Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The politics of Citizen Kane

Socialist Organiser no. 503, 18 October 1991 · scan p. 13 · about 1,214 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Coactly twice as old as itizen Kane, at fifty, is Orson Welles when he made the film which so many critics place at the top, or close to the top, of their list of the greatest movies ever made.

The twenty five year old Welles and his co-writer Herman Mankiewicz) made a technically dazzling and hypnotic film about Kane, the mythical super-rich American plutocrat, Kane's story is told first in a pseudo newsreel in the style of the late 1930s, and then through reminiscences and flashbacks as a journalist talks to Kane's surviving associates. Kane's life has been written large in the public records of America, but he remains an enigma.

Significantly, Kane's last word, "Rosebud" • can not be deciphered by any of them. The Journalist never finds the meaning of it. Citizen Kane, on one level, seems o be just a parable - and maybe that is all it is - exemplifying the answer to the Bible's rhetorical The arrest of Derek Bentley question: "What does it profit a man if he gain the whole world and suffer the loss of his own soul?". Not much, says Citizen Kane.

Kane, though, may never have had a soul to lose in the first place, and he was, as a child, already one of the richest of the American rich. It was not quite myth: Kane was plainly meant to be - and plainly intended by Welles to be identifiable as — William Randolph Hearst, the then still-living, very powertul, and ultra-reactionary tycoon who (like Kane) ran a chain of mass-circulation papers.

t probably took some daring for Welles to go after such a powerful man, and bait him so openly and so unmercifully.

For instance, it seems that the answer to the movie's unsolved mystery of the meaning of Kane's last word, "Rosebud", was quite simple and well-known in Hollywood: it was William Randolph Hearst's pet name for his long-time actress paramour Marion Davies's clitoris!

A long sequence in the film in which Kane uses his money to try to make an opera star out of a mediocre singer exactly parallels Hearst's efforts on behalf of Marion Davies, whom he starred in a lot of "vanity movie-making" films. (Though no less than Charlie Chaplin himself described Davies as a talented comedienne, and most accounts make her out to have been something like a decent human being.)

Hearst tried to have Citizen Kane banned, and when that failed his press hounded it, and, for many years after, Welles himself.

Citizen Kane vividly shows the corruption of US life by graft and by money. It shows the craziness of a capitalist system which allows vast accumulations of the social wealth in the hands of the rich. The old Kane lives in an uncompleted castle filled like an old attic with junk and with the rich artistic plunder of the world, most of it still unopened and in crates.

In one scene, in a vast space filled with crates, some of them upended to look like skyscrapers, Welles creates the image of a city, and that evokes the cities and the people whose lives are owned and played with by the Kanes and the Hearsts. The futility of it is suggested after Kane is dead by a great plume of black smoke coming out of the castle's main chimney, produced by the burning junk.

And it may indeed be tha this is all the "message" there is film, the Bible's assertion of the ultimate personal futility of the search for vast wealth.

And yet the film is replete with the echoes and reflections of the political struggles of the '30s.

Welles was, it seems, a New Deal Roosevelt Democratic liberal, perhaps, then, on the lett wing of the wide spectrum of opinion that rallied to Roosevelt, whose use of state power to revive the US economy was a very radical departure in US politics. Hearst was a stone-bottomed reactionary, whose press made propaganda, for example, for the Spanish fascists during the Civil War there.

Thus Hearst-Kane is shown as a would-be paternalist who goes sour when "the people" won't elect him, a "friend of the working man" who turns hostile when the workers confront him as an organised force, as "organised labour"

And yet it is here, as a political table, that you see that Citizer Kane is shot through with political lies, in fact with the typical official lies of New Deal Liberalism and of bourgeois democracy everywhere.

Politically and ideologically it is on exactly the same plane as the sentimental comedic parables of which, typically washington" and an honest Smith goes to sorts out the connivers and cynics, converting some of them.

Citizen Kane is, politically, that tale told from the other side. Mr Kane does not go to Washington. He fails in politics. His failure is asserted to be a result of "the people" and "the workers" outgrowing his early paternalism and coming into their own.

Kane is shown as a marginalised figure, extruded from politics by a sex scandal, and politically impotent despite his great wealth. His political failure seems to show the limits of money power.

If not the wealthy, then who rules? Mr Smith and his friends, of course. Kane the mythical plutocrat is thus presented in the film as the precise opposite of the real American rich in real American politics, then and now.

In fact the American rich buy political power and influence. They buy senators by putting up — usually on a shared-ownership basis — the $25 million needed to run an effective Senate campaign. Their representatives can be seen in the Senate telling the senators how to It is not Kane who is true to the reality of American plutocratic politics — where less than half the people bother to vote - but John F Kennedy, whose father bought him the presidency.

he Bible parable that it profits nothing to gain the whole world if you lose your soul here turns into the great political lie that wealth, which allegedly cannot bring you happiness, cannot bring you political power either.

But yes it can! William Randolph Hearst proved that in his own way. For all Welles's evident relish in baiting Hearst, his picture of Kane is in fact a sanitised picture of the man. The real Kane, Hearst, could, and it seems did, get away even with murder.

In 1924 Hearst took a party of movie people on his yacht. They included the movie director Tom Ince and Charlie Chaplin. Hearst caught either Ince or Chaplin in flagrante delicto with Davies. He went out, came back with a gun, and shot dead Tom Ince (who may just have entered the room, as Chaplin scarpered).

Tom Ince was cremated very quickly. His death certificate said "acute indigestion"! Hearst paid Ince's wife a life-long pension. A journalist on board, Louella Parsons, had a lifetime career as a movie gossip columnist with Hearst's press ahead of her.

Though the story was widely known, there was no investigation. It was summed up in a joke about William Randolph Hearse...

Capra's sympathetic, sentimental, and good-hearted Mr Smith myths, and Welles's great Kane myth, notwithstanding, Us politics is living testimony to the power of money, not to money's futility or powerlessness.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 503

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →