Hanged for his mate
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Vicki Morris re Him Have It"
erek Bentley was a nineteen the friend of Christopher Craig who shot a policeman and ried to shoot several more.
Craig was too young to hang, so hey hanged Bentley, who was already in police custody when Craig shot the policeman.
In the film, Bentley is portrayed shouting the words "let him have it, Chris" which got him hanged for complicity in the murder.
Craig and some of the policemen who were there on the night say that Bentley didn't even do that much. The police lied in court.
The film brings out other aspects of Bentley's trial to show that it was not a fair one.
There wasn't the time to prepare a doctor's report about Bentley's state of health — he was an epileptic - or his "mental age' - 11 years it turned out.
The trial took place a matter of weeks after the crimes, and the jury and the judiciary, evidently shocked by them, wanted to convict.
All this is greatly unfair. When the film has built up a picture of Bentley as a young man who has had a raw deal in life but who, nice beyond words, now struggles to please his parents and get back on the straight and narrow after his boyhood misadventures, the sense of injustice is magnitied.
There is some sense of the fight that his family and supporters put up to save his life. But the sadness is a bit too exquisite for you ever to believe that life is about more than just sadness and comfort.
It's about joy sometimes, but, when there is sadness and wrongdoing it is about rage too and the struggle to overcome injustice.
The film is about Bentley's particular misfortune, but it ought also to be about capital punishment as such - after all, where there is no death sentence, there remains a chance not just to rescue the name of a wrongly convicted person, but to save his skin, even if it is after he has spent a good part of his life in prison.
The cases of the Guildford Four and the Birmingham Six have taught us that very recently.
Compared to earlier films which formed part of the propaganda campaign to abolish the death sentence, this film lacks the stark and horrible portrayal of hanging itself - judicial murder.
The days leading up to the hanging are filled with the struggles of the family, their feelings, of pathos.
There is not much about what the man to be hanged goes through — the psychological torment, the knowing you are going to die, the knowing how many hours or minutes you have left.
An ironic tone is struck at the end where the credits say that Craig served ten years and now lives "a law-abiding citizen" - what is the message here? That he learnt that it's dangerous to play with guns?
So the film might send its audience home feeling "life's sad, the weak are to be pitied." This is not a very dynamic message and a shame to come out of such a moving and dare I say it, attractively filmed picture.
Let Him Have It is a bit too catharthic to be a completely effective anti-hanging film, or even fully to convey the injustice that was done to Derek Bentley
Scan page 14
iSE