Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Who savs I'm invisible?

Socialist Organiser no. 503, 18 October 1991 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 649 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

coup:

"Anastasia will never know the fight/That Grandpa made to keep his dream in reach./But when fullgrown that young girl in sunlight/ Will understand - that Grandpa gave her more,/Much more, than access to a beach."

Fortunately, we will never know what John Betjeman would have done as General Secretary of the Below we print the highlights National Health Service plc Offer for sale 1. Henry Montagu Benson & Sons Limited on bebalf of The Secretary of State for Health lnd pies will fy .. when the Tores fun the NHS adequately .iz Dickinson t was with very personal interest that I read extracts from Germaine Greer's new book "The Change, Women, Ageing and the Menopause". My reactions turned from interest to disbelief to Aççording menopausal and postmenopausal women become invisible. Whether waiting to order a drink, or queueing in the shops they will be ignored.

Futhermore, we are fast approaching being unwanted, undervalued and sexually undesirable. But, Greer says, thought unwanted we will be... FREE!

She intimates that a woman's usefulness, vitality, desirability and her sense of worth vanish along with her menstrual cycle. Even if you retain a sex drive... forget it, because it's unlikely anyone will want to have sex with you.

But don't despair you mature women out there. You will pass into a serene old age, full of wisdom and at one with nature - and you will probably only be fitty!

Greer indulges in sweeping generalisations about menopausal symptoms and their effects ignoring the fact that millions of women have millions of different experiences of the menopause.

She also takes a swipe at women who choose to take Hormone Replacement Therapy to alleviate, what can be, the quite debilitating effects of menopause.

She says we are sick and that we should stick it out as the symptoms might only last two years (!) And, after all, it is only natural. Ms Greer, aren't period pains natural as well? Shouldn't women stop takıng pain killers for those?

A mature student with finals looming, I started taking HRT, because day and night I was literally dripping with sweat from 'hot flushes'. I coldn't sleep. My menopause was early and the symptoms extreme. After discussions with my GP I made an informed choice to take HRT.

If Germaine Greer had been menopausal whilst making her way through college, I doubt she would put forward the same polemic.

She does make some valid points about the drug companies selling HRT.

They would be more valid if she confined her wrath to the system of capitalist production and profit, rather than to the women whose daily lives are made more bearable by the end product.

The male-dominated medical profession also comes under fire. Rightly so.

Many. unnecessary hysterectomies are carried out on women experiencing the onset of menopause.

What women need is information about all the options. We need to be able to discuss the menopause dispelling myths and histrionics, and then make informed choices.

Mature women in their forties have moved on, sometimes painfully, from the Women's Movement of the "70s, Greer's heyday.

We began to realise that our place in society should not be determined by our age, reproductive capacity or sexual attractiveness.

This hasn't been easy for working class women after years of conditioning in an ageist and sexist society. We've fought long and hard to challenge the biological determinism that Greer now seems trapped by.

Finally, Jill Neville in the Independent writes, "Greer acts out her own personal therapy in sky-writing, and makes the megalomaniac error of projecting her own experience onto everybody else."

If Germaine Greer feels invisible and unwanted because she has passed through the menopause, that is sad. She must not assume that we all feel the same. I am not invisible, and neither will you be.

Scan page 7

ITSE

----- pull-quotes -----

John Major's speech on Friday NHS

WOMENYS EMIR

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 503

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →