Women must fight for rights as workers!
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Royal Pride strike 1982 CONTROVERSY he first thing to say to my outraged critics is that when it comes to the "woman question", socialists who on any other subject display intelligence and curiosity seem to switch off their minds.
Socialist Organiser is above all a paper which encourages debate, and stands out against many of the untenable "left orthodoxies" . SO tries not to hide behind optimistic slogans or world-revolutionary theories, but looks at the facts.
What I am trying to do in "Women's Eye" is not only le point out how the sick society we live in affects and oppresses women, but also to question (and if necessary outrage) received feminist dogmas. The reason for this is that much recent "radical" feminism, with its "lifestylism" and its prejudices is inaccessible nonsense, with no relevance to most women's lives. Much modern feminism does have a middle class bias. So if I deal with those ideas, I am dealing with a subject with a middle class bias.
Nonetheless, such ideas require attention. The "radical" feminists use moral pressure to bash women with whom they come into contact. In the sometimes rather inwardlooking world of left and women's politics, their ideas are put across forcefully, and people who don't agree are ruthlessly witch-hunted. Many feminist events are not for the faint-hearted.
Often the response of "socialist feminists" is to descend to the classreductionist ideas of the SWP. Both sets of ideas come with the pressure to "believe" , rather than think. 1 would argue that that pressure is atfecting you, O critics, which is why you are in such a hurry to shut me up.
Now, my article had many taults, but they are not the faults I am accused of. My problem was in extrapolating from a couple of anecdotes into a general "theory". Even so, I think the theory is valid. And I am astonished that no one commented on the story of a woman who could not support herself on $15,000! Do you all think she is a victim?
In defending my "theory", 1 want to draw on three main themes: the history of the women's movement, the idea of choice, and the relationship between the individual and society.
Firstly, the history of the women's movement is the history of women's struggle to play an equal part in society. For example, the struggle for the vote, not to be slaves to fertility and the struggle for the right to work. Society gives credit to those who work. Not the "Obviously the Tories have not advanced into the home on the scale of the 1950s either."
credit that the workers are to, but credit nonetheless.
This struggle has largely been fought by middle class women, because working class women have never been stopped from working. But just because Simone de Beauvoir, Virginia Woolf were fighting against well fed but enforced idleness does not mean that fight is not important for all women.
Middle class women's struggles to enter the universities and the professions are part of our history -part of the fight for women to be taken seriously as intelligent beings. Those women were fighting against a society which on the one hand exploited female labour and on the other set women up as a civilising influence emanating from the home. Other daily struggles for equal pay, fair promotion prospects, maternity and childcare provision, etc. at work are a continuation of that struggle. Those women who opt out let us down.
Some women make me angry. The women who have taken on the protective covering of male values, who run themselves down (and by implication all women), who pretend to be helpless, and simper that their goal in life is to marry a millionaire. I dare to suppose that Sylvia Pankhurst and Rosa Luxemburg would have found them pretty objectionable too.
Of course the truth is that most of these women are just as pissed off by the low pay and rotten childcare as I am. 9 times out of 10 they turn off the simpering when the last man leaves. Feminism is about saying to such women - you agree with us, so join us! Events like strikes, trade union activities, issues like health and safety and their own experiences can be the biggest eye-openers.
But these women are not passive receptacles of ideology, waiting only for the struggle to kiss them into wakefulness. Some of my critics fall into the "world historical process" trap when they perceive all women as a homogenous mass. When a worker crosses a picket line we call her a scab. She has chosen to side with the bosses against her own class interests. She is doing what all the media, the lying propaganda machine is telling her to do.
We have the right to make demands on women who fall in with the dominant ideology, who side against all our interests as women. To stand up against the propaganda, to defy society and take your place with the minority who are actively struggling for better conditions is a hard choice. But it is a real choice, and most women are aware ot it, however peripherally. Otherwise what the hell are we all doing?
Of course, once you have children, a home to keep up, elderly relatives to care for, the choices inevitably lessen. Even so, the ostensible narrowing of choice frequently leads women to join the struggle for something better, particularly when they are the sole "breadwinner"
But my criticism is not of women with dependents (and I made this quite clear), but of healthy, childless, single women who devote their energies to finding someone to take care of them.
This is essentially a tivity and it is the fault of capitalism. But it is not acceptable to say "blame capitalism" and that's the end of it. Capitalism will not just end, and everyone be free. Part of the ending of capitalism will be the erosion of its ideology.
Although the economic fight is pre-eminent, the ideological battles have an important place. The ideological battle here is to demand women's rights to be taken seriously as workers and to condemn those who won't (not can't, won't) take part.
There are bigger and more important things to worry about on a material level than a minority of women who won't work. On an ideological level, there is a lot of work to be done to kill the myths about women not being "real" workers (and consequently not needing "real" wages or "real" opportunities). Every time the papers find some man to say that my wife doesn't have to work" and some women to display her starched antimacassars and matching place mats, and say "my place is here" the struggle gets harder for the rest of us.
My critics suggest that many women would like to escape from work. Yup, count me in. Many men would like to escape from work too. But that isn't the point. There is no escape from work, either "at home" or in society. Someone has to do it, and someone will have to do it in a socialist society. In a socialist society, work will be different, better, more rewarding and more equally shared - but no one will miss out on it!
Under capitalism we can make improvements to our working lives, too, and the battles for those improvements we want is to be taken seriously, whatever job we do, or even if we are unemployed.
Finally, I want to say that things have improved for women workers.
Women have been pulled in and out of the home depending on capitalisms' needs. Women are, after all, part of the "reserve army of labour" . But we are far less a "reserve" army than we were.
Equal pay legislation is not enough, but it makes women less attractive temporary labour, less reservists.
Essentially the Tories have failed to push women back into the home! More women are now principal breadwinners than before the wave of unemployment. Equal pay legislation and unemployment, along with EC tax and benefit reforms are killing the idea of the family wage. The Tories are holding out against these changes but (l hope they can not totally reverse them.
Obviously the Tories have not ad. vanced working women's cause, 1 am not saying that they have, bur they have not pushed women back into the home on the scale of the 1950s either.
On the ideological front, the mainstream women's magazines are debating the question of work vi home for women. But unlike in the past, it is a reasonably balancec debate. Women are not stupid They know (as Virginia Woolf and Simone de Beauvoir did that paid work confers status and that thi "joy" of being a civilising influenc is a false joy.
We must demand of women tha they fight for their rights a workers, as full, independen members of society and don't giv in to all the pressures to sit at hom embroidering napkins. Or mor likely cleaning the toilet.
The case for amphlet Et lilable from Women's atback, PO Box 823, Londor 5 4NA. E1 plus 32p p&p
Scan page 13
HE CULTURAL FRONT nise
----- pull-quotes -----
working women's cause, but they have not pushed women ba
FAT. nue Strikra for defending
Socialist Feminism