Democracy and the Russian revolution
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Party machinery remained in the hands of the right wing and of Hugh Gaitskell. Keep Left reacted to the Scarborough decisions with a demand that the left fight to consolidate its victory, as yet a paper victory. It called a conference of its supporters, trade unionists, and young CNDers for November 6th, in Manchester's Free Trade Hall, under the slogan, "Implement Scarborough Keep Left for October-November 1960 argued that the Scarborough policy - official Labour policy — was the way to win youth to the YS and to build a mass youth movement. 150 youth, from 47 YS branches, attended the November 6th conference, and pledged themselves to fight for the Scarborough policies.
"We have come to bury Gaitskell, not to praise him" , said Gavin Kennedy, organiser of Keep Left and secretary of Hendon North YS, which sponsored KL together with Wembley North. The conference also pledged that if the Labour Party did not call the promised YS conference at Easter 1961, then Keep Left would call a YS conference at Whitsun 1961. It was in tune with the atmosphere and the battles of 1960, and the open defiance of Labour conference by the PLP and its leader; it expressed the need to fight for the Scarborough decisions. Yet already here the characteristic Healyite note of braggadocio makes its appearance.
The NEC's reaction was swift and sharp. At its meeting of 23 November 1960 it decided to destroy Keep Left. "It is not the function of a branch, or branches, of the YS to issue a journal for national circulation" , its representative wrote to Wembley North and Hendon North. They were ordered to cease publication. The keynote for the next four years had been struck.
The right of the party was beginning its assault on the unilateralist left with a seemingly easy target. Shortly afterwards, Michael Foot and four other MPs had the Labour whip withdrawn for voting against the Tory government's Air Estimates. Ernie Roberts, an elected Assistant General Secretary of the AEU, had Transport House approval withdrawn as Labour candidate for Horsham, and was called to account for 400 speeches he had made! As late as 1962, there were attempts to exclude Bertrand Russell and Canon Collins from the Labour Party.
Keep Left's response was as decisive as the NEC's. The December 1960 issue had a banner headline: "Our reply to the disrupters and witch-hunters on the NEC: we shall not shut down this paper" . And just under the masthead was a list of 16 YS branches sponsoring KL where there had been two!
By January 1961 there were 27 sponsoring branches; by February 32; and eventually the sponsors hovered around the 45 mark until Keep Left was proscribed in May 1962. This -was the strongest argument against the right -wing! Many labour movement bodies supported Keep Left and protected it. For examle, 250 delegates to Liverpool Trades Council unanimously defended Keep Left's right to publish.
om Rigby (SO 500) rightly warns us about the dangers of abstract arguments when referring to the anti-democratic measures taken by the Bolsheviks in the early 1920s.
But in his attempts to defend Lenin against Ian McCalman's charges I think he ignores, or only partly addresses, important issues about democracy and socialism that have plagued and hampered the movement down to the present day.
That Lenin was a consistent democrat there can be no doubt. But the Bolsheviks took measures in the early '20s that made it much more difficult for Trotsky and others to defend the gains of the revolution later in the decade.
If we are truly to learn the lessons of history, we would be wise to debate these matters seriously. Many of the arguments may be abstract at this historical distance, but this is no excuse for ignoring the mistakes of the past, particularly at a time when socialism and democracy are seen as polar opposites in large parts of the world.
It might be "arguing in the abstract" to doubt the wisdom of the decision to ban factions in 1921, but the growing influence of the bureaucracy was a pretty concrete and growing phenomenon even at that stage. It threatened the Bolshevik Party and the revolution "from the inside". In trying to defend the revolution from its enemies the genuine Bolsheviks underestimated those standing menacingly at their backs.
Tom says that "many of the best cadre had died in the civil war, others had been drawn into the party or into positions in the state machine — where they were outnumbered by careerists, time-servers, ete". If this was the concrete reality of the day then banning factions could not serve the interests of the revolution. In fact the banning of factions at the end of the war could only have helped Stalin and the time-servers to make the exceptional decision of 1921 a permanent feature of the party.
Yet it is still important to understand that the decision of 1921 was exceptional, one based, at least in the minds of genuine Bolsheviks such as Lenin and Trotsky, on the extraordinary dangers facing the workers' state at the time.
This is an important matter because Lenin and Trotsky saw internal democracy and debate as the oxygen of the movement. Looking around at the left today, with the odd exception, one is struck by the lack of democracy that infects their organisations. The two largest, the SWP and the Militant, have learned a lot from Stalinism and little from Lenin. In organisational terms they are stuck in a 1921 time warp. Given such internal rigidity is it surprising that they stick religiously to their respective theories on the nature of the Eastern Bloc states even after history has consigned such ideas to the wheely bin? Serious socialists who take the trouble to read the writings of Lenin and Trotsky will find it difficult to accept that the methods of Militant and the SWP are in the same tradition. And it is important, especially at a time when socialism needs to re-establish its democratic credentials, that the record on this matter is set straight.
"'The implications of an end to internal democracy were clear to Trotsky and the Left Opposition. The dying out of inner-party democracy leads to a dying out of workers' democracy in general the trade unions and non-party mass organisations."
Lenin and Trotsky never meant the 1921 decision to become permanent. Unlike the left today who face no war, who do not have to defend the gains of the revolution, who confront only the witch-hunters of Walworth Road, Lenin and Trotsky saw the decision of 1921 as the exception, not the rule. In fact, up to 1921, despite the dangers of the civil war, full discussion and debate continued in the party. Often Lenin himself insisted on it. At the time of the internal disputes over the Brest Litovsk treaty, Lenin demanded that all views be aired. The "Left Communists" , at Lenin's request, had full rights to make their views known both internally and through the pages of Pravda.
Trotsky re-asserted these ideas in the "Platform of the Left Opposition". Written in 1927 at a time when Stalin was striking the final fatal blows against the workers' revolution of 1917, it speaks volumes against the latter day left who ban factions, impose the line from the top down, and, in the case of the SWP, face up to debate by throwing opponents out of their meetings.
The Left Opposition were ruthless in their opposition to what Stalin had done to the life of the party, If the party must be looked at from the top down, wrote Trotsky, *the Leninist party...no longer exists".
The implications of an end to internal democracy were clear to Trotsky and the Left Opposition. *The dying out of inner-party democracy leads to a dying out of workers' democracy in general — in the trade unions, and in all other non-party mass organisations." The association made by Trotsky between party democracy and workers democracy should not be lost on those organisations who profess to support the latter yet stifle the former.
And while the opposition were denied the right to reply the Stalinists used every opportunity to carry out a vicious polemic at all levels of the party against the views of the Left Opposition.
To remedy the situation the Left Opposition proposed party unity. They opposed splits and expulsions and supported not a fake unity but one built around the "free discussion and decision...of all disputed questions". Party members should be entitled to accurate information and all relevant documents, taken from every viewpoint, so as to ensure genuinely collective decision And should these discussions take place in the press? Why certainly! "Every comrade and group of comrades ought to have an opportunity to defend their point of view before the party, in the press, at meetings, etc." Was this restricted to internal party press and journals? Certainly not! "The draft theses (the platform) of the Central Committee, of local organisations, of individual members of the party and groups of members, ought to be published in Pravda [Trotsky's emphasis]".
Finally, the debates should be conducted in a business-like and comradely manner, without personalities and exaggerations. Compare that to the campaign of whispers that goes on between the "Trotskyists" of today, where in the case of Militant, you can never be sure what they are saying about you because it is rarely said, and certainly not written, in public.
The issue of democracy is a vital one for socialists at this time. In the aftermath of Stalinism and its untold damage to the life of the whole movement, we should leave no stone unturned. Tom is right to pose the question, "what kind of democracy?" But "how much" of the most "full blooded" democracy in human history was left by 1921? And is it enough to blame the lack of revolutions in Western Europe for the total destruction of democracy in the Soviet Union by 1929, only 8 years after the decision to ban factions in the Soviet CP?
These are important questions in their own right, but given the state of the movement today we need some answers urgently.
Scan page 12
Organiser SSION nin