Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The grey Danube

Socialist Organiser no. 503, 18 October 1991 · scan pp. 4–5 · John Cunningham · about 1,651 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

The Danube is no longer blue as in the Strauss waltz, more the colour of wet concrete nowadays, but it is still the most important waterway in Central and Eastern Europe. Through its 2,842 km journey to the Black Sea, the Danube joins East and West, demarcates lands which have known centuries of territorial dispute and, as the enormous barges passing through Budapest's bridges attest, is a major commerIt is also more. For centuries, the aspirations for peace, in an area of the world seemingly perpetually inclined to war, were often centred on the river. The Hungarian poet Ady once described the Danube lands as a "pillory made for halving people and halving nations" . Another Hungarian poet, Dezso Kosztolanyi said in the early 20s, "Not even the Ganges is as sacred as the Danube"

The Danube, often the signifier of national difference and territorial delineation is also ambiguously and at the same time a unifier. The revolutionaries of 1848, for example, planned a new state which would have included much of present day Croatia, Hungary, Serbia, Moldavia and Wallachia. They were ruthlessly crushed by the Habsburg and Tsarist armies, but their land was to be called the Danubian United States and the Danube was to be its heart and artery.

Although attempts were made to resurrect this idea after the First World War, the victorious powers were content to reaffirm the 1859 Congress of Paris which declared the principle of free navigation along the Danube. The Belgrade Agreement in 1948 maintained this principle, but precious little was done to use the Danube as anything other than a commercial trade route.

The proposal then to divert part of the Danube and build a hydro-electricity plant at BosGabcikovo - the Nagymaros River Barrage System (GNRBS) — thus met with a certain degree of approval. It was, after all, commercial exploitation of the river, something which had been going on for centuries. The outrage at the proposals, a joint Austrian-Hungarian-Czechoslovakian projeet, from all over Central Europe testify and demonstrate the other side of the equation. The plan was regarded as little more than the rape and destruction of the soul of Central Europe. Posters and banners appeared in Hungary with I love the Duna' (the Hungarian name for the Danube). Green activists, environmentalists and many thousands of ordinary people took to the streets in The scheme in its essentials represents the worst kind of centralised state planning and plain ignorance, this time backed by Austrian technology and large amounts of Schillings. It has two main components: the first being to divert the river some 30 km into Czech territory, with the old course of the river maintained, but at a greatly reduced level. Second, the diversion is intended to feed into a barrage at Bos-Gabcikovo where a huge hydroEnvironmentally, the scheme is almost universally regarded as a total disaster. Diverting the stream of the river will play havoc with the water table over a vast area. The by-pass canal is elevated some 20m above the land-level in an area of known Key areas such as certain forest and wetlands would be lost due to the lowering of the water table, large areas of agricultural land would be lost, fishing destroyed and long established communities divided or simply gone forever.

Not surprisingly, opposition has been strong. Nor has it been a particularly fortuitous time for such projects. Many people, from all walks of life, are increasingly wary of the kind of major tampering with nature involved in such schemes. Dreamed up in the mid-70s by planners from the Czech and Hungarian governments, the political changes in those two countries have also cast a great shadow of doubt over its continuance.

In Hungary especially, the new government of Josef Antall decided to pull out. The Austrians, after making sure that their construction companies were amply compensated, also pulled out. Only the Czech and Slovak government now appears interested in carrying on with this monster -even though the scheme will meet only 2% of the for socialists in the Labour Party after the Brighton conference abour Party conference was a pre-election event. This is the stage at which the leadership is at its most powerful, and the left is isolated.

There are also some cial thoroughfare. unusual circumstances this year. The events in the USSk have led to a general attack on socialist ideas.

The adoption of onemember-one-vote, first for parliamentary selections, and now for internal party elections is not in itself a bad thing. But voting taken without political discussion becomes a plaything of the media.

And the establishment of "policy commissions" will make it difficult to challenge the National Executive Committee. Presumably the conference will be invited to vote O'Mahony row can you tell when a turned into a witchhunt, and the witch-hunt has taken on a momentum of its own?

That was easy back in the days when witches were people accused of doing evil things with the Devil and on the Devil's behalf, as distinct from the Labour Party now, where people are hunted for politics which the men in suits who run the party consider diabolical.

The witchfinders would seek out witches, make acPrague, Budapest and Vienna. cusations, have people immersed in water to see if the Devil came and saved them. (If they drowned, that proved that they were innocent of all devilish protection). Maybe electricity plant is to be built.

seismic instability! country's energy needs. wing they dumped her for or against NECrecommended policy, with no opportunity to amend documents. This year's consultation on the future of party conference is designed to lead to the abolition of party conference and its replacement by a rally.

The witch-hunt has already gone a long way. Militant supporters have been hounded. Dave Nellist and Terry Fields have been treated very badly, and banned from party conference without right of reply.

Now Labour groups in local government are being given the automatic support of the National Executive every time they make an attack on their own population. In Lambeth the defiant Labour group said it was acting on policy of the local party. It was threatened with suspension.

This all has a detrimental effect on recruiting people to the party. For instance, there is now the smallest number of under-25 year olds in the party for 40 years.

Some people are leaving the Labour Party - but this some witches would be condemned to be burned or hanged. Whisperings and accusations would become common.

The Devil and his agents could be anywhere, and were known to be everywhere. Ar appearance of being the vers opposite of what people thought the Devil was, wa: itself cause for suspicion.

People whom you did not like, or were in conflict with were especially likely te arouse your suspicion. Ap parently innocent acts had tc be looked at afresh with the fearful knowledge uppermos in the mind.

Wasn't that old womar seen near a cow that late: died unexpectedly? Ther you are! The hysteria an fear would build up and up.

And then would come th transformation. Peopl what they is a terrible mistake. People should stay in the Labour Party. This party was set up as the political voice of the trade unions and working class as a whole. To leave the party because of a particular authoritarian trend is to give in. It is exactly what the right wants. My message is: do not leave, stay and fight!

Outside the Labour Party is the wilderness. Look at the experience of the ILP split from the Labour Party in the 1930s. The ILP was virtually obliterated.

The left can still win victories. We beat the Labour leadership at conference on arms cuts.

And we must recognise that the party reflects what happens in society generally. There is no easy way out, but my feeling is that we have passed the worst times. Although there is some holding back on the industrial front prior to the election, I think that after the election we will be in an entirely new situation.

A future Labour government will meet trade union action. Will Labour really be would get up in church and level fantastic accusations of lewd and malevolent dealings with the Devil, of having gone for midnight rides on the Devil's spikey tail, of having cast diabolical spells on people who had recently died - at whom? At themselves!

Women and men, driven out of their wits by fear and hysteria, and terrorised into identifying completely with their witch-hunting oppressors, would get up and Massachusetts, fessing young women. then able to say we will not make a pension increase because we need another Trident submarine?

The events in Eastern Europe do not mean that socialism has failed. The party played an elitist role and became a passport to privilege. The Soviet state was a highly centralised authoritarian state. We now see an explosion caused by all sorts of different pressures.

70 years of Russian domination over the Soviet nationalities is leading to break-up. People are demanding better living standards.

The problem which the people in the USSR will have working class living standards. The people who were demonstrating for pluralism and democracy were not demonstrating for lower living standards, but that is what will come.

Socialism is not dead. It will continue to live because capitalism cannot provide for working class people.

Jeremy Corbyn was talking to Martin Thomas. accusation is the real take-off point for a full-blown witchhunt.

Clare Short's performWing Labour Party conference strongly suggests that this stage has now been reached in the Labour Party.

Short got up in church in Brighton - that is, at the Tribune fringe meeting -and denounced herself and will quarrels and attacks on the reported Clare Short as Labour

Scan page 5

cialist Organiser No. 503 page

----- pull-quotes -----

to face up to is that capitalism means attacks on

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 503

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →