"splitters" ] Offshore Instry
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
it "foolish and tragic"; while Alex Ferry, General Secretary of the Confederation of Shipbuilding and Engineering Unions (CSEU) called upon offshore workers to put their All of which is a bit rich, given that OILC has been attempting to work with the "existing unions" (and, indeed, to overcome their sectional rivalries) ever since 1988 — only to be stabbed in the back this summer when recognition at a date determined by the oil companies.
The final straw was the refusal of the AEU and EETPU to even attend meetings for a united offshore union federation at this year's TUC. Instead, the TUC unions proposed a toothless sub-committee of the CSEU, from OILC's leading figures (notably Ronnie MacDonald) had been resisting rank and file demands for a new offshore union and pinning their hopes on the creation of an Offshore Federation with executive power over its constituent unions. The "hook-up" sell-out, the sectarianism of the AEU and EETPU, and the failure of th other unions (notably the TGWU, MSF and RMT) to come up with any worthwhile proposals, made the creaAgencied toe it rears TC, The cument the Offshore Trade Unionism: this is a closely-argued critique of existing unions' failure to organise effectively and it puts forward eminently sensible proposals for a campaign for an all-inclusive offshore industry agreement. In particular, the authors propose making use of the Cullen Report (into the causes of the Piper Alpha disaster) to give the unions a toe-hold in the health "Specifically, he [Cullen] laid down two conditions which the process: (1) the trade unions should achieve recognition in relation to a substantial aspect of labour relations; (2) that the union should have substantial membership on the installation in question. Those two conditions - recognition and membership on the installation - can only be achieved if the unions pool their resources in the kind of Offshore Federation which the Given the abject failure of the existing unions to seize what OILC describes as the "rather slender life-line" presented by Cullen, the new union will be concentrating upon health and All in all, the OILC "split" is the logical, responsible, and all-but-inevitable response to the failures and betrayals of the existing unions offshore. OILC are not really "splitters" at all out of a total offshore workforce of 36,000, the TUC unions can claim only 6,000 members, most of whom already look to The attacks on OIL. from people like Airlie and Ferry were to be expected. What is strange, however, is the response of much of the "left" - including many of those who rushed to support the ill-advised and counter-productive EPIU split from the EETPU. The Morning Star, for instance, pontificated about how "at this time, when the unity of the TUC is under severe attack...the establishment of a new union outside the TUC can only make things worse and play into the hands of the extreme The decision of the Liaison Committee (OILC) to form itself into a new union has brought forth predictable cries of condemnation from predictable sources.
Frank Doran, the Labour Party's "spokesman on Oil and Gas" , called the decision "damaging to the cause of workers off-shore"; Jimmie Airlie of the AEU called faith in the "existing unions"
the AEU, EETPU and GMB signed another hated "hook-up" agreement, involving automatic dewhich OILC would be excluded. tion of a new union inevitable.
Anyone who has doubts about the wisdom of prepared for this year's TUC, The Crisis in and safety process:
unions must fulfil if they are to play a part in the safety OILC is calling for..."
safety as the first step in the fight for recognition.
OILC for leadership. right."
But then, the leaders of the EPIU split were supporters Morning Star, whereas the leaders of OIL just want an effective, united organisation in their industry. Trade ucion members - 45%. Noo-trade salon members - 55% Percentage of employees who belleve that the workforce would be more effectively represented by a single indesecial union Percentage of employees who wold consider Joining an indostrial trade union which repreacoted all offsbore wodkers regardi of occupation Percentage of employees who are trade mionists who feel their trade unice adequately represeats its members offsbore 20% By Sleeper The Offshore Industry Liaison Committee (OILC), which organised the unofficial strikes and rig occupations in the North Sea in 1989 and "90, has decided to form itself into a trade union for offshore workers. On this page the OILC Standing Committee explain their actions. Aformaria at the nyone expecting formal announcement of the formation of an Offshore Workers' Union at the Queens Hotel in Brighton on 3 October was to be sadly disappointed.
The OILC had earlier been unofficially briefed on the outcome of a meeting held that morning, chaired by Alex Ferry of the Confederation of Shipbuilding and Licine Total Engineering Unions, which was attended by national of83% ficers of nine unions with interests offshore.
They emerged declaring 62% 71% that the interests of offshore workers were to be placed in the hands of a loose alliance dependently certified, would not have executive control over its constituent members, may at some vague point in the future involve negotiating rights, the constituent unions would carry on much as they have been doing up to now, but would develop a "common strategy . There was to be no formal role for OILC nor any indication of support for the Offshore Information Centre. Dual membership was out.
In short, it had no clear identity as an offshore workers' organisation and was a recipe for the continuation of sectional interests. It was evident to those who would be expected to sell it, that it would be no more relevant to the workforce than the Inter-Union Offshore Oil Committee was!
What was surprising was that this represented a dilution of the proposals which were unanimously endorsed by local, some national officials and lay delegates at the IUOOC meeting at the TUC in Glasgow only four weeks previously. It became obvious that reducing any proposed structure to the level of a sub-committee was necessary in order to coerce the AEU and EETPU to become involved.
No alternative to new union After discussion, the decided that they had no you are bound to be accused to deserting the trade union movement when the reality is that it has deserted you, or at least some of the officials controlling it have.
In place of euphoria there was determination and confidence that, whilst regrettable, the step that was being taken was the correct one in the circumstances, was justifiable and more, it would work!
We cannot be accused of being hasty. More than three years has passed since the Piper Alpha and Ocean Odyssey disasters and in that time the OILC has repeatedly called on the unions to flag up an effective united front to the employers, the oil companies and the workforce. This is has patently failed to do, despite the late, though commendable, efforts of some unions.
By their prevarication throughout the debate, and their hostility to an independent confederation, the AEU A discussion document, Oftshore Industry Liaison Committee and EETPU in have signalled:
(a) that they are happy to continue the sectional divisions of the past;
(b) that they do not place anv importance on the wishes of their offshore members;
(c) that the effective representation of offshore matter which is peripheral to what they regard as the more important matter of union power broking.
This group has ensured that the watered down "confederation" will be stillborn, with no relevance to the majority of workers.
Most people working offshore just want to get on with it. This does not mean, however, that they are unfeeling, unthinking robots. Most could be persuaded of the benefits of trade union representation (many already are), but it is small wonder that many have been disaffected and apathetic when STRIKING OUT!
"Abso JO
----- pull-quotes -----
INSIDE THE UNIPNS
FOR OFFSHORE WORKERS AND THEIR UNIONS
workers, especially in the area of safety, is a minor