Temptation wilderness
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
EYE ON We invited an independent, non-Socialist Organiser reviewer to cast a critical eye over our pamphlet, "Socialists and the Labour Party: the case of the Walton by-election". Al Richardson is joint author of a number of books on the history of British Trotskyism. Thi is his report.
his pamphlet is a detailed blow-by-blow analysis of the utter debacle of the Walton by-election.
In spite of the limitless capacity of the left to delude itself that defeat is victory, there can be little doubt that debacle is what it was. The size of Mahmood's vote was a derisory advertisement of the real weakness of the movement; more socialists have been witch-hunted out of the Labour Party, including two of our best MPs; a fresh splinter group (the Liverpool ILP) has been created, devoid of direction, with its own bans and proscriptions in place; Militant itself has been left in that half-in, half-out stati already rejected by the revolutionary movement in the 1930s, and has now commenced to split as a result of the unviability of its position.
What also plainly emerges from this collection is that the leadership of Militant has suffered a loss of direction and a loss of nerve. Militant had recruited large numbers of young people as paper sellers on a low political level (its education department has not functioned for a year and a half), and then found that possibilities had dwindled in Instead of changing the name of its paper and moving its office (the timehallowed answer to bans and witch-hunts) it saw its opportunity to direct its supporters' energies into the Anti-Poll Tax Federation.
It was easily able to make a takeover bid due to its numbers. When the Tories pulled the rug from under this, and its own dead hand had bored everybody else away, momentary success in the council elections seemed to offer a new orientation. An extraordinarily bureaucratic leading apparatus, consisting entirely of full-timers!, has allowed two areas, Glasgow and Liverpool, to alter the entire policy of the group without any conference being held at all!
This does not mean that there are no real class forces behind this movement. The very existence of the new political formation (ILP) separate from Militant shows this to be the case. tradition of ERIC HEFFER A candidate campaign on socialist policies / YES to the 1.000 compulsory = N to the 1.000 compulsory / VES to ang talith saint pall = NO soing tail agains pell in sen pasers s one of the wea knesses of his collection tha it it malyses the situa tion in erms of stunts rs ather than if the movement of classes.
In a city of hig nemployment, v here the ocal authority is the largest ingle employer, cutting ouncil jobs mea ns real leprivation for e onsiderable lumbers.
It is not surpri sing, either, hat this lays Mil itant open o charges of job bery, hough it says vo lumes bout the state o f the labour novement that tl hey can find his repugnant in the case of I park attendant or a Justbin man, wh ile forgeting conveniently the hated *jobs for the gir Is" on top alaries created h ly the midle class cliques i in charge of iome London co uncils, which is sure to cost Labour valuable seats in the coming general election.
Nor is the pre: sent reviewer impress ed by the molied support given to the "Black Caucus" over Sam Bond - we havi e already had quite enougl h - and the United States fai r too much - of self-styled "representatives" of comr nunities, who never appoi nted them, with their eyes o n the public purse.
What is plain is that Militant bent to the pressures of these class force: s. It is allowing an advs anced section of the class to become consumed by im patience and become isolated from the main organisatic ins of the working class, b efore they began to move a is a whole.
It was, as this / publication makes clear, an abdication of political lead ership.
That does not I at all mean that no others a re to blame. This observer w as shocked and disgusted b y the violation even of bor urgeois. legality by allow ring Bleasdale's GBI y to be screened while t he Walton by-election was in full swing - an interferen ce with the electoral proces: s that would have led to an c utery if it had been applie d to one of the main bourg eois paties.
In this contex it some of the language of these article ("bully boy", Tammany Hall jobs-for-th le-boys corruption) make s no contribution towar ds defending the left against the propaganda barrag e directed against us.
But the main thrust of the pamphlet cannot be ignored. The Labour Party is sure to dominate the politics of the working class as we move closer to a general election. Those who think that they can make it disappear by denouncing it from outside only advertise the impressionism of their own The very fact that the Kinnockite apparatus is desperate to get socialists out of the Labour Party strong reason for staying there,
----- pull-quotes -----
LESLEY MAHMOOD is the REAL Labour candidate democratically There are two Labour choices in this election: / People's Choice The other candidate is She will continue the endorsed by party