The everyday reality of poli frame-ups
Socialist Organiser1991 1991-10-18Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
(''Conviction")
Recent months have seen a spectacular series of exposures police frame-ups. The Guildford Four, the Birmingham Six, and Judith Ward are only best-known cases.
On 26 March this year Tony Wellington, a young black prisoner from Birmingham, had his conviction for robbery quashed by the Court of Appeal. Wellingto had been arrested in 1987 and questioned by members of the infamous West Midlands Serious Crime Squad.
After being arrested and charged with bag snatching offences, Wellington made signed confession admitting to those charges. Police officers added a fabricated written admission to a post office robbery. At his trial Wellington maintained that he was innocent of the latte charge but was found guilty and was sentenced to ten years.
At the time of Wellington's appeal, 95 cases of alleged "framing" were currently being investigated from the West Midlands area. Fifteen more cases are to go to appeal in the wake of Wellington's release. The West Midlands Serious Crime Squad was also involved in the Birmingham Six case.
Evidence has been building up dramatically since 1987. In that year, tour men charged with the 1986 Hootys Warehouse robbery were tried at Dudley Crown Court. The defence solicitors proved that a bogus admission statement had been added to the interview notes of one defendant and that a false confession had been attributed to another. The prosecution dropped their case against all four men.
Over the following months the police lost further cases as juries became more reluctant to convict at trials where "confessions" were the sole prosecution evidence. In July 1989 a "framed" black prisoner, Keith Parchment, had a five year sentence for robbery quashed after his solicitor proved that police had contrived evidence against him.
In August 1989 it was announced that the case file of an Irish-born prisoner, Michael Bromell, arrested for "unlawful wounding" in Coventry and convicted some two years previously, had gone "missing" from police custody. A few weeks previously Bromell had written to Police Chief Geoffrey Dear protesting his innocence and claiming that officers had contrived statements against him. Dear had sent for Bromell's papers only to find that they were not available.
He responded by disbanding the whole elite unit of his force. Officers from the Serious Crime Squad were moved to other areas of policing, and West Yorks police began a mammoth it quiry into all cases handled by the Squad since 1986. Some cases of the two previous years were also to be investigated.
The well publicised cases, such as the Birmingham Six. are simply the tip of the iceberg. "Framed" prisoner often serve longer sentences - as they risk losing parole for not expressing remorse for their "crimes" - and get victimised by the prison service for being supposed troublemakers.
Prison can be a hard, brutal experience for any person and the issue of prisoners' rights warrants far more serious attention from socialists and other radicals. Some say that torture does not take place here. Tell that to inmates of Long Lartin prison such as Derek Harry Tredaway or Keith Twitchell, who had plastic bags placed over their heads whilst West Midlands Serious Crime Squad officers forced them to sign prepared "confessions" to armed robberies! Or to Martin Foran who was fitted up by the Squad for robbery offences and denied medical treatment for a severe illness whilst in prison!
Many crimes are "cleared up" by plea bargaining arranged with prisoners already in custody. Some people in police custody get "admissions" forced from them.
There are political reasons for these injustices. The legal system is class biased and elitist. People with little or no money have to make do with solicitors on legal aid rotas, who are rarely enthusiastic and want these trials over with so that they can move on to more financially rewarding work. People with money can seek out more competent solicitors and pay them well.
Once in the courtroom, people find that their background or their lifestyle are on trial as well. Judges have the prejudices associated with their privileged class and their age group.
Take an everyday example: a young man fitted up for assaulting a police officer after the anti-poll tax protests of March 1990.
He was arrested outside Hackney Town Hall during a demo. Some protestors had thrown stones at the police, who then charged the crowd.
He was assaulted by the police, arrested and later framed for assaulting a police officer, and sentenced to a year's imprisonment. The authorities had quite simply decided that any person who had taken part in this protest had placed themselves outside the law. The police want to get a quota of arrests and then arrange a case against those they caught. The message is clear: "stay off the streets or risk jail.
Police malpractice will only be curbed when the issue is taken far more seriously. In the meantime, those prisoners who have been fitted up deserve our active support and solidarity.