Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Party and fight!

Socialist Organiser no. 503, 18 October 1991 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 903 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

The emperor has no principles the Left are the people who are against the leadership. That's not good enough, comrades.

"We have to use the democracy of our party to lead it where we want it to go. We should be having a vibrant discussion. Where is it?

"The Trotskyist entrist project damaged the Left. It was an enormously painjul journey for some of us to deal with it. But Walton did it. I like Dave [Nellist] and Terry (Fields), but we can't treat MPs differently from ordinary members".

She may also have slipped some rat poison in Neil Kinnock's tea at a meeting of the NEC. This and other revelations can be expected the next time Ms Short has an overconvivial lunch with some Edward Pearce or other.

low in fact this poor whole, led a pretty blameless political life Her left credentials amount to what, exactly? Concern with women's rights? But though her opposition to naked women in newspapers may have stung the Sun into calling her Crazy Clare, or something like that. her politics here are strictly in line with her good Catholic upbringing.

What else has Clare Short been "left" on? Ireland? Well, yes, but even on that she has been no red Republican enragé.

True, on certain and at certain meetings Short does not differentiate from an identikit "left" troops-out view. But Robert Maxwell has the same policy Ireland! And for "considered" and formal occasions Clare Short presents herself as against a precipitate British withdrawal *without a political settlement"

Sometimes she sounds a bit like SO - except that for Short this is not something she tries to educate the left about so that it can be more "moderate" face for the establishment.

On not a great deal else can Clare Short base any confession to having been left-wing. She has never been a prominent organiser of the left. I don't think she has ever joined any "faction" less respectable than the Tribune Group.

When this woman W goes around denBouncing herself for her left-wing past, then the Labour Party really is in the grip of witch-hunt hysteria!

Clare Short may even have been reduced to this state by fear, for she is being hounded in her constituency by the EETPU, who are trying to deselect her. In some areas of today's Labour Party, even Clare Short is "too left wing"

Of course, this classic demented old lady performance of Short's would be impossible without the credulous, scared, confused audience provided for her by the Tribune meeting. The reports I have read do not say whether or not others at that meeting, following Short's self-denunciation, got up and denounced themselves, or spoke in tongues before rolling on the floor and frothing at the mouth.

There is now a whole culture in the Labour Party which might be called "witch-hunt left". Tribune editorials express this viewpoint. Tribune is in favour of driving Militant out of the Labour Party. With impeccable schoolbook logic -and on one level, irrefutably - Tribune says that Militant cannot stand against Labour and be in the Party. With great democratic rectitude it insists that the MPs Nellist and Fields should get no special treatment; and it seems quite incapable of putting these things in the context of what is going on in the They seem incapable, too, of grasping the imperious authoritarian logic that will work itself through in the sort of one-faction Labour Party they are now in fact supporting. Clare Short may denounce the left and her own half-imaginary past: but what if the EETPU is not placated?

What happens if, under a new Labour government, Tribune finds something intolerable and protests OI, heaven forbid, organises against it? Some Clare Short — or perhaps this Clare Short will denounce them for Kinnock's panel of 'left-wing" witch-finders: Margaret Beckett, David Blunkett and Clare Short factionalism and for their "contempt for Labour Party democracy", increasingly defined as rule by an authoritarian machine in the name of a passive and mediamanipulated "majority".

Stomance should burt hort's ridiculous perall those in Labour's "centre left" who are concerned for the well-being of the Labour Party, and for its spiritual and mental health.

They should look to themselves, and to the witch-hunting culture they have allowed to grow up in the former left of the Labour Party. That is where Clare Short is coming from (and, also, going from!)

Defeats - most of them avoidable defeats - have produced the present mood on the Labour left, in which nothing matters but getting the Tories out. This left quietly allows Kinnockites like Clare Short to blame the defeats on those who attempted to make Labour a fitting instrument for working-class struggle, when the blame lies squarely with the right wing and with former left-wingers like Kinnock who have less fight in them, and less anti-Tory fire in their minds and in their bellies than even a Paddy Ashdown has.

The serious left will treat the Shorts and the other Tribunite witch-hunters with the contempt they deserve. When they have exhausted their usefulness so too, probably, will the right.

Scan page 6

God's little angels saving us from barbarism... Socialist Organiser No. 503 page 6 A classic pii serious popular lumalismi BRITISH FRISE ANNAROS Mirror: MAILY SCARGILL AND THE C -START MONEY L TE FACTS

----- pull-quotes -----

N misguided, confused woman has, on the

effective against the establishment; it is her

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 503

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →