past experience breakaway unions suggests OIL's move will prove a mistake"
Does this mean all breakaways are wrong? Tha not possible to argue in the light of constructive, liberati breakaways such as that whi led to the formation of the great industrial unions in the USA in the 1930s. So we ha to judge each breakaway co cretely.
Socialist Worker's second argument: "Even if the OIL succeeds in becoming a maj body organising the offshor workers, it could easily end replicating the bureaucratic structures of the existing unions".
Yes, an offshore union co become bureaucratic - but even if that happens, the establishment of an industri union for the North Sea wo be a major step forwards fo the workers, wouldn't it?
Without a union, without organisation, the working cl can only be a class of victin An effective union, bureauc or not, represents a massive vance in comparison.
If Socialist Worker can't that, they can't see anything Lenin often insisted that serious working class politic had to be based on 'concret analysis of a concrete situat To illustrate the point, he would tell the story of the village odd ball who sings w ding songs at funerals and dirges at weddings. In both cases he gets a hostile respo Militant and Socialist Wo deserve the same kind of re tion for promoting toy-tow breakaway' politics in one stituency one minute and de nouncing a genuine working class jail-break the next. he ch the nse. irker cepcon-
----- pull-quotes -----
the offshore workers despit adverse circumstances, succeed, it will be a substantial victory for all people.